This movie has concepts from Chapters 5.
Next,
write your comment. Your comment does not need to provide an overview of the
movie (we have all seen it). Your comment should be an in-depth analysis
of one or more principles from your text. You should use scenes and characters
to provide examples of textbook concepts. Your comment should reflect that you
are in an upper division, university level Motivation and Emotion course and
clearly link elements from the movie to the textbook. This is a
comprehensive assignment (linking course lectures, textbook, and the movie) and
you cannot do that in just a few short paragraphs. 500 words!
BE
SPECIFIC. At the bottom of your comment, please put a list of the ME terms you
used.
Throughout the movie, Malcolm is presented with a series of different situations that lead him to be extrinsically motivated. These events were all fueled by his dream to get into Harvard which was his intrinsic motivation.
It all starts when his normal path home is blocked and he has to take a different route that leads him to Dom. It is in that moment that his journey to getting into Harvard becomes a little more complicated. When he goes to his Harvard interview is when all of his extrinsic motivation truly begins. He was told by the interviewer that he must sell all the cocaine or kiss his dreams of a good recommendation goodbye. The drive to sell the cocaine becomes an extrinsic motivation because of the fact that he is doing in order to receive the reward that comes from it. In the end, he does complete this task regardless of the obstacles he overcomes. He even takes the extra step to insure he gets a good recommendation by blackmailing the man who made him do it in the first place. Analyzing the scene where Malcolm tells AJ he can help him get into Harvard or face the consequences of being caught for selling the drugs serves as a link to the concept of a punisher. AJ can either choose to help Malcolm or face the consequences of jail time that will more than likely follow. The same can be said for Malcolm when he is first told by AJ that he must first sell all the drugs before he will help him get into Harvard. Malcolm had to make the decision to sell the drugs or deal with the consequences of not getting into Harvard and maybe even having harm done to his friends and family.
Malcolm’s one goal is to get into Harvard and he does all the necessary things to make sure this goal happens. He has always wanted to get into Harvard so he got good grades and stayed out of trouble. Coming from the area that he did there was many things that could have deterred him from this goal. In the end of the movie you see Malcolm has received a letter from Harvard. The closing scene is his face with a look of satisfaction. One can infer from this that he did in fact get into Harvard after all the things he went through. His intrinsic motivation finally led to a feeling of autonomy. Another need associated with intrinsic motivation is the support from one’s relationships. Malcolm definitely received this from his two best friends. Although they too were put in danger by the whole ordeal they stuck by his side, most times, and helped him get all the drugs sold in order to help him meet his dream of going to Harvard. After all the happened, I am sure they will have all learned to avoid that area and that they should continue being good and staying out of trouble like they have done for so long.
Terms:
Intrinsic motivation
Extrinsic motivation
Reward
Goal
Autonomy
Punisher
Chapter five primarily discusses intrinsic and extrinsic motivations. In the movie, Malcolm is experiencing many kinds of both. Intrinsic motivations are motivations that are based on an individual’s needs or wants. This type of motivation is important because it can cause a person to become persistent and creative. It can also improve learning abilities. Malcolm has many intrinsic motivations: Starting at the beginning of the movie, Malcolm wants to do his best in school to improve his chances of getting into Harvard. He wants to listen to 90’s music and study with his friends. After Malcolm meets Dom, his intrinsic motivation is wanting to talk with Nakia. He relays messages from Dom (which is the first example of extrinsic motivation, too) because he wanted to talk to her and ask her to the prom. Extrinsic motivations are rewards, consequences, or incentives from an outside person or environment. This situation is also extrinsic motivation because Dom is a threatening character, and Malcolm does not want to upset him. The specific consequence of Malcolm not being their messenger would scare him enough to motivate him to listen anyway.
After Malcolm hears about the birthday party, he has intrinsic motivation to go because, again, he wants to talk to Nakia. At the party, extrinsic motivation causes Malcolm and his friends to run from the situation. The police came in trying to bust Dom and his drug dealers. This again was a good example of a negative consequence. If Malcolm were to get caught with the drugs (or just being at the party underage) the law would get involved. Knowing this, he ran. Malcolm’s friends also served as reinforcers throughout the movie because they have similar goals and push each other to start selling the drugs. The selling of the drugs can be seen as both intrinsic and extrinsic because they did it for personal gain and because they were scared of getting caught by Dom or any of the other dealers. They wanted to get rid of the excess drugs. The reward (money from people purchasing the drugs) from selling the drugs was enough to keep the group motivated. At this point, the reward outweighed the risk in their opinion. The end of the movie brings out an interesting idea; Malcolm brought a bag to his reference to Harvard. He talks about the man’s bank account and illegal activity. He also threatened to frame him. This is evidence for the idea that Malcolm’s actions were all due to intrinsic motivation because he wanted to get into Harvard.
Another point that is made in the text that relates to the movie is how to build interest in an undesired activity. This portion of the book almost perfectly describes how an intelligent teenager wanting to get into Harvard would start selling drugs. The characteristics of the environment caused Malcolm to be around drug dealers more. In addition, the characteristics of the person changed Malcolm into a stronger-willed person. As he sells drugs and gets further involved, he gets mad at Nakia. In the end, Malcolm brought the motivation full-circle by showing that his goal was to get to Harvard all along.
Terms: Intrinsic Motivation, Extrinsic Motivation, Reward, Negative Consequence, Building Interest, Goal
Dope, from a thematic perspective, is a film about overcoming odds that are perpetually stacked against you. The main character, Malcolm, is a young high schooler who just wishes to get into his dream school, Harvard. However, to achieve that goal, he must dredge through haphazard drug deals, Bitcoin sales, a corrupt businessman, and unrequited love. Fortunately, Malcolm does ultimately achieve his goal in the end after returning home to find an envelope from Harvard laying on his bed.
From a psychological perspective, this movie is a perfect example of the battle of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. Malcolm, as the focus of the movie, is the character in which this battle takes place. Malcolm is already a perfectly intrinsically motivated student. He sees his school choice as a perfectly autonomous (free) choice. Wherever he wants to go, he can go. Malcolm also believes that he is competent enough for the Ivy League, as he has his eyes set on Harvard University. In doing this, he also feels he fits in with (relatedness) his only two true friends, Diggy and Jib. As the school’s “geeks,” they are constantly picked on for being different. They strive to achieve beyond high school and enjoy “White Shit.” Because of this, they are ridiculed by their immediate peers, but fortunately have each other as social support. These three factors combine into the origin of Malcolm’s own psychological need of academic achievement, that intrinsically motivates him to pursue an education at Harvard.
Malcolm’s counselor further reinforces and supports Malcolm’s behavior. As a good counselor, he understands that Malcolm wants the achievement that so few in “The Bottoms” desire. He, therefore, provides the support necessary to encourage the autonomy, competence, and relatedness that Malcolm’s intrinsic motivation requires. However, Malcolm is a bit lacking in this area, as he believes that Harvard will accept him purely based on academic achievement. Therefore, the counselor provides a positive incentive to Malcolm: Go get an interview with Austin Jacoby or you can say goodbye to your dreams of Harvard. This acts as a positive incentive for Malcolm because it attracts him (approach-oriented) to the action of going to see Mr. Jacoby, but it does not directly cause him to immediately start the course of action. What this incentive does is it plants the expectation within Malcolm’s head that if he does go see Mr. Jacoby, his chances of seeing himself at Harvard increases significantly.
The battle that I alluded to in the second paragraph begins when bad influences begin to seep into Malcolm’s life. They all provide extrinsic motivation in one form or another, but all wish to gain compliance and control over Malcolm, not the starkly contrasted positive influence that his counselor provided.
As an example, Austin Jacoby, the man Malcolm once believed was what he was destined to be. A man raised from the slums to the throne of success on the back of his hard work and study at Harvard. However, Mr. Jacoby was also revealed to be a drug dealer, and is as corrupt as the day is long. Upon finding out that Mr. Jacoby is the “AJ” that Dom said to go find, Malcolm informs him that he has the drugs that Dom was supposed to acquire. Mr. Jacoby, wanting nothing to do with the already heated and heinous crime, provides reinforcement to get Malcolm to comply with finishing the deal for Jacoby.
Now, this is where it becomes a bit hazy for me. I could honestly see this reinforcement as coming from both positive and negative aspects. It could be positive reinforcement, “If you sell these drugs for me, then I will give you a recommendation from Harvard.” He could be motivating Malcolm by inserting the valued recommendation to Harvard into Malcolm’s environment. This would increase the likelihood of Malcolm’s drug-selling behavior. However, it could also be negative reinforcement, “If you don’t sell these drugs, I will not recommend you to Harvard.” According to Malcolm’s counselor, without that recommendation Harvard is as good as gone. So, this could be taken as Jacoby taking away the Harvard future, removing a stimulus to increase Malcolm’s drug-selling behavior. And some may argue that this is more of a punishment than a negative reinforcer, however the book defines that negative reinforcement encourages escape/avoidance behaviors while punishment purely decreases undesired behavior. Malcolm has not performed the drug-selling behavior yet, and he wishes to avoid the future without Harvard, so he would be more likely to sell the drugs to avoid a Harvard-less future.
Finally, in the end, Malcolm turns the situation around on Mr. Jacoby, the main influencer of the film. After selling the drugs, Malcolm ensures that the money could be traced back to Mr. Jacoby. Mr. Jacoby again utilizes reinforcement, this time I am confident that it is negative. Mr. Jacoby wishes to increase the behavior of not-tracing the money to him. So, he threatens Malcolm (The line: “You know what a man like me can do to a boy like you.”). He introduces a future stimulus (pain/beating/possibly death (?)) into Malcolm’s environment that Malcolm will want to avoid. However, Malcolm is prepared to face Jacoby’s reinforcement and assures Jacoby that the shoe is on the other foot. He points out that, since they both come from questionable backgrounds in “The Bottom,” the DEA would not be as forgiving of anyone involved, be they poor high school student or Harvard business (secret drug kingpin) millionaire. Malcolm wishes to increase the likelihood of Jacoby’s recommendation behavior, as Jacoby will want to avoid the future where he may lose everything he’d achieved and wind up in prison. This clearly works as demonstrated by the Harvard letter sitting on Malcolm’s bed at the end of the film.
Terms Used:
Intrinsic Motivation – Pg. 111
Autonomy – Pg. 111
Competence – Pg. 111
Relatedness – Pg. 111
Origins of Intrinsic Motivation – Pg. 112
Extrinsic Motivation – Pg. 113
Incentives (Positive) – Pg. 114
Positive Reinforcement – Pg. 117
Negative Reinforcement – Pg. 118
Punishment – Pg. 118
Chapter 5 in the text book talks about the kinds of motivation people have, extrinsic and intrinsic motivation, along with rewards and punishment as motivators as well. The movie Dope had many good examples of those motivators. Malcolm, a nerdy black kid from a rough neighborhood, wants to get into Harvard. Getting into Harvard is his goal, so he has to make sure he can reach. Malcolm has all A’s, was involved in the science club, is in a band, and is involved in many other extracurricular activities to ensure that he would have a diverse application, these are all intrinsic motivators. This means purely the good feeling of accomplishing these things that will help him get into Harvard motivates him. Along the way, he accidentally gets involved in a drug bust, and ends up receiving a bunch of molly. Malcolm realizes he has two options, turn the drugs over to the cops and risk getting killed by the supplier for giving up his drugs, or selling the drugs himself and run the risk of getting caught. He weighs out the pros and cons of each and decides on the option that wont get his mother, friends or himself killed.
Malcolm decides on selling the drugs and run the risk of getting caught because that option is better than getting killed. He is extrinsically motivated because the motivation arises from environmental incentives and consequences. While the whole drug situation is going on, Malcolm meets Nakia, a girl trying to get her GED. Malcolm offers to help her study, with the hopes that he can ask her out and take her to his prom. This is an extrinsic motivator with incentive.
Malcolm and his friend Jeb are both intrinsically motivated to go to college and get good jobs to help support their mothers. Malcolm’s situation is more pressing than Jeb’s though, because Malcolm is trying to get into an Ivy League school. At the end of the movie, Malcolm is rewriting his admission essay and implies that if he were white, the admissions would not be asking him why he wants to go to Harvard. Throughout the movie he has implied that when people see him and hear what neighbor hood he is from, they assume he is involved with gangs and the drug dealers. His wanting to go to Harvard and getting accepted is intrinsic motivation to prove to people that a black kid from a rough neighborhood can get good grades and go to an Ivy League school.
Reward and punishment play a big part in this movie. There is the reward of getting accepted into Harvard, getting the girl, and not getting caught, even when there were some close calls. Though it wasn’t stated in the movie, I am assuming that Malcolm was accepted into Harvard. All of his hard work studying and getting good grades had paid off. In the end, Nakia passed her GED test and invites Malcolm to come to six flags with her. The final reward of this movie was that Malcolm and his friends did not get caught selling the drugs. There were a lot of threats of punishment in the movie. The biggest punishment was getting caught with the drugs and getting arrested and going to jail, and in that process, losing Harvard. There was also the threat of his loved ones being killed if he didn’t do as he was told.
Terms: extrinsically motivated, intrinsic motivation, reward, punishment, goal
Chapter 5 had a lot of information, and most of it was regarding intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation is an act of interest in something, and is done, “for fun”, while extrinsic motivation is more of a “do this and get that” form of motivation. The movie shows both forms of these motivations throughout it. Malcolm is the main character of this film and he shows intrinsic motivation frequently in the beginning. Intrinsic motivation is a psychological need satisfaction and can stem from autonomy, competence, and relatedness. This is first shown by his desire to get into Harvard. Malcolm is a straight A student, but his personality steers others from believing he could get into his dream school. Malcolm still believes that he is Harvard quality and this demonstrates autonomy in his life. Autonomy is the need to control ones life, and this can explain why Malcolm wanted to get into Harvard after being told he wouldn’t be able to. If a person has a lot of intrinsic motivation they’re likely to have more persistence. Malcolm showed persistence through this film, and this was shown at the end of the movie when he opens up a letter from Harvard and smiles. The whole movie is a process that Malcolm goes through to achieve his goal, and it is accomplished through different motivations. Malcolm shows other ways that he is intrinsically motivated by the extracurricular activities he participates in to make his resume look better for when he applies to Harvard. Relatedness in these terms are the need or desire to have close, affectionate relationships with others. The desire Malcolm has for getting closer with Nakia can be explained through his psychological need for relatedness. Extrinsic motivation was also shown with Malcolm towards Nakia. She is studying for her GED, and Malcolm offers to help. He uses this as a way to ask her to prom, and she says yes. Extrinsic motivation was also shown other various times throughout the film as well. As stated earlier, Malcolm had people in his life who did not believe that he would make it into Harvard based off of grades only. Extrinsic motivation was demonstrated when Malcolm’s guidance counselor told him to get an interview with Austin Jacoby. Malcolm doing this showed a “do this and get that” form of motivation. Malcolm was told by Jacoby that he could would be able to get into Harvard if he sold drugs. Malcolm feels that he has no other option and decide to ask help from a stoner and hacker that he had met at band camp years ago. This kid helps them organize an online network for selling drugs without it getting traced back to them. Malcolm is showing extrinsic motivation, because he is only doing this because it is an incentive for him to get into Harvard. Overall this motive had many examples from chapter 5, and it was easy to relate scenes that showed intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. I think that all movies will generally show some form of these motivations, because motivation is what drives us to do anything.
Terms:
extrinsic motivation
intrinsic motivation
autonomy
persistence
motivations
The main character of the movie Dope is Malcolm. Malcolm is presented with both intrinsic motivation and extrinsic motivation throughout the movie, which is what chapter 5 primarily discussed. Malcolm expressed intrinsic motivation with his desire to go to Harvard for college. He expressed extrinsic motivation soon after his interview for Harvard, when he gets involved in complicated situations such as drug deals with dangerous people.
Malcolm shows intrinsic motivation with his school behaviors. He has a desire and interest to exercise his capacities and master challenges of education, which is the result of his intrinsic motivation. He expresses a psychological need within himself to excel in his education and to attend a very prestigious college. When Malcolm is getting his education and learning, he experiences autonomy and competence. He is good at school and feels competent and intelligent when he is learning. He feels relatedness to his friends, who are seen as “nerds” and also wants to feel relatedness with other people who share his interest in education, such as people at Harvard. These feelings are what drives his intrinsic motivation. Since Malcolm is intrinsically motivated to learn, he is getting a better quality of understanding and learning from his education because he is motivated to gain mastery over the subjects, as compared to extrinsic which focuses on the reward of learning the subjects.
Malcolm also experiences extrinsic motivation throughout the movie with the dangerous choices he makes. In the movie, Malcolm meets a character named Dom who is very dangerous. Since extrinsic motivations are influenced by incentives and consequences, he is extrinsically motivated to follow Dom’s directions to avoid the negative consequences. He is also extrinsically motivated to do as Dom says because when he relays Dom’s messages, he gets a chance to see a girl that he is attracted to. This is a reward/incentive that motivates Malcolm to perform certain behaviors that are dangerous. In the movie, Malcolm also is extrinsically motivated in the situation of his Harvard interview and the drug deal. In order to receive the outcome/reward of Harvard, Malcolm must perform a drug deal between his interviewer, AJ, and Dom. If he does not perform the drug deal, AJ will make sure he does not get accepted into Harvard. He performs this behavior because he is motivated by the reward/incentive, which is Harvard. Without this incentive, he would not be behaving in the way that he does.
Extrinsic motivation is also present in another character besides Malcolm, and that is AJ. After the drug deal, Malcolm introduces a punisher to AJ. If AJ does not give Malcolm a good recommendation, then Malcolm has ensured that AJ can be found guilty for the drug deal by tracing the money back. This is an example of a punisher because the scene includes an environmental stimulus that decreases the future probability of the undesired behavior. The undesired behavior is no recommendation from AJ, and the probability of this undesired behavior is decreased when the blackmail (environmental stimulus) is presented to AJ.
Terms:
Intrinsic motivation
Extrinsic motivation
Psychological need
Autonomy
Competence
Relatedness
Incentives
Consequences
Reward
Punisher
There are two contrasting ideas that arise from the movie Dope. One comes from A.J. when he tells Malcolm in their first meeting, “You always have a choice.” The second actually comes from the actor who plays Jig in one of the bonus features. In discussion of the situation that the three geeks find themselves in, he says, “They become a product of their environment.” Now the question is, which is true? Are humans a product of their environment or do we always have a choice?
The answer to this question comes back to intrinsic versus extrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation, being the motives within ourselves, aligns with always having a choice. It’s behavior that stems from interest and the need to overcome challenge. Extrinsic motivation, the motives from our environment, obviously aligns with Jig’s statement. It’s behavior that stems from environmental incentives and consequences. As the textbook discusses and Dope demonstrates, environmental events can be incredibly influential.
An example of the environment’s power is the scene where the gang, the Bloods, jump Malcolm, Jig, and Diggy as they were heading home with the bag full of cash. One of the Bloods opened the bag and saw all the cash, seemingly ready to leave with it. This would have left Malcolm in a difficult situation, potentially one that could ruin his chance of getting into college, which would probably be the least of his problems if he returned to A.J. without the money. Knowing this potentially consequences of losing the money, Malcolm pulled out the gun Dom had put in his backpack and pointed it at the Bloods. Malcolm’s incentive to pull out the gun was money, amongst other things. An incentive is an attracting or repulsive environmental event that precedes action. Incentives are also learned through experience. Malcolm, having grown up in gang-filled neighborhood, learned that the presence of a gun can provide a person control over other’s actions.
The same scene presents another example of extrinsic motivation. The Blood who picked up the bag of money had a gun pointed at him. For this Blood, the gun, a threat to his life, became an incentive to leave the money with Malcolm. The Blood had learned through experience that if you do not do what the person with the gun wants, you risk death. If you do what the person with the gun wants, you live. The consequence changes based on the behavior. Fortunately, the Blood left the money with Malcolm and ran away. Without the environmental influence (the gun), the Blood would have behaved differently (likely taken the money). In this sense, perhaps Jig is right; humans may be a product of their environment.
Even though the environment can convince us to act in ways we normally wouldn’t, I don’t think that necessarily means we don’t any choice. Malcolm still had a choice: to pull out the gun or not. The Blood still had a choice: to take the money or leave it. In this sense, A.J. is right; we always have a choice. I think the movie and text would concur that choice is always available, that intrinsic and extrinsic motivation are often working together, and that environmental influences can make one option seem like the only valid option to make in a given moment. I can’t help but wonder, if the Blood tried to leave with the money, would Malcolm be totally overcome by extrinsic motivation to get the money and pulled the trigger? Would he remain caught in between who he is and how he is perceived? Would he become defined by his zip code, his environment, or would he become defined by who he is as a person?
Terms: intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation, incentives, consequences
In the movie Dope, it is made apparent that Malcolm is both highly intrinsically and extrinsically motivated. The primary intrinsic motivator is Malcolm’s desire to be more than what everyone in “The Bottoms” expects him to be. Malcolm possesses a dream of going to Harvard rather than just one of the local colleges. Malcolm also possesses intrinsic motivation when it comes to his own creativity and personality. By this I mean Malcolm takes pride in listening to 90’s rap music and modeling his own fashion sense and musical creativity after the hip hop moguls of the era. Malcolm showcases persistence, creativity, conceptual understanding, and improved well-being when he is pursuing the things that intrinsically motivate him. Extrinsic motivators really move the plot along however, and as we see in the film, the benefits of Malcolm’s intrinsic motivations are hindered by the strong extrinsic motivators he encounters.
Of course, the main extrinsic motivator in the film is Austin Jacoby. A.J. is a successful man that supposedly gained his good fortune on his own merit via studying at Harvard. As Malcolm finds out at his thought to be college interview however, A.J. is also a very corrupt drug dealer. A.J. provides Malcolm with both positive and negative reinforcement in order to get him to sell the drugs. Mr. Jacoby tells Malcolm that if he sells the drugs for him then he will grant Malcolm a recommendation to Harvard. Then on the flip side, if Malcolm doesn’t sell the drugs he won’t receive the recommendation and will likely be harmed and potentially even killed. The threat of harm and losing the recommendation serve as aversive stimuli. In order for Malcolm to avoid these aversive stimuli he takes proactive action by setting up his Bitcoin drug dealing system. He is extrinsically motivated to both receive his letter of recommendation and avoid potential death. Of course the death threat is also a punisher, as it is decreasing the likelihood of Malcolm not selling the drugs for A.J. Essentially, Malcolm is faced with this dilemma, he may either engage in the undesirable behavior (not selling Mr. Jacoby’s drugs) and suffer the aversive consequence (potential death) or perform the undesired behavior (sell the drugs) and avoid the aversive consequence while obtaining the recommendation to Harvard which served as an incentive for Malcolm.
After Malcolm traverses the treacherous waters of selling drugs in “The Bottoms” and arrives back to Mr. Jacoby, he expects to be given his letter and be on his way. Mr. Jacoby however is still skeptical about whether or not the money made by Malcolm will be traced back to him due to Malcolm deciding to use Bitcoin. Mr. Jacoby threatens Malcolm’s life and provides even more negative reinforcement. Malcolm counters Jacoby’s threat by pointing out that although the two of them are on different levels socioeconomically, they are still both from “The Bottoms” and are the DEA is sure to be suspicious of anyone involved. Malcolm counters Jacoby’s negative reinforcement with some negative reinforcement of his own. This being because Malcolm is looking to increase the likelihood of Jacoby giving Malcolm a recommendation to Harvard by providing the aversive stimuli of being investigated and potentially imprisoned by the DEA. I see this as a proper showing of karma. Luckily for Malcolm, Mr. Jacoby keeps his promise of granting Malcolm a letter of recommendation as the Harvard letter patiently awaits Malcolm on his bed at the conclusion of the film.
Terms Used:
- Intrinsic Motivation
- Extrinsic Motivation
- Punishment
- Incentive
- Aversive Stimuli
- Positive Reinforcement
- Negative Reinforcement
This movie shows a lot of extrinsic motivation and some intrinsic motivation. The intrinsic motivation includes Malcom’s strive to get accepted into Harvard University and talking to Nakia. Malcom making following through with Dom’s requests could also be intrinsic motivation because he does not want to get caught having the drugs on him because that could potentially jeopardize his academic career. This example could be seen as extrinsic motivation because if Malcom gets rid of the drugs, he will get AJ to write him a recommendation to his dream school. Malcom is positively reinforced by his friends because they encourage him to continue behaviors so that they can tag along. One example of this in the movie that stuck out to me was when they want to go to the party. An example of negative reinforcement would be throughout the movie as Malcom is getting rid of the drugs. His behavior is increasing by being encouraged to continue to get rid of the drugs while avoiding getting caught with drugs before he sells them. A punisher in the film could be Dom’s party. Malcom is probably less likely to go to a party now because the last party he went to, he got roped into this situation. The money that Malcom made through all of this can definitely been seen as an expected reward for his behavior. AJ was also extrinsically motivated in the movie by Malcom threatening to frame him unless he wrote a good recommendation letter.
Malcom is a very good student, which leads me to believe that he is intrinsically motivated to learn. This means Malcom has conceptual understanding and values high-quality learning rather than just memorizing the information given to him. Throughout the movie, we see Malcom’s persistence in trying to get rid of the drugs for his Harvard recommendation. My favorite example of Malcom’s persistence is when he gets in the fight with the bully. Malcom struggles and begins to lose in the fight, but his persistence made him keep trying. Once he lost the physical fight, he became creative with his resources by pulling out the gun to make the bully respect him. Malcom was extrinsically motivated to win against the bully because he wanted to keep his money. When Malcom gets to keep his bag after the fight, he feels competent. Malcom’s relationship with his friends shows relatedness because they support his drug selling and other behaviors so they can tag along. At the end of the movie, Malcom feels free in the fact that he got rid of the drugs and he got his recommendation letter to Harvard, which was his goal throughout the entire movie. Since Malcom has autonomy, relatedness, and competence, he has reached his optimal functioning and well-being. To describe this film by using the three-term model (S: R C), we can say that the situational cue (S) was Malcom getting the drugs placed in his possession. This set up the occasion for Malcom’s behavioral response of getting rid of the drugs the way Dom wanted him to, rather than turning in the drugs to the police. Malcom made the decision to obey Dom showing that the situational cue does not cause the behavioral cue. However, getting rid of the drugs Dom’s way led to a positive consequence for Malcom since he got the letter of recommendation that he wanted so bad. His behavioral response led to this consequence.
Terms:
Extrinsic motivation, intrinsic motivation, positive reinforcement, negative reinforcement, punisher, reward, conceptual understanding, competent, persistence, relatedness, goal, autonomy, optimal functioning and well-being, three term model, situational cue, behavioral response, consequence
Throughout the movie, Malcolm was motivated both intrinsically and extrinsically. Intrinsic motivation comes from personal wants and needs and Malcolm very badly wanted to be able to attend Harvard. He was intrinsically motivated in school as he had very good grades and was under the impression that he did well enough in school and was competent enough that he would have his choice of schools. Throughout the movie, Malcolm’s intrinsic motivation was continually challenged by extrinsic motivations that were trying to get in the way of his one original goal of getting into Harvard.
There is a section in the chapter explaining extrinsic motivation to be an attempt for someone to manipulate another person's behavior. I believe that both Dom and AJ were trying to manipulate Malcolm and this lead to the position that Malcolm had to try to find his way out of. (Selling the drugs) The external motivation began to escalate when Dom was able to sneak the molly into Malcolm’s backpack and then was able to use him as a drug dealer. Malcolm was extrinsically motivated to do what Dom told him because Dom stated that “AJ could kill him.” Shortly after, when Malcolm was able to get in touch and meet AJ, he was extrinsically motivated to sell the drugs for AJ or he would not get as good letter of recommendation to Harvard as Malcolm had found out the AJ was the person he was to be meeting for the alumni meeting. Malcolm had to determine whether or not the reward of selling the drugs (letter of recommendation) was high enough to do so. In making this decision, he also was able to factor in the punishment that would occur if he was to fail to get rid of the molly. If he failed, he would not get the letter of recommendation that he needed for Harvard, and he would also risk being injured as Dom had said earlier when talking about AJ. Just as the book said, it seemed that extrinsic motivation being presented to Malcolm was an attempt to control his behaviors in order to benefit the drug dealers.
While this was occuring, Malcolm was left to test his intrinsic motivation towards his goal of getting accepted into Harvard. He grew up in a bad neighborhood where not many kids found their way out, his counselor told him that he had an “arrogant” goal and that he likely will not be able to achieve it, and he got tangled up with AJ and Dom. There were many factors that Malcolm was up against but he was able to show persistence and continue to fight forward towards his goal. Another intrinsic motivation that Malcolm exhibited that is related to the chapter is the psychological need to love/connection. Malcolm had his friends who he was able to lean on even though they were bullied because they were nerds. He also offered to help Nakia obtain her GED. This likely was not because he just wanted to help her; it was because he was interested in her and wanted to ask her to prom. He was searching for a connection.
Likely my favorite part of the movie was when Malcolm was able to flip the situation onto AJ. He was able to extrinsically motive/control AJ by threatening to leave a trail that would allow AJ to be caught for his crimes. The consequence for AJ was that he needed to write a letter of recommendation for Malcolm, otherwise he was going to get caught. He had a decision to make and ultimately was motivated to write the letter for the benefit of Malcolm. Throughout the movie, Malcolm was able to stay intrinsically motivated while fighting through the other motivations that were being thrown his way. In the end, he learned something about motivating others and was able to flip the script to his advantage. I thought this movie was full of great examples that relate to the current chapter.
Persistence
Intrinsic Motivation
Extrinsic Motivation
Reward
Punishment
Psychological Need
Consequence
Like we all know, chapter 5 focused on intrinsic and extrinsic motivations, along with reinforcers (rewards) and punishments. Just to recap, intrinsic motivation refers to behavior that is driven by internal rewards. In other words, the motivation to engage in a behavior arises from within the individual because it is naturally satisfying to you or arises from the things that we like to do because they are interesting to us. Extrinsic motivation refers to behavior that is driven by external rewards such as money, praise, grades, trophies, etc. This type of motivation arises from outside the individual. This movie had a lot of positive and negative situations of motivation. It was almost a “life or death” “right or wrong” type of motivational drive throughout the movie.
In the movie Dope, Malcolm and his friends (Jib and Diggy) are in their senior year and it seems to me like they just want to enjoy this last year together. These three individuals are not like most kids at their school. All three of them good grades and plan apply to college. Malcolm has his eye on Harvard. I found that Malcolm is intrinsically motivated to get into college and to write a good essay as a part of his application process. Malcolm mentions to his guidance counselor that his essay is one of kind. He doesn’t want to write the cliche essay about growing up in a bad neighborhood and being raised by a single mother. He is motivated to be known as a smart, well-rounded young man who works hard for what he really wants in life.
Malcolm meets Dom in the beginning of the movie and is persuaded to play a quick game of telephone on Dom’s behalf with a beautiful girl. Malcolm comes to realize that his girl is trying to get her GED because, like him, she also wants to go to college in the future. These two leave a party together that gets busted and she drives Malcolm home. As they are talking in the car about school and college, they eventually come up with a proposition. If Malcolm can help her get her GED then she will go to prom with him. The external reward here being that this girl will go to prom with him and also demonstrating his desire for relatedness and a close relationship. In this situation, this is a positive external reinforcer or reward.
Another example on intrinsic motivation in this movie is when Malcolm and his friends play their music. You can tell that they really enjoy doing that together because they simply enjoy making music and hanging out with each other. At one point in the movie, when they go to AJ’s house, they are actually asked to record their song in the houses studio. I believe this was a case in which they were extrinsically motivated by the reward of getting to record their song. I believe they were still intrinsically motivated as well because they do simply enjoy playing their music whenever they can.
Terms: Intrinsic Motivation, Extrinsic Motivation, Reinforcer, Reward, Relatedness
The movie Dope exemplifies the various intrinsic and extrinsic motivations centered around a young black man in high school by the name of Malcolm. He sums up in his revised personal statement for Harvard how his personal interests and unfortunate social situation (which, admittedly, he made the best of) has shaped two different sides of him:
"Let me tell you about two students. Student A is a straight-A student, lives in a suburb of Los Angeles. Plays in a punk band with his friends. Loves to skateboard and ride BMX bikes. His favorite show is “Game of Thrones.” His favorite band is The Thermals. He is a ’90s hip-hop geek. Student B goes to an underfunded school where teachers, who would rather not be there and teach kids who don’t care. He lives with a single mother, doesn’t know his father, and has sold dope. Now close your eyes. Picture each of these kids and tell me what you see. Be honest. No one’s going to judge you. Now open your eyes. Am I Student A or B?”.
Of course, Malcolm is both Student A and B. However, on the one hand Student A describes his individual interests, driven by intrinsic motivation, whereas Student B describes his situation, driven by his environment and extrinsic motivators.
For example, Malcolm (Student A) was intrinsically motivated to play guitar. He learned on his own (autonomy), kept the music going when he played a gig at the party (competence) and did it with his friends (relatedness). He was also intrinsically motivated to listen to 90s hip hop, skate, bike, learn about science and technology, and watch Game of Thrones.
On the other hand, Malcolm (Student B) was extrinsically motivated, for example, to sell dope. After the shooting at the club, Dom gave him a bag. Malcolm didn’t know at first, but he assumed responsibility for about $100,000 worth of drugs, which set off a whole chain of unintended consequences that affected everything from his interview with Austin Jacoby, the Harvard alumni and Malcolm’s recommendation writer to-be, to pulling a gun on a peer (bad side effect) to writing his personal statement (good side effect).
But Malcolm is not just Student A or B. He is one person and experiences tugs and pulls between intrinsic and extrinsic motivators. As Nakia concluded when Malcolm said he wasn’t himself when he suspects her of using him, he was being himself. However, he hadn’t integrated his behavior yet; he was still rejecting being a drug dealer and everything that came with it. His suspicion was elicited by the unusual circumstances of assuming responsibility for the drugs and Nakia’s boyfriend being a drug dealer who made him responsible for the drugs he found.
But in his personal statement, he comes to terms with being a person who is shaped by both intrinsic and extrinsic motivators. At first, all he wanted to do was write about 90s hip-hop, trying to show Harvard his dedication to his individual interests. He almost explains his intrinsic motivation himself when he says to his advisor Mr. Bailey, “I’m talking about something that I love. It’s well reasoned, supported with historical data. It shows creativity, critical thinking.” However, his advisor told him he needs to write about his underdog story: being poor, raised by a single mother, having no father etc. His advisor asks him, “Who do you think you are?” Even though Malcolm's persistence, he questions his possible success too when he’s in the car with Nakia and says society tells us that only black ball players get into college. However, after his experience selling drugs and understanding himself as something bigger than his personal interests; he rights the personal statement that shows both sides: Student A and B.
At the end of the movie, Malcolm understands the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, even if he doesn’t know the terminology. He understands he is influenced by both, can suss them apart, and ends up integrating the, to make a great case for why he should be accepted to Harvard.
Terms:
Intrinsic motivation
Extrinsic motivation
Individual interests
Situational Interests
Autonomy
Competence
Relatedness
Creativity
Persistence
Unintended consequences
There were a lot of different instances in Dope where the characters of the movie were forced to make decisions based on certain extrinsic motivators and intrinsic motivators. Since chapter 5 talked about the self-determination continuum, I will list my examples in order of the continuum. There was one situation in the movie where Lily jumped out of the car and ran and peed in the bushes outside of the restaurant. Since she was on drugs at the time I said that this decision was non-regulation because she did not have 100% if any control over her actions. Next is external regulation. There were many of these types of situations in the movie in order for characters to get a certain consequence, good or bad. Malcom, Jib, and Diggy are forced to find an alternative route home when the Bloods are filming a music video in the street that they usually take. The consequence of going through there compared to 104th street where the dope dealers were swayed their decision into taking 104th street. When Malcom goes over and talks to Nakia for Dom he does it because he does not want a consequence of possibly getting beat up if he says no. When Dom calls Malcom from prison and tells him not to give the drugs to whoever is in the El Camino, Malcom listens to him because he does not want the consequence of being killed or arrested by whoever was after him. Malcom left Lily and took her car when he was late for his interview because he did not want the consequence of not getting into Harvard because he missed his interview. Jib does not want to help sell the dope anymore because they almost got caught at school during a monthly drug raid but continues to help with the extrinsic motivation that his friends give him via peer pressure. When Malcom goes to see a guy about trading in some of the bitcoins for cash the guy wants Malcom to punch him in the face and then he says he will give him the cash. Malcom needs the money so based on rewards and punishment, he takes a chance and punches the guy in the face and ends up getting his cash. Next on the continuum is introjected regulation. Malcom, Jib, and Diggy cannot get into Dom’s birthday party but they pass Nakia when she is going in and she asks them if they are coming in. Malcom decides to find a way to try and sneak in because being at the party with Nakia would definitely help boost his self-esteem. When the police came in and raided Dom’s birthday party, Malcom ran past Nakia on the floor and to avoid guilt he went back and helped her up and got her out of there. After Introjected regulation comes identified regulation. Malcom views his interview as important so he makes a decision to ride in a car with Lily when she is on drugs to get to his interview. Going to Harvard is very important to Malcom so he makes the decision to sell the dope in hopes that AJ will then make sure that he gets into Harvard. Next on the continuum is integrated regulation which is used because it reflects someone’s values. I did not have any integrated regulation scenarios. Lastly is intrinsic regulation. One instance where Malcom, Diggy, and Jib make a decision is their choice in participating in “white shit” which is intrinsic because it is their own personal interests. When Malcom does not go with his friends to go get food and stays behind to hang out with Lily instead is intrinsic as well because Malcom is staying behind for his own enjoyment.
Key Terms:
Non-regulated motivation, Extrinsic Motivation, External motivation, Introjected motivation, Identified regulation, Integrated regulation, Intrinsic regulation, Self-Determination Continuum
Both chapter five and the movie Dope expressed great deals of extrinsic and intrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation comes from the motives inside and extrinsic motives come from the motives outside. In this movie, the main intrinsic motivation is Malcom wanting and trying to get into the school of his choice, Harvard. There are many extrinsic motivations in Malcom wanting to get into Harvard. Malcom is a good student and has every intention to get into Harvard, but he also has a lot of actions that could land him not in his first choice. Having to go through so many struggles and what not of his daily life affects his motivation to get into school, nevertheless he persists.
Malcom is intrinsically motivated to learn, which makes school a lot easier for him. He likes to learn and wants to continue learning every day, driving his motivation to learn. Extrinsically he was motivated by the thought of getting into Harvard. He is easily motivated because he wants to learn, and could go to the schools closer to him, but what is extrinsically motivating him is getting into Harvard. Another reason why he might want to go to Harvard so badly is because he is easily able to relate to those students more than he would at any other school. He can relate to them because they are intelligent, and also enjoy learning and are intrinsically motivated to learn, like he is.
Another example that relates the book and the movie are the rewards. Malcom is a strong writer, and knows he is. He wants to write a good essay that is not “cliché” because he wants to challenge himself. (this could also be an intrinsic motivation because it makes him feel better when he is challenged, and he does well. He could write about how hard his life was growing up with a single mom in a scary neighborhood and having to face gang problems and the list could go on. However, he does not want this. He wants to stand out. So, if Malcom writes a good essay that is different, and still outstanding, he will be rewarded with getting into Harvard. If he does not write the best essay that is unique and outstanding, then he could be punished and not get accepted into Harvard, having to settle for less.
Malcom getting good grades could be an example of the term reinforcer. Once he gets the good grades, he is going to be accepted into schools, reinforcing his good grade behavior. This is a positive thing, and he is gaining benefits from it. Another example of a reinforcer is how he is getting the letter of recommendation. He needs this letter to get into college, and what is reinforcing him to make the actions is being reinforced by getting the reward of the acceptance letter.
Terms: intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation, reward, reinforcement, positive reinforcement, negative reinforcement
Dope is a film with the main character named Malcolm and his group of friends Diggy and Jib and in high school. The film shows a lot of concepts that were depicted in chapter five. The chapter elaborates on intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation is seen in the beginning of the film, for the most part, how Malcolm has the desire to go after Nakia. His intrinsic motivation is seen how he is not being told to have a crush on her or to pursue her in any way but that he wants to do it on his own. Extrinsic motivation through praise is seen by how Malcolm’s friends push him and praise him in a way to get into Dom’s party. As the movie continues we see how the group get into some trouble. With a lot of illegal drugs in Malcolm’s backpack he receives a call telling him who to deliver the bag from. He is provided with the incentive of not getting hurt or murdered if he were to deliver the package successfully. This also showcases the topic of extrinsic motivation as well because there is a direct reward. As we stated in class “do this to get that”, this is seen clearly as the movie continues and Malcolm faces an interview where he is tested on what he should do with the package that needs to be delivered. He was almost promised a position or spot at Harvard if he were to “do the right thing” with the package. Another example that we see of extrinsic motivation is when Will is in the situation where he can help the group. They need his help and he agrees, but all he wants in return is to be able to say the N word. Two of the three members are black. The “do” is the ability to say the N word from will and the “that” is to help the group sell the drugs that Malcolm got stuck with from Dom.
With Will agreeing to help, he decides that instead of getting some profit through cash, he would rather just get paid in the drugs that they are selling. This is an example of an extrinsic reward. The group overall has an expectation of reward. They understand that money is to be made from the drugs that they are selling. The motivation that they have behind selling the drugs is the fact that they will not get caught easily. Having their main selling location at a school, they have the ability to lay low and have a higher drive to sell drugs.
The intrinsic motivation is also seen throughout the film by how the group play in a small band together called Awreeoh and they seemingly play for just the fun of it. They have the chance to sell their drugs and also perform at a party and their presence become known. With the rise of their drugs fame their drug becomes extremely popular and gains police attention. The motivation to keep selling drugs goes way down because of the fact that they are highly likely to get busted and arrested.
Terms
Intrinsic Motivation
Extrinsic Motivation
Extrinsic reward
reinforcement
In chapter 5, we mainly discuss intrinsic and extrinsic motivation and how they apply to our lives. Dope was a perfect movie example of both types of motivation. Intrinsic motivation refers to actions that are motivated by... well, us. Intrinsic motivation is doing something because you want to. It would only make sense that extrinsic motivation is the opposite of that and refers to the actions we do that we don't particularly want to do, such as chores.
In the movie Dope, our main character, Malcolm, lists us his various and precarious (for his background) interests. They refer to this list in the beginning as "white shit" and it includes activities such as skateboarding, comics, guitar, trash talk, and Donald Glover. These are all examples of activities that Malcolm would take part in because he purely just wants to and enjoys these things. This is a perfect example of intrinsic motivation, these are all things Malcolm would take part in just because he really wants to. One of the standout characteristics of Malcolm is that he is very smart, and a very good student. I would like to say that this is because Malcolm is intrinsically motivated to get good grades, however I'm not sure this is the case. Malcolm wants more than anything to become a man of Harvard, the movie does not explain as to why that is really, just that that is his ultimate goal. If that is the goal, then is Malcolm only a spectacular student because it is the only way he will achieve his goal of getting into Harvard. In this case, he would be extrinsically motivated to be a good student.
Malcolm does however encounter quite a bit of extrinsic motivation throughout the film. The first standout scenario to me where this happens is when Malcolm was invited to Dom's party by Dom. Malcolm and friends don't seem to be all that interested, and even a little afraid about the idea of being in that atmosphere. Malcolm can't seem to say no though because of the beautiful girl he's after. He knows she will be there, so he says yes to the party in order to get close to her. A similar situation occurs after Malcolm finds himself at AJ's house. AJ invites Malcolm and his friends into his house, they are reluctant at first until they see AJ's sister, Lily, undress. The thought of being with this beautiful woman is enough extrinsic motivation to get all three of them into the house because they are seeking a reward, regardless of how dangerous the situation might be. The other reoccurring situation that happens to Malcolm is him trying to keep from being arrested. Malcolm must trust Dom and do as he says in order to keep from getting arrested or killed. Malcolm leaves his SAT session, risking a lower score, to keep the police from finding the drugs in his locker. Malcolm also decides not to turn the drugs in after discovering them because he thinks the police will instantly arrest him and his friends. Malcolm also makes some questionable decisions to get into Harvard, such as letting someone under the influence of drugs drive him to his interview so that he is not late. The climax of the film also comes when Malcolm decides he is going to sell the drugs he's stumbled upon in order to wow his Harvard interviewer. And last but not least, Malcolm ultimately decides to blackmail the same Harvard interviewer in order to achieve his goal of becoming a Harvard student. This movie is filled with extrinsic motivation and scenarios where Malcolm is forced to do something he doesn't want to do in order to save he and his friends' skin.
Terms used: Extrinsic Motivation, Intrinsic Motivation, Reward
The movie Dope relates to chapter 5 talking about Intrinsic and extrinsic motivation quite well. Malcom experiences both of these in many situations. Firstly, intrinsic motivation is showed when Malcom expresses his wants to get into Harvard, meaning he needs to do his best in school. He is intrinsically motivated by his friends and the genre of music he enjoys as well. These all internal feelings of accomplishment and feeling “good”. In the midst of all these good things he gets caught up in a drug bust. Malcom knows he can either get killed by turning in the drugs or he can just sell the drugs himself at the expense of possibly getting caught. Malcom decides to sell the drugs because he doesn’t want to get himself killed, and more importantly to him, his mother. This is an example of being extrinsically motivated, because this comes from the environment, this was not something that internally came up. During this whole ordeal Malcom meets this girl (Nakia) who is trying to get her GED. Malcom decides he would like to help her study with the hopes of being able to ask her to the school prom, this would be an extrinsic motivator. Another way Malcom is intrinsically motivated is to get a good job and go to school because he wants to help his mother. Malcom has a disadvantage compared to his friends because he has hopes to get into an Ivy League school. He is intrinsically motivated by his race as well, many people when they hear about him or see him just assumes that he is a bad guy, he doesn’t have the potential to get into an Ivy League school, and he is just assumed to be a drug dealer. Another very important part of the movie is punishment and reward. There are rewards in getting accepted into Harvard, going to prom with Nakia and hopefully eventually being something more, and helping out his mom. Punishment would be not being accepted, getting caught, and Nakia denying Malcom. We learned that Intrinsic motivators refers to behavior that is driven by us internally. Extrinsic motivators are behaviors that are driven by the environment, we do these for rewards like money, gold stars, trophies, good grades, and many more things. These are both very frequent in the movie. There are many examples of these throughout the entire movie.
Intrinsic motivations/Motivators
Extrinsic Motivations/Motivators
Positive
Negative
Reinforces
In Chapter five we learn about extrinsic and intrinsic motivation. In the movie “Dope” we see a lot of motivations come from Malcom and if we analyze where those motivations come from, they are a mix between extrinsic and intrinsic. Intrinsic motivations are behaviors that are done because of an internal reward, like pure satisfaction. Extrinsic motivation is a behavior that is done because you will receive something that makes it worth it, such as money, trophy, stickers, or praise. Malcom and his friends enjoy 90s hip-hop culture, and are good students. Malcom has an intrinsic motivation to get As because of his desire to get into Harvard. An important characteristic of intrinsic motivation is persistence. Persistence is doing a behavior for a long period of time despite how difficult it is. I think this is something Malcom does a great job of throughout the movie because basically everything he does is motivated by getting into Harvard.
Malcom meets Dom and becomes a messenger to him and Nikia. This is one of the first examples of extrinsic motivation (and also could be intrinsic) because he gets to talk to Nikia. She says she will only attend Dom’s party if Malcom is there, so Malcom and his friends agree to go, this is an example of intrinsic motivation because they aren’t getting any certain reward other than satisfaction. While at the party, other gang members bust in and start shooting Dom and his gang. The police show up to bust the party and the drugs, so Malcom and his pals run from the situation because of extrinsic motivation and negative consequence. Dom finds Malcom’s backpack and stuffs the Molly in to hide it. This leads to an even bigger problem for Malcom because he’s a good student who is trying to work his way into Harvard. Macolm’s next mission was to get rid of the drugs by selling them and using the money to bribe his way with Austin Jacoby. Getting rid of the drugs would be an intrinsic motivation because he wouldn’t have to worry about carrying them in his backpack anymore. This also falls under extrinsic motivation because he will get a reward if he sells them. The money from the drugs would be the reward. Malcom makes a deal with Austin Jacoby and if the reward of getting into Harvard wasn’t so high on his intrinsic motivation, Malcom would have obviously given up by then. The risk outweighed getting killed by the gang members who were controlling him.
Malcom’s story begins and ends with intrinsic motivation. If he didn’t have a desire to get into the Ivy League school to support his family, there is no way he would have done anything with drugs. The geek showed his motivation by doing behaviors that he wouldn’t do on a normal given week. The end of the movie shows Malcom rewriting his submission essay for Harvard. He decides to write about why he even needs to prove why he wants to get into Harvard. If he was white, he wouldn’t have to justify what kind of neighborhood he lives in. He wouldn’t have to justify what makes him want to get good grades. This is all driven by his needs and wants to satisfy himself.
Malcom risked his life dealing with the drugs and selling them all because of his intrinsic motivation to get into Harvard.
Terms: Intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation, reward, negative reinforcement
The movie, Dope, is full of different forms of intrinsic and extrinsic motivations for behavior. Malcolm’s troubles all began after he decided to talk to Dom on the street and then become the middle man between Dom and Nakia. What motivated Malcolm to go talk to Dom? I have a feeling that Malcolm was tired of being beat up and being scared to ride his bike home, so he wanted to make an ally or prove that he is someone not worth beating up. He is extrinsically motivated because environmental factors are motivating him to make this behavior.
One really important aspect of Malcolm’s life was his goal to go to Harvard. Malcolm was intrinsically motivated to get into Harvard. He enjoyed schoolwork, and really wanted to go to college. No one would have to force Malcolm to go to college or pay him to do it, although if he were offered a full ride, I doubt he would decline. Because of his desire to go to Harvard, he won’t let anything ruin that reputation. Once he has the dope, things become complicated because if he is caught he could be arrested and that would ruin his chances of Harvard.
The scene where Malcolm goes to his college interview with Austin Jacoby/A.J., he talks to him about the “delivery.” I found this an interesting spot in the movie because A.J. asks him why Malcolm did it, and Malcolm replied that he had no choice. He had mentioned earlier in the movie that if they had taken it to the police they would have looked super suspicious because of their skin color and would most likely be arrested. Because of this, I believe that Malcolm was intrinsically motivated to deliver the dope. I believe this because I think he felt that he had the responsibility of delivering them because Dom placed the dope in his backpack and made Malcolm become a whole part of this.
In order for Malcolm to get rid of the dope but still have a chance to get into Harvard, he has to sell the dope on a secretive website where people use bitcoin to pay for things. I think a little bit of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation was used for creating the bitcoin account and selling online. I think this had an intrinsic motivation because Malcolm wants to do this so that he cannot be traced because of his ultimate goal of going to Harvard. Extrinsic motivators for Malcolm could have included the money for all the dope they sold, being completely free of dope, and then having a clear conscience. Being free of the dope is extrinsic because he would no longer need to fear for his life or gang members and can walk a free man.
I think that Malcolm was much more intelligent than the movie led on. He had his own motivational reasoning for setting up A.J. I think when A.J. told Malcolm that he had a choice the whole time, Malcolm took that and decided to use it to his advantage to get his way into Harvard. I think, after this meeting, Malcolm was constantly being extrinsically motivated by the idea of Harvard. He listens to A.J.’s advice and does everything he advises so Malcolm can use it later for a little bit of blackmail towards A.J.
Terms:
Extrinsic
Intrinsic
Harvard
Environment
Dope
Throughout the movie Dope the main chapter Malcom was faced with multiple situations that lead him to be extrinsically motivated. The events that came up in his life were all mostly motivated by his want to get into his dream school which was Harvard. All of the events that came up in his life were all mostly geared from his intrinsic motivations things that he knew he wanted. Nobody had to tell him that he should or needed to get into Harvard but that was what he wanted for himself. Everything started to change after the one day of taking a different way when his path was blocked and he had too it was then that he ran into Dom. He then had the backpack that was full of cocaine and it was when he then went to his interview with Harvard that his inner motivations kicked into play full speed. It was at his interview that he was told he needed to sell or lose the cocaine or that he could say goodbye to his years at Harvard. This was when he really started to step up his game in the fact that he really needed and wanted to get rid of the cocaine. He then went through many obstacles to get rid of the cocaine but to him it didn’t matter what he had to go through because he had one thing on his mind and that was getting into his dream school. Another thing that was displayed in the movie that dealt with the chapter was the scene with AJ and how Malcom chose to blackmail him and tell him to write a letter to help him get into the school since he was the reason he got into all this trouble in the first place. Malcom told AJ that he needed to help him or that he would get in trouble and possible face jail time. AJ also did the same to Malcom when he told him that he needed to get rid of the drugs or that he was not going to get into his schools. Malcom was a good kid all throughout his days he made sure to try hard and get good grades and he wasn’t going to let the bag of cocaine take away from getting into the school that he wanted. His intrinsic motivation took him to the point of what he wanted. Towards the end of the movie in the last scene it was shown by the look on his face that he made it into the school that he wanted Harvard. After all that he had gone thought and all of the trying from hard event that came up and was going to stop him from getting in and that pushed him to try harder and achieve his goals. This movie was a prime example to show that even when things come up and become hard that has humans we all have goals within ourselves that can push to come out no matter what the outcome.
Terms:
Intrinsic motivation
Extrinsic motivation
Punisher
Motivation
In the movie Dope, we can see clear examples of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation in Malcolm. Malcolm’s wild journey begins because of an innate, simple need: the need for sex. He is placed in a situation where he is forced to talk to a girl he finds attractive, Nakia. In this specific scene, we see Malcolm struggle with his motivation to go to the party with her or to stay home and attend to his studies. His need for sex and intimacy wins out and he goes to the party. After the party, Malcolm face with the motivating factor that is punishment. He can either return the dope or he will possibly face death. In the scene where Malcolm is approaching the car, we can see motivation in him and his friends. Malcolm’s friends stay back from the car as they fear the threat of death and by staying back they are negatively reinforced as the drugs become Malcolm’s responsibility, not theirs. Malcolm is motivated through external regulation as he really wants to be completely uninvolved with drug trade. He is only motivated through fear and therefore begins to approach the car.
The other side of Malcolm is his intrinsic motivation to perform well in school and stand out from his cohort who are all involved in drugs and gangs. In one scene, Malcolm and his friends are shown about to start taking the SAT. This scene truly shows Malcolm’s strong intrinsic drive to succeed in life and go to college. There were only about six students in the room taking the SAT. The other students are too busy doing drugs and performing the typical gang activates. Another scene that shows Malcolm’s internal drive to go to college is his mad dash to his interview. Despite his strong desire for sex, he pushes the beautiful naked girl off of him and even risks his life by having the girl drive him despite being incredibly stone from snorting the ecstasy. Malcolm has worked very throughout his high school career and it is obvious that despite the tumultuous time in life, he risks everything to make it to the interview. Malcolm believes that college is the best option for him despite how his peers believe otherwise and does all he can to preserve his good standing and make it in to college.
Terms: External regulation, punishment, intrinsic, extrinsic, sex, need
Malcolm is a young man who is driven by several sets of motivating forces that sometimes conflict. He shows intense intrinsic motivation to pursue activities which he enjoys, even if that marks him out for ridicule and misjudgment by his peers and others. He enjoys ‘90s hip hop, and the trappings that go with it, even though this is out of style. He is interested in learning, and academic success, even though this marks him as different from his peers. And as he says in his personal essay for admission to Harvard, his atypical interests have led to him not fitting in to any of the social realms he travels in. And yet he is able to meet his strong need for marching to the beat of his own drummer (autonomy need), benefit from the satisfaction of meeting his need for competence in numerous areas, and enjoys close relationships (relatedness and affiliation need) with his two loyal friends. His intrinsic motivation to pursue his interest in all things ‘90s hip hop related, and desire to learn lead to higher levels of learning and understanding that allow him to later in the movie to apply skills and competences in new, but similar tasks. Despite the bullying and not fitting in to the larger peer culture, we see evidence of well-being derived from following his quirky interests and the friendship that is connected to them. Of course, we also see extrinsic motivation play a role in his drive to succeed academically and go to Harvard. But, with evidence like his quirky first essay draft and his willingness to risk Harvard to stay true to himself, the extrinsic motivation appears to be secondary and reinforcing of the strong intrinsic motivation to learn and pursue his academic interests.
At the same time, he is responding to cues from his environment that sometimes motivate him to behave in ways that threaten to disrupt his goals. Desire for sex drives him to pursue both Nakia and Lily. Their appearance, especially Lily’s nudity creates an incentive that intensifies his drive for sex. The two women’s smiles and other verbal and non-verbal cues provide a positive reinforcement to increase his continued sex-seeking behavior. These ultimately lead to him making several choices that threaten his desire for college. He ends up in a club which is a high risk environment in pursuit of Nakia. He forgets about his alumni interview for Harvard because of his pursuit of sex with Lily. The testosterone increases his attention in the two women and also interferes with cognition.
Once the MDMA and gun are placed in Malcolm’s backpack, we also see a very strong negative emotional state (fear) motivate him to try to pick his way through a series of constrained and risky choices. His desire for relief from the negative emotional state that environmental signals are triggering in him, drive him on to ultimately engage in activity that is at odds with his image of himself and values. But, after he learns that the alumni interview is with the drug distributor and that his entry into Harvard can be ruined or helped by whether or not he does a good job delivering on the mission AJ presses on him, we see a change in Malcolm’s behavior. The external motivation marries up with his personal goals. Rather than bumbling from one scrape to the next, we see a return to his previous competence and comfort in his choices return. He reasserts his autonomy by taking the bad situation and making choices that turn it to fit with his own desires. As he achieves success in tasks that draw on his strengths but provide new challenges, we see evidence of dopamine releases (reward) helping to reinforce his persistence and increasing his enjoyment of the tasks. He is no longer just trying to escape the unpleasant emotional state, but taking pleasure from his accomplishments, and gaining confidence to take on new challenges (such as the black market exchange of cash for bitcoins).
Terms:
intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation, environment, autonomy, competence, relatedness, affiliation, sex, need, testosterone, positive reinforcement, negative emotional states, fear, dopamine, reward, persistence.
In the movie Dope, Malcolm faces two major life threatening dilemmas. First, he is in a club with several friends when people with guns enter the area and begin shooting. Next, he finds himself in possession of drugs worth thousands of dollars, which lead into several smaller, yet equally serious life threatening conditions. Malcolm is both intrinsically and extrinsically motivated to get rid of the large amount of drugs he was given and here is how.
Extrinsically, Malcolm is motivated to sell the drugs because he simply wants to get rid of them, for there is a complex hierarchy involved in both the drug world and the academic world. In the drug world, Dom is above Malcolm, and above Dom is Austin Jacoby, and Austin Jacoby also happens to be the same person at the top of the academic pyramid – the person Malcolm needs to get into his dream school, which is Harvard.
Intrinsically, Malcolm’s friends, Jib and Diggy, are motivated to sell the drugs simply because thee wants to. Jib and Diggy go down the path of being drug dealers because they felt loyal to help their friend; they did not have to join Malcolm in his endeavor. The people after the drugs would have been more than happy to only catch Malcolm, and his friends could have let him deal with the situation on his own; however, they knew how much trouble he could get into and they did not want him to suffer alone.
Another scene where intrinsic motivation is present is when Will, a white man, feels the need to say the “n-word”. Will does not receive any form of outside, or external, motivation to say the derogatory word, he simply wants to say the word to say it; there are no benefits to saying the “n-word”.
Thinking back to Malcolm, he is extrinsically motivated to link Austin Jacoby’s bank account to the large sum of cryptocurrency, or bitcoin, due to the fact that Jacoby is the only person standing in the way of Malcolm being accepted into Harvard. If Malcolm can gain leverage over Jacoby, then he can ensure he will be allotted a place at his dream school.
Jacoby is extrinsically motivated to obey Malcolm, for if he does not, Malcolm can alert authorities to the large sum of bitcoin Jacoby acquired through Malcolm selling his drugs, which would be a negative consequence and may land him in jail or prison.
Malcolm’s plan to sell Austin Jacoby’s drugs and attend Harvard was successful; however, it could have cost him his life as well as the lives of his friends. Selling illegal drugs and linking the money made illegally to Austin Jacoby’s personal account was extremely risky; however, he had several motivating factors such as keeping his friends safe, keeping himself safe, and attending his dream school. All of these tasks involved illegal activities that could have put Malcolm in danger as well as trouble, but he managed to turn a bad situation into a good situation and attend his dream school.
TERMS USED
Consequence
Friends
Extrinsic
Intrinsic
Motivation
One of the first things that I noticed throughout the film “Dope” was the use of intrinsic motivations and extrinsic motivations. This entire film is based in the ghetto of California and focuses on a kid named Malcolm, who has made it a goal in his life to get accepted into Harvard. Although he lives in “the bottoms,” he is set on not becoming a thug and on keeping his nose out of trouble. One large intrinsic motivation for him to get into Harvard is the fact that Malcolm wants to be better for himself and getting into an Ivy League school would make him feel more secure in that. However, Malcolm seeking a better future is also considered an extrinsic motivation, because by going to Harvard Malcolm will [assumingly] build connections, get better job offers, and essentially better his life; all motivations from the outside, or environment. Nakia is also both an intrinsic and extrinsic motivator, because as the film develops he begins to fall in love with her. This is intrinsic because it involves Malcolm wanting to better himself for her, but Nakita herself is also an extrinsic motivation because she is also an outside motivator. One of the largest extrinsic factors—aside from Harvard—was Malcolm’s mother. It is said throughout the film that Malcolm wants to be able to support her and getting into an Ivy League school is a big step towards that.
Malcolm also must face rewards and punishments throughout the film. One of his main rewards is at the end of the film, when it implies that he got into Harvard after all the dismal things that he had to do. He faces both positive and negative reinforcement throughout the film, such as meeting Nakita and his dreams of Harvard being threatened. Meeting Nakita was a positive reinforcer, because she is one of the reasons that Malcolm gets into the world of trafficking drugs and dealing with other illegal activities. Harvard was threatened by a man named Austin Jacoby, who was not only an admissions leader, but also the drug leader that lead Malcolm down the path of drug and bitcoins in the first place. He would be a negative reinforcement, because he’s threatening to take Harvard away from Malcolm if he doesn’t deliver, motivating Malcolm to continue with the drugs.
This film focuses a lot on goals; both short-term and long-term. Clearly, Malcolm’s main goal is to get into Harvard to support his mother. His goals also include impressing Nakita –whom he met from the men threatening him to sell their drugs that they snuck into his bag at a party— so that she will go out with him and getting out of the worm hole and world of drugs that he accidentally wandered into when he has to take a different walkway home in the beginning of the film. Chapter five helped us to look at goals and how they motivate us, and Malcolm’s above-listed goals were the main motivators that pushed Malcolm throughout the movie.
Intrinsic Motivation
Extrinsic Motivation
Rewards
Punishments
Positive reinforcement
Negative reinforcement
Goal
Jon Lutz - section 01
Early in the movie there is a scene which demonstrates the major flaw with extrinsic motivation. Mr. Bailey is trying to motivate Malcolm to write a better acceptance essay to Harvard. His speech is impassioned and his motive seems pure, but his verbal phrasing lacks concern for Malcolm’s psychological needs. Mr. Bailey claims Malcolm “isn’t taking it seriously,” which undercuts his competence. Also, he refers to a “Harvard Man” implying Malcolm is not one, hitting his competence and relatedness. Mr. Bailey suggests he take a direction with his essay that Malcolm considers less original than his first submission, dampening his autonomy. On top of these subtle forces, the content of Mr. Bailey’s message is overtly contradicting Malcolm’s intrinsic motivation. Malcolm wrote about something “he loves,” though he is extrinsically motivated by Mr. Bailey, who fails to use integrated regulation. It is not until the end of the film and Malcolm identifies with a better message that he takes an improved approach.
Intrinsic motivation did more than help Malcolm revise his essay. It drives the characteristics that carry him to the end of the movie: Persistence, creativity, and engaged learning. The intense interest Malcolm and his friends have for their unpopular hobbies gives them the upper hand. Their engagement with schoolwork, namely technology, allowed them to outsmart all their adversaries. They trick the thugs in red al camino with the gps. They defeat A Jacoby with their knowledge of cryptocurrency. It is Malcolm’s assistance with the GED that gets him the girl. The whole time the team is displaying creativity, more than the bad guys in pursuit who seem to only be motivated by monetary reward and reputation (extrinsic incentives and consequences). It is a shame that such well meaning children are forced into such unlawful activities. Malcolm becomes a drug dealer, lies, and even pulls a gun not because he is trying to make a bunch of money, but when Jacoby threatens his college acceptance and his chance to be a “Harvard Man.” Evident in his persistence, intrinsic motivation is the deciding force for Malcolm.
In the movie there is a disproportionate amount of gun violence. The movie chalks it up to a poor and crime ridden neighborhood. I think the equation S:R → C helps explain more concretely. The situational cues are that of a highly populated, impoverished, and marginalized community in a country where access to guns is incredibly high. The resulting behaviors are a wide range of violence (gun wounds, mugging, aggressive posturing and language) and substance abuse. The “:” implies an interaction but not causation. That is why not everyone in the movie (and life) shoots and snorts. The resulting consequences include death, dependency, incarceration, but also reinforcing consequences: money, status, pleasure. Sadly the negative consequences only feed the chaotic situational space in which the the characters interact. This unfortunate setting also too often tips the behavioral threshold in favor of illegal and immoral action, despite such gruesome punishments.
Extrinsic motivation
Intrinsic motivation
Integrated regulation
Verbal phrasing
Psychological needs
Competence
Relatedness
Autonomy
Persistence
Creativity
Learning
Incentives
Consequences
Situational Cues
Consequences
Reinforcers
punishment
Malcom is a high school geek who loves hip hop, spending time with his two other geek friends Jib and Diggy, and playing funk music. Although he lives in Inglewood, California, a city known for gangs and crime, Malcom is confident and motivated that he will be admitted into Harvard. His path to Harvard gets tougher when a drug dealer named Dom puts a ton of molly in his bag and is forced to sell it in order to get a good recommendation for Harvard.
Throughout the movie Malcom is extrinsically motivated. Extrinsic motivation comes from “environmental incentives and consequences” and “arises from a “Do this and you will get that” behavioral contract; it exists as an “in order to” motivation” (Reeve, 113). When he is riding on his bike home from school he runs into a drug dealer/gang member named Dom. Dom tells Malcom to go up to a girl named Nakia and invite him to his birthday party. The first example of extrinsic motivation is when Dom. This is a good example of Extrinsic motivation because Malcom is threatened by Dom and fears the potential consequences that could occur if he doesn’t do what Dom says. After Dom’s birthday party gets interrupted by a different gang and a shootout starts, Nakia gives Malcom a ride home and talks about how she is going to get her GED and go to a community college somewhere in California. They somehow start talking about prom and he gets the nerves to ask her to prom. She says that she wouldn’t be able to go to prom because she would be busy studying for the GED. He asks if he helped her pass the GED if she would go to prom with him and she says maybe. The insensitive for helping her pass the GED is that he will get to go to prom with him.
Another notable example of extrinsic motivation in the movie is when Jacoby (AJ) reschedules their Harvard interview and tells Malcom that if he doesn’t sell the molly that Dom left in his bag that he will not give him a good recommendation. The incentive in selling the molly is that Malcom will get a great recommendation from AJ and the reward is being accepted into Harvard. If Malcom decided to decline AJ’s deal, then he is faced with the consequences of never getting to go to the school of his dreams. When Malcom decides to sell the molly, he experiences the consequences of getting caught, especially because he is storing the molly in school and he has to sell a lot of it.
Malcom is also intrinsically motivated throughout the movie. Intrinsic motivation “is the inherent propensity to engage one’s interests and to exercise one’s capacities and, in doing so, to seek out and master optimal challenges. It emerges spontaneously from psychological needs and innate strivings for growth” (Reeve, 111). The first example of intrinsic motivation that I noticed was that Malcom is intrinsically motivated through being with his two friends Jib and Diggy and playing music. Because Malcom is a geek and doesn’t fit in with the norm of living in Inglewood, California hanging out with his geek friends and playing music are intrinsically motivating to Malcom because it helps him feel free, competent, and related/emotionally close to others.
Extrinsic Motivation
Intrinsic Motivation
Insensitive
Consequence
Reward
The movie Dope is a good representation of intrinsic and extrinsic motivations and where they can lead an individual. Throughout the movie, the main character Malcom experiences both of these quite often. The general extrinsic motivator that exists throughout the film is the dream of getting into Harvard, Malcom’s school of choice. We see this drive his choices of being different when writing his paper on Ice Cube in hopes of standing out and appealing to Harvard, and also later in the film when he is motivated to get rid of the drugs so that he can get AJ to write a letter of recommendation for him. The main intrinsic motivator in this story is his desire to learn. He doesn’t do well just to get good grades. Rather, Malcom is driven to stand out and put his smart mind to good use. As a result of this kind of motivation throughout the years, we see the character of Malcom become creative, both in how he dresses and his problem solving, but we also see him become persistent when working with his extrinsic motivators to achieve his ultimate goal, an acceptance letter to Harvard. Early in the film we see Malcom hesitant to go to a party, with the reward of it being a dance with Nakia. Later, however, we see his persistence grow when he is less hesitant in his choices because he really wants that letter or recommendation. Even though these motivators were both seen in the film, I saw that the extrinsic motivators were more dominant with Malcom when driving his behavior throughout the movie. Along with the motivators themselves, there are also reinforcements and punishments that we see that either push the behavior further or stop it in its tracks. A punishment example could be having Dom’s party crashed by gang members and as a result, Malcom was probably scarred and would likely not go to a party with that group of people again. A reinforcement could be the money that Malcom earns throughout the movie. The money earned can also be related to the Cognitive Evaluaion Theory from Chapter 5, which explained that an external event such as praise, money, grades, etc, can be used to control another’s behavior. This particular case would be an example of creating an extrinsic motivator because it establishes an if-then relationship between a desired behavior and a consequence or reward.
These pushes and pulls of different motivators for Malcom illustrated almost two opposite sides of his personality. On one hand, from the intrinsic motivators, you see a kid who is doing well academically, has dreams of going to Harvard, hangs out with his friends and plays in a band with them, and is made fun of because of his obvious obsession with the 90’s. On the other hand, we see a kid who is driven by extrinsic motivators, goes to a party hosted by drug dealers, and ends up selling dope all in hopes of going to college one day. The movie Dope is an excellent example of showing how different motivators can conflict with eachother and get someone into a tough situation. Fortunately, Malcom made the best of it what he could have and guessing by the smile at the end when looking at the letter from Harvard, it all worked out.
Terms:
Extrinsic Motivation
Intrinsic Motivation
Drive
Creativity
Persistence
Reinforcements (Positive and Negative)
Punishments
Reward
Cognitive Evaluation Theory
Consequence
This week’s movie was the 2015 film, Dope, that relates to chapter five, in the textbook, on intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. In the film, we follow Malcom as he navigates life as a 90’s nerd in modern day Inglewood, California. This premise allows for several cases of these types of motivation, as well as, different external regulators like consequences and incentives. Throughout this post, I will explore examples of these elements of motivation as they appeared in the film.
The textbook explains that intrinsic motivation derives from psychological needs for autonomy, competence, and relatedness. This can be see in Dope through three different examples of Malcom’s intrinsic motivation. First, it is clear that Malcom, and his friends, are fans of 90s culture and seek to emulate it through their personal style and band. This interest shows an intrinsic motivation that is inspired by their need for autonomy and allows them to express themselves creatively. Second, Malcom explains that he is made fun of for being into “white shit” such as getting good grades. This interest comes from the psychological need for competence and allows him to have a high-quality learning experience. Lastly, Malcom’ multiple relationships throughout the film, particularly those with Nakia and Lily, are a result of the intrinsic motivation for relatedness. Malcom continually approaches his motivation towards Nakia by being persistent in his pursuit of her.
When considering examples of extrinsic motivation, two specific examples stood out to me during the film. First, was the proposition made by AJ that if Malcom sold the drugs, AJ would get him into Harvard. The acceptance to Harvard was to be Malcom’s reward for dealing drugs. Despite not intending to play that role, Malcom agrees to this behavior based on the extrinsic motivation provided by AJ. Also, Malcom makes a deal with Nakia that if he can help her pass her GED, he would be allowed to take her to prom. Despite this being an expected and tangible reward, Malcom’s intrinsic motivation towards being around Nakia does not decrease due to extrinsic rewards but, arguably, increases.
In connection to these last two points, is that the expectation of rewards worked as an incentive for Malcom to sell the drugs and help Nakia with her studies. On the other hand, there were some external regulations that worked as consequences throughout the film. Firstly, the student who was in the gang, Bloods, imposes a negative reinforcement on Malcom when he bullies him to give up his shoes. It is clear that this event has occurred in the past and presents two ways in which Malcom could have handled this negative reinforcer. In the film, Malcom begins to give the student his shoes as a form of escape behavior. In the future, Malcom could choose to wear less appealing shoes to employ avoidance behavior as a means of keeping the student from bullying him in the first place. Secondly, towards the end of the movie, that same student bullies Malcom again and grabs the bag that holds the money he made from selling drugs. As a punisher for harassing him and grabbing his bag, Malcom pulls a gun on the student. This punisher worked to decrease their behavior at that moment and in the future, as they purposely do not bully Malcom again after this incident.
Overall, Dope showcased multiple examples of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. Malcom and his friends were intrinsically motivated by their love of 90s cultures and desire to get good grades. Malcom was extrinsically motivated by incentives and rewards to help AJ and Nakia. The use of concequences such as punishers and negative reinforcers were used by Malcom and a bully to effect behavior.
Terms:
Intrinsic and Extrinsic Motivation
Autonomy
Competence
Relatedness
Creativity
High-Quality Learning
Persistence
Rewards
Expected and Tangible Rewards
External Regulation
Consequences
Punisher
Negative Reinforcer
Escape Behavior
Avoidance Behavior
Incentives
The main focus of Chapter five of the textbook is regarding intrinsic and extrinsic motivation and this film contains great examples of both. Dope follows a group of high students with one in particular named Malcom whose primarily goal is to attend Harvard. Throughout the film, Malcolm finds himself in peculiar situations and obstacles. This film depicts manners in which Malcolm is both intrinsically and extrinsically motivated.
Intrinsic motivation is described as the motivation an individual receives from inner need such as having fun or gaining competence. In the beginning of the film, Malcolm and his friends are seen playing music together in a classroom. Their motivation to play music is primarily intrinsic in attempt to have fun and to spend time bonding. Malcolm also displays a genuine interest in 90’s music and during various scenes in the film he explains that his motivation to listen to this genre stems from a love and appreciation for the artist of the 90’s. During one scene of the film, Malcom meets a girl named Nakia whom he instantly finds attractive. Throughout the film, Malcom is intrinsically motivated to talk and spend time with Nakia due to his romantic interest and genuine desire to get to know her. In one scene of the film he goes as far as to attend a party a club in order to spend time with her. His intrinsic motivation places him in a dangerous situation due to this romantic interest and as a result becomes caught in a drug situation.
Malcolm finds himself in a situation where he has possession of drugs and no manner in which to get rid of them. He is ultimately forced to sell the drugs and deliver the money. While involved in this situation, Malcolm’s extrinsic motivation comes to the surface. Extrinsic motivation is defined as the motivation an individual receives from outside sources such as money and trophies. His extrinsic motivation in this film however comes from AJ whom forces Malcolm to sell the drugs in order to ensure a good standing with himself and with Harvard. In order for Malcolm to receive his recommendation letter and have a better chance at attending Harvard, he must sell the drugs and deliver the money to AJ. In this scenario, Malcolm is extrinsically motivated because he wants his recommendation letter from AJ. One scene of the film depicts Malcolm and his friends nearly being robbed by a group of teenagers. Malcolm becomes intrinsically motivated to pull out a gun and prevent the drug money from being stolen. His intrinsic motivation came from the money that needed to be delivered.
There are certain scenes that depict both punishment and rewards. Rewards are defined as any offering from one person given to another person in exchange for his or her service or achievement. Punishments decrease the likelihood of a certain behavior occurring in the future. The scene where AJ is discussing selling the drugs with Malcolm is a perfect example of rewards and punishments. Malcolm is informed that his reward for selling the drugs and delivering the money will result in a good recommendation letter to Harvard. However, if he fails at this task, his punishment will result in no recommendation letter and a reduced opportunity to attend the school. The opportunity of receiving a recommendation letter is an example of a reward, while no recommendation letter is an example of a punishment. Ironically, at the end of the film Malcolm provides AJ with a punishment and reward system. Malcolm blackmails AJ with informing the police about AJ’s involvement with drugs. The punishment in this scene is the likelihood of AJ’s destroyed reputation and the reward is to maintain his good reputation. Malcolm’s intrinsic motivation to attend Harvard results in successfully attaining a recommendation letter.
Terms: Goal, extrinsic motivation, intrinsic motivation, competence, punishment, reward
Dope follows the story of Malcolm, a smart high schooler in a poor neighborhood who is presented choices during the film that are related to intrinsic and extrinsic motivations. Malcolm and his intrinsic motivations are enhancing his creativity. For example, the idea to leave a trail of evidence, is a good idea and would require specific steps and processes to be done to be able to carry out a plan that could be complicated. During the course of the film, Malcolm’s intrinsic motivation is to get accepted into Harvard, while some decisions during the film, like blackmailing a former Harvard alumni with pull to get accepted. Malcolm’s other intrinsic motivations include wanting a relationship with Nakia, a girl who like Malcolm who he tutors so she can get her GED. One of the drug dealers in his neighborhood suggests that he invite her to a party, knowing that Nakia likes Malcolm. He goes to the party, in hopes of having a dance or intimate contact with her. It is intrinsic motivation as it is something that he desires, and serves as a personal goal or natural feeling. Intrinsic motivation is also related to persistence, which could be an example of him not wanting to give up and achieve his intrinsic goal of attending Harvard. It also could explain how well he does in school in that he continues to attend and stay in school.
An example of extrinsic motivation seen throughout the movie is when he blackmails AJ, a former Harvard alum who is selling drugs. AJ forces Malcolm to try to sell the drugs in return for a chance of getting into Harvard. But Malcolm switches it on AJ, by leaving a trail of evidence of bitcoins, and microtransactions that if Malcolm isn’t admitted to Harvard will result in his arrest. This is extrinsic motivation as the reward is external and that it is letter admitting him into Harvard. He saw an opportunity where possibly the reward outweigh the risks, and took the steps to get there. This could be a negative or positive reinforcer, depending on how he interprets it. A reinforcer is something that increases a behavior. If he may have another opportunity to blackmail someone that may result in him gaining a reward or incentive, he may or may not do it again. The same could be said for selling the drugs, he did sell it and make a lot of money, but did depending on how he viewed that it could be good or bad. Malcolm is a very crafty and intelligent student, and at the end uses the phrase of “Student A is a music geek that plays in a punk band and gets straight As, while student b suffers in the hood and makes money in immoral ways.” He is describing himself is this and is using both forms of motivations. An intrinsic motivation he likes to play music cause he gains joy or satisfaction out of it could be considered autonomous, while an extrinsic motivation would be making money in immoral ways like selling drugs to have a form of gain of money or information that could be used to blackmail someone.
In the movie Dope, we follow a high school senior named Malcolm, who is living a “double life” as Student A and Student B. Malcolm is being shaped by both intrinsic and extrinsic motivators. Intrinsic motivation is “the inherent propensity to engage one’s interests and to exercise one’s capacities and, in doing so, to seek out and master optimal challenges” (pg. 111). “Extrinsic motivation arises from environmental incentives and consequences” (pg. 113). Extrinsic motivators are different than intrinsic motivators because with intrinsic motivators, you are tracking your progress yourself while with extrinsic motivators, others can see your progress or lack of progress.
Student A is motivated to play guitar in his band, do well on his SAT, and get into his dream college: Harvard. This is an example of intrinsic motivation because it is out of his personal interest. Learning to play guitar and trying hard to learn in school gives rise to autonomy, competence, and relatedness. Malcolm grew up in a bad community but took it upon himself to make a better life for himself and accomplish more than what was expected of him. He did well on his SAT and entrance exam and made it into Harvard.
Student B is motivated to sell and deliver dope through an online site without anyone knowing. When Dom put the dope and gun in Malcolm’s school backpack, Malcolm took the same bag to school and then realized he had the bag full of dope and a loaded gun. After a phone call, he was told he needed to sell the dope or else his family would be killed. His extrinsic motivation allowed him to continue selling the dope and create an online website that would prevent the law from figuring out it was him. This was a form of negative reinforces, Malcom wanted to make sure that he wouldn’t get caught because that would interfere with him getting into Harvard and effect his mother as well.
Malcolm’s extrinsic motivation is getting in the way of his intrinsic motivation. An example of this would be when Malcolm is in a room to take his SAT and the police come with their drug dogs. Malcolm is forced to get out of his seat to get his school bag from his locker in order to prevent the drug dogs from finding his bag full of dope and ruining his chances of getting into Harvard. As an incentive for Malcom was not only motivated to make sure he was getting into Harvard, but also was motivated to say out of trouble.
Malcolm’s friends, Jib and Diggy, did not agree with the selling and dealing of dope because it did not agree with their own intrinsic motivators. However, Malcolm’s extrinsic motivators were strong enough to continue selling dope because his family was in danger if discontinued. Therefore, Malcolm had to finish selling the dope and keep him and his mother safe. He was able to write an entrance exam paper to Harvard to apply to the school in hopes he would get excepted.
Terms used:
Intrinsic motivation
Autonomy
Competence
Relatedness
Extrinsic motivation
Negative Reinforcers
Incentives
Dope provides many examples of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. Malcolm is a very intrinsically motivated teen when it comes to getting good grades, getting into college, and making someone out of himself. When getting into college becomes jeopardized, though, he takes many risks in order to stay out of jail, not get shot, and make it through high school and into Harvard. These risks came from the extrinsic motivation of money, incentives, consequences, and staying alive. Throughout the entire it movie, there is the constantly battle with Malcolm between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. After the situation at Dom’s house where Malcolm ends up a load of dope, he struggles with the right decision to make. When he meets with the interviewee for Harvard, he realizes that he must sell this dope or he can kiss his dream of Harvard goodbye. The intrinsic motivation being that his lifelong dream is to go to Harvard, but there is now an incentive present of “do this or kiss your dream goodbye” present, making it an external motivation to sell the drugs.
As the movie progresses, we reach the many scenes consisting of Malcolm and his friends selling the Dope on a website that cannot be tracked by the government by using bitcoins. At first, he is cautious and concerned about this behavior, but he knows it must be done in order to reach the reward of going to Harvard. During this, they begin to make more and more money as they sell the dope, and Malcolm becomes more and more confident in himself. Throughout this process the money he is receiving becomes a positive enforcer, which results in him wanting to keep selling dope to get more money.
The movie also exhibits a good example of a punisher. In Malcolm’s high school, he’s the nerd that dresses goofy, does his homework on time, and is the butt for all the bullies to kick. Malcolm engages in the undesirable behavior of dressing silly and not trying to fit in, and he pays the consequences of listening to the criticisms (punisher) that the bullies throw at him. Internal motivation is also present when Malcolm decides to go to Dom’s party in order to see Nakia, the girl that Dom invited. Malcolm is so persistent on seeing her in the beginning that he finds any way he can to get into the house, with the intrinsic motivation of interest being what drives him to make the irrational decisions that he did, since the higher one’s intrinsic motivation, the more persistence they will be with a certain action or behavior.
By the end of the movie, Malcolm has reached a very high state of autonomy and competence. He has made it through being shot at, selling dope on the internet and not getting caught, and getting into Harvard because he completed the task he was told to do. He now feels very in control of his life and he has learned from his experiences which helps him feel more competent for the future.
Terms: Intrinsic Motivation, Extrinsic Motivation, Consequence, Punisher, Positive Reinforcer, Autonomy, Competence, Persistence.
In Dope, Malcolm (interpreted by Shameik Moore) is a teenager that lives in a poor neighbourhood but has high aspirations in life that make him motivated to do many of the risky things shown in the movie. I would say that Malcolm is both, extrinsically and intrinsically motivated in school. He seems to enjoy school and develops personal interest in playing in the band or writing essays about his favourite 90’s hip hop rappers. We can clearly see the three psychological needs that drive this intrinsic motivation in some examples like 1) autonomy, when he argues with the school counselor about his desire to achieve academic success, 2) competence, when he tries to master his environment by helping Nakia, and 3) relatedness, by fitting in with his two close friends, Jib and Diggy. On the other hand, he is also extrinsically motivated to get good grades in order to go to Harvard. According to chapter 5, extrinsic motivators could undermine the person’s intrinsic motivation toward an activity, but in this case I would say that going to Harvard increases his motivation.
When Malcolm found himself in a life threatening situation, his behavior was extrinsically motivated to avoid the risk of being killed from a gang. After talking with AJ, he had to decide what to do with the drug he has, wether get rid of it or sell it and have a chance to get into Harvard with his help. Malcolm decides selling the drug and is driven by the type of extrinsic motivation called Identified Regulation, where he values and knows the importance of achieving his desired academic goal. The group of three friends, have an external regulation motivation to prepare and try to sell the drug. The successful drug sells act as incentives and positive reinforcers that increase the persistence of their behavior and its future probability. Positive reinforcers release brain dopamine that activates Malcolm, Jib, and Diggy’s Behavioral Activation systems that generate inherently positive feelings like hope and interest. This may be an explanation of why some people do not engage or stay in certain activities that involve risk. As an example, Jib was not sure about continuing with the idea of dealing with illegal behaviors because he could be less sensible to BAS activation and prefer BIS (Behavioral Inhibition System) activation that responds to cues such as negative stimuli or events that involve punishment or frustration, resulting in avoiding risky situations.
In the most important part of the movie, Malcolm decides to ensure his recommendation to Harvard by threatening AJ with the punish of releasing all the information that could make AJ guilty for the drug deal. This situation invalidates AJ’s response cost threat of losing the attractive goal of going to Harvard.
I found surprising and very interesting how Nakia built interest in getting closer to Malcolm. At the beginning of the film, she started feeling a situational interest in him because Malcolm has some novel, surprising characteristics that are relevant to her goals. As the movie goes on, Nakia starts building an individual interest where she develops deeper emotions toward him that apparently, matches with Malcolm's feelings.
Terms used:
Extrinsic motivation
Intrinsic motivation
Autonomy
Competence
Relatedness
Identified regulation
External regulation
Positive reinforcers
Incentives
Dopamine
Behavioral Activation system
Behavioral Inhibition System
Punish
Response cost
Situational Interest
Individual interest
The movie Dope was released in 2015 and is a popularly watched movie on Netflix. The main character is Malcom, in which he goes through many different intrinsic and extrinsic motivational factors. Intrinsic motivation is when we are driven by internal rewards such as how we feel during and after we complete a task. Specific examples of this kind of motivation would be if an individual works out at the gym because it makes them feel proud of their commitment and determination to live a healthier lifestyle. No one has to tell them or force them to go work out at the gym, because it is something that they will want to do anyway. Extrinsic motivation would be if an individual goes to the gym to work out in order to receive compliments from others on their body or if someone paid them to go. There would need to be an external reward or some kind of incentive to work out, because it is not something they just want to do. There are many different scenes throughout this movie where you see Malcom and his friends go through their intrinsic and extrinsic motivations.
One of the most important details about the movie and main character Malcom is that he has a specific dream of getting into Harvard which is his dream school. Having the dream to go to a school like Harvard and working so hard on his academics is a form of intrinsic motivation. Malcom enjoys learning overall and it makes him feel really good about his persistence and determination when it comes to completing projects, essays, exams, etc. As we learned in Chapter 5 intrinsic motivation is responsible for our creativity. Malcom is really into different kinds of fashion styles with vibrant colors and patterns as well as being really into 90’s hip-hop culture. His close friends also enjoy the same things helping the intrinsically motivated side of the argument because it is something him and his friend bond together with. Listening to music and being interested in fashion is something that they love as a group, because it makes them happy and they enjoy it. There is no one that has to force them to engage in these behaviors and they do not get any kind of physical reward for doing so.
Another very important detail about the movie Dope and main character Malcom is that he finds himself caught up with the possession of drugs and a weapon. This started because Dom, a drug dealer, invited Malcom to come to one of his legendary parties if he could get a girl named Nakia to go. Malcom and his friends end up getting into the party and further into the night some rival gang members end up busting the party and shooting. Basically when Malcom goes to school the next day he discovers that Dom had stashed molly and a gun in his backpack. Malcom then gets a call instructing him to bring the stash to a specific location in order to get rid of it. This is an example of extrinsic motivation for Malcom, because the reward for him returning the stash to the owner means safety. It means that he will not get busted for it himself and that he will get to live for not returning it to the police instead. If it were his choice he would probably give it to the police in order to do the right thing and feel good about himself, but there are more important things on the line such as his and his friends lives.
Malcom’s relationship with Nakia could also be seen as intrinsic and extrinsic forms of motivation for a couple different reasons. Malcom volunteers to help her complete her GED and he does this intrinsically, because he loves to learn and help others learn to. He also genuinely cares about her and wants to do what he can to help her be happy. This situation could also be extrinsic motivation, because this could get their relationship closer for her to be his girlfriend. He would feel good about helping someone achieve their dreams as well, but it would be nice to have a girlfriend to show off as a reward. This could also score her as a date for him to go to the prom with. Again this is intrinsic, because it would make him happy to be with her due to the desire and also extrinsic due to having a physical date or girlfriend as an external reward. There are many more scenes that show intrinsic and extrinsic motivation and all could be analyzed well enough to show this distinctively. Malcom spends a lot of time deciding to engage in an action or behavior because it is something he truly enjoys without force or to do something solely because there would be an external reward for doing it.
Terms:
Intrinsic motivation
Extrinsic motivation
Reward
Punishment
Incentives
Consequences
Reinforcement
Persistence
The movie Dope did a great job of portraying examples of intrinsic and extrinsic motivation that was also covered in chapter 5 this week. The movie Dope has an African American teenager named Malcolm, Malcolm is depicted as a teenager who strives to his best ability in his academics, but is also placed in “The Bottoms” in California where going to college is scarce, and is raised by a single mother (who is never depicted in the movie) who seems to always be working to provide for Malcolm. While meeting with his advisor, Malcolm receives negative punishment when his advisor tells him that Malcolm is “pretty arrogant” to so highly of himself and wanting to achieve admission into Harvard University. Malcolm's advisor does, however, put the idea in his head that if he is going to write a statement of purpose, then it should be about Malcolm himself—not Ice Cube. While Malcolm is riding in the car with Nakia he expresses that “he may not be so different from those other …. After all, if he doesn’t get into college.”
The best example from the movie Dope of intrinsic motivation is Malcolm’s SAT scores and grades. Malcolm lives in the projects where the likelihood of someone from the demographic attending college was slim to none, let alone an African American man. Malcolm not only spent time getting good grades to get out of the projects but also because he appeared to genuinely enjoy learning and becoming competent in different areas of the curriculum.
The two types of extrinsic motivation I see predominantly within this film are Nakia, and acceptance into Harvard University. When Dom tells Malcolm to go invite Nakia to Dom’s birthday party, Nakia replied to Malcolm that the only way she would go to the party is if she saw Malcolm at the party. Malcolm was very hesitant and skeptical about going to Dom’s party, as Malcolm knew that Dom was a drug dealer in “The Bottoms”. Malcolm ended up discussing the dilemma with his friends, all three of them went to the party. The only reason that Malcolm was motivated to go the party was so he would see Nakia and be able to dance with her. The second type of extrinsic motivation from the film is Harvard University acceptance. After Malcolm finds out that the man he is interviewing with is a drug lord who also came from “The Bottoms”, Malcolm works to his best abilities to sell all of the Molly using exchange for Bitcoin. The reason Malcolm didn’t just leave the backpack of drugs with Alex Jacoby originally, is because he knew that Alex Jacoby would write Malcolm a phenomenal recommendation letter to Harvard University, where Alex Jacoby was coincidentally an Alumni. After Malcolm had successfully sold all of the drugs, risked his life at gunpoint, and threatened to shoot a group of gang members from his school, Malcolm received his acceptance letter from Harvard. The movie doesn’t come out and say it, but Alex Jacoby’s letter of recommendation played a major role in Malcolm’s acceptance to get out of the projects of California.
ME TERMS:
Negative punishment
Intrinsic motivation
Competence
Extrinsic motivation
WORD COUNT: 520
Chapter 5 talks about Intrinsic and Extrinsic motivation. Intrinsic motivation comes from a desire to succeed and achieve internal awards. Extrinsic motivation comes from a desire to achieve external rewards or to avoid any negative consequences. In the movie Dope, these topics are demonstrated often throughout the film. The main character Malcolm is a very nerdy, geeky kid that lives in California. The main intrinsic motivation for him is to attend Harvard, which is his absolute main goal in life. There are many twists and turns in this movie that introduce extrinsic motivations. These redirections eventually lead up to his main goal of attending Harvard, or at least getting accepted. When an extrinsic motivator is present, the original intrinsic motivator is slowly diminished while the remaining extrinsic motivation is increased. Although there were many extrinsic motivators that were introduced, Malcolm kept his underlying intrinsic thoughts wanting to go to Harvard.
An example of extrinsic motivation in this movie would be selling the molly that came from Dom’s party. During the party, Dom and his friends were selling powdered molly to clients. After a rival gang starts shooting, Dom thinks fast and puts molly and a handgun into Malcolm’s backpack. After later finding out the contents of his own backpack, he feels the need to comply with the intentions of Dom which are selling his molly. This is extrinsic motivation because there are environmental factors that work into his behavior, and not for personal gain. The motivational factor that played the biggest role is the selling of the molly. When Malcolm went to his Harvard interview, AJ told him that in order to receive an invitation to the prestigious school, he must sell the rest of the molly to potential buyers.
Another example of intrinsic motivation is the desire to go the Dom’s party because Nakia would be there, and he might have a thing for her. When we are interested in someone’s overall character, we get intrinsically motivated to see them to fulfill our internal needs. We have an overall longing to be with another human due to our physiological make up. Even though many things happen during the span of Dom’s party including the gang fight and people receiving molly and a gun in their backpacks, his needs were still met by talking to her and getting to hang out. The book states that the higher an individual’s intrinsic motivation, the higher their persistence will be involving that task. These persistent behaviors include continuing the actions that motivate as well as adhering to the needs of others.
This movie overall was very enjoyable and included many terms from this chapter. There was an underlying intrinsic motivator that stayed true throughout the entire movie, while many extrinsic motivators were introduced on top of that. In the end, his intrinsic motivations payed off, and he looks into the camera and smiles after receiving a letter from Harvard. This implies that he received the acceptance letter, proving that his hard work and dedication pulled through.
Terms:
Intrinsic Motivation
Extrinsic Motivation
Needs
Persistence
Reward
The movie Dope is about our lead character Malcolm, and some problems he gets into when he stumbled upon some drugs. This led to him getting into trouble, and having to sell the drugs out of fear of being hurt or killed. He was able to sell the drugs online, and from his emotion at the end it looks like he was accepted into Harvard. He struggles to keep his friendships together, and his grades together as he tries to get out of the drug world and go back to being a hip-hop nerd.
This movie was assigned with ch 5, which discusses intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. He has intrinsic motivation to get into Harvard, which is his dream school and will get him out of the tough areas of town. He studied hard until he was caught in the drug ring, which then took up a lot of time and he was not able to stay awake in class. His motivation was shifted from schoolwork to staying alive, since several people had threatened his life. This form of punishment is known as a negative reinforcer, as they are taking away something, his life. His personality and his drive came from within, which is the key to intrinsic motivation. He also had intrinsic motivation when he was going after Nakia, as he clearly had some interest in her. He helps her with homework, and apologizes after he messes up his opportunity. He is intrinsically motivated by his biological needs, and he finds her attractive.
His extrinsic motivation was his actions after getting involved in the drugs. He followed the leader and did what they told him. Extrinsic motivation is outside sources pushing you to do things, which is what he did. He listened to the counselor and sold the drugs, he almost gave the drugs to the guys in the red El Camino because they told him to, and he stopped because the other drug dealer told him to stop. He was clearly out of his element, so his motivation was to do whatever he thought would get him out of the situation as soon as possible, without getting hurt.
He was very adamant about the drugs not being traceable, and not wanting to get caught because he knew if he was caught he would never get into Harvard. He set up a Bitcoin account and met with some pretty shady people in order to keep himself as safe as possible. This was his positive reinforcement, as he was given something, an chance at college and cash in hand. This was two of his goals colliding and two different types of motivation. He does not want to sell the drugs, but he has to in order to both not get killed and get into Harvard. This is what leads him to do what he is told, when in another situation when not so much is on the line he may have just turned and run away. Getting people invested is one way to motivate them to do what you want, in this case it was sell drugs.
Terms:
Negative reinforcement
Intrinsic motivation
need
Extrinsic motivation
Positive reinforcement
Dope is a modern movie about the journey of three high school individuals, Malcolm, Jib, and Diggy, and their experiences with the drug dealing realm and with racial stereotypes that come with living in his little hometown. In the beginning the drug dealing became an extrinsically motivated task, like pulling a gun on someone to protect drug money to afford school and then towards the movies resolution the drug dealing seized but also is an intrinsically motivated task when Malcolm decided to take his own initiative and rewrite his admission paper to Harvard so that way people would see how great of a kid he is and that he is beyond where he lives. Malcolm seems to find himself as the main character in all of these extrinsically motivated tasks and then turning to intrinsically motivated towards the end.
Extrinsic motivation is an environmentally created reason (incentives or consequences) to engage in an action or activity. Malcolm exhibits many scenes in the movie using extrinsic motivation but one scene in particular that I want to talk about is when Malcolm pulls a gun on the Blood gang that takes his shoes in school. In this scene in particular though is when the gang tried to take Malcolms fake purse and drug money. I say this is an example of extrinsic motivation because AJ told Malcolm he had to sell all the drugs so that way AJ would reward him with trying to get him into Harvard or he would get some form of punishment. If this situation was an intrinsically motivated situation Malcolm would not have had to been threatened or told by an outside source, also known as AJ, to sell the Lily.
Intrinsic motivation is the inherent desire to engage one's interests and to exercise and develop one's capacities. To make this into more simple terms, intrinsic motivation is basically the desire to do things for yourself above all. Malcolm towards the end of the movie only showed this more prevalently. The biggest example was when he decided to change his paper from an Ice Cube thesis statement, to a statement about two students and challenging imagery for racial stereotypes. Malcolm was told by his teacher that he cannot make it to Harvard because of who he is and that Harvard would overlook him. Malcolm throughout the course of the whole movie ignored his teacher and was just going to submit the paper because he wanted to. This would be considered extrinsic motivation for a period of time because his teacher suggested to change his topic but I think it changed from extrinsic motivation to intrinsic motivation because Malcolm changed his paper topic because he wanted to do to what he learned in his academic and drug dealer lives and what racial profiling he has experienced. His new topic addressing the fact that his student A and his student B, while they are both him, don’t match to most stereotypes was a genius topic and it was a positive reinforcement that the teacher ended up helping him in the choice of changing his topic. While the choice was ultimately up to Malcolm I think the right choice was up to him because he ended up making a beautiful piece with his experience that showed his true self and not some person that people can assume about over a piece of paper.
Terms:
Extrinsic Motivation
Intrinsic Motivation
Positive Reinforcement
Reward
Punishment
This week our main focus was to learn about our intrinsic and extrinsic motivation and movie that we were assigned to watch “Dope” was a great example that demonstrates both by showing many great examples. Dope is a 2015, comedy-drama coming-of-age film. This movie shows a group of high school students but Malcolm being the particular and the main character of the movie, who is very motivated to graduate and attend Harvard. Malcolm is portrayed as a 90’s nerd in a modern day who lives in California. Throughout the movie, Malcolm finds himself being in harsh situation that are very complicated and sophisticated. This movie shows great examples of Malcolm being intrinsically and extrinsically motivated regardless of what he’s going through.
According to our textbook, intrinsic motivation can be a motivation where someone feel the need to live their life the way they want and gain proficiency. In the movie Dope, the main character, Malcolm and many of his other friends are playing music in the classroom. This situation can be described them as primary intrinsic because they all are trying to have a good time by what they’re doing and which is also creating a strong bond between all of them. Malcolm seemed to love 90’s music and as we can all tell by the genre of the music is that he likes to listen to the “love” type of music. During the movie, Malcolm gets to meet a girl name Takia, which he happens to be very attracted to. He gets intrinsically motivated to spend more time and talk to Takia since he has romantic feelings towards her. We saw that he was willing to do anything at that point where he could just talk to her so he goes to a party hoping to spend some time with her. But unfortunately, the situation turns kind of upside down where he gets caught in some kind of drug situation that leads him in a fair amount of troubleness.
Malcolm seemed a little helpless and vulnerable when he knows that he has the “ownership” with the drugs but still has no idea how he would get rid of them because he is unfortunately forced to sell them in order to get the money. Being involved in a complicated situation like this, his extrinsic motivation comes outward. Extrinsic motivation can be described or refers to behavior that is driven by external rewards, such as, money, fame, grades and praise. This type of motivation arises from the outside of an individual, as opposed of intrinsic. In the movie, Malcolm’s extrinsic motivation comes from his friend AJ, who encourages him to sell drugs so he’ll have good amount of money to be able to afford going to Harvard. Malcolm knew very well that he needed to do this order to get recommendation letters from AJ, so gets extrinsically motivated to do so. One scene of the film represented Malcolm and his friends being almost robbed by bunch of teenagers. That’s when Malcolm’s intrinsic motivation comes to place when he pulls out a gun and try to prevent the drug money to be stolen so he could successfully deliver that money.
We can tell that there are a couple of scenes where the movie depicts both reward and punishment. According to our textbook, reward can be described as “any offering from one person given to another person in exchange for his or her service or achievement”. Whereas, punishment is supposed to decrease the likelihood of a certain behavior being repeated in the future. Movie shows a scene where Malcolm and AJ discuss about selling drugs to make money. I think this can be a perfect example of a reward and punishment because Malcolm knew that his reward would be getting a nice recommendation letter and a better chance of attending Harvard if he sells all those drugs. But, if he is unsuccessful completing this mission, his punishment would be that he won’t get a recommendation letter which will lessen his chances to get into Harvard. Malcolm knew that selling drugs and jeopardizing his life is the last thing he want to do if he gets caught selling drugs, so he decided to do something that would involve him not selling drug but still get that recommendation letter. Malcolm decides to blackmail AJ with notifying the police about his drugs. This can be an example of punishment and reward system. The punishment in this case was obviously AJ’s reputation and character being ruined while he maintain his own ( which would be an award). As luck would have it, Malcolm’s intrinsic motivation resulted in earning recommendation letter without selling the drugs. It was very fortunate that it all worked out for him since he made a very smart choice, and judging by his smile while reading the letter from Harvard college is a proof of a good outcome of his his good decision.
Terms Used:
Intrinsic Motivation
Extrinsic Motivation
Award
Punishment
External Rewards
Drive
Consequences
Competence
There were many ways that intrinsic and extrinsic motivation were present within this movie. One of the first examples I noticed was concerning Diggy’s visual appearance. Whether she was forced or had a choice, the church tried to extrinsically motivate her to dress and act more like a woman, literally attempting to pray away the gay. The extrinsic motivation was ineffective because Diggy’s intrinsic motivation was to dress like a boy and hang out with boys, which aligned with her sexual identity and overpowered the extrinsic motivation (introjected regulation) attempts.
Diggy, Jib, and Malcom loved ’90s music, which led to intrinsic motivation to dress like they were living in the ’90s, wearing acid-washed clothing and flat bill snapbacks, Malcom even sporting a ’90s flat-top haircut. They seemed to enjoy the autonomy of dressing how they wanted, even though other people (such as Dom) made fun of their look. Awreeoh, Diggy, Jib, and Malcom’s band, seemed to contribute to competence, especially when they played at the Molly party and received a lot of attention. The group also experienced competence when they successfully sold the dope. Relatedness came into play, since Diggy, Jib, and Malcom indulged in the ’90s fashion and music together, contributing to the bonds of their relationship. Together, they were very persistent (tried to get the dope to AJ, then successfully sold all the dope), creative (making music and utilizing the school to package and sell the dope), and had a high level of understanding (hacking AJ’s firewalls and creating an ultimatum that trapped AJ into recommending Malcom for admittance into Harvard).
Examples of extrinsic motivation were easy to identify: Malcom rewriting his essay after Mr. Bailey expressed that he thought Malcom could do better, Malcom hitting the bitcoin exchange man after the bitcoin man kept daring Malcom to hit him, Malcom retrieving his drug-filled backpack from his locker during the SATs when he was fearful of punishers, such as being arrested or expelled, as the drug dogs and cops were walking the halls, etc. It was more challenging to determine whether a motivation was intrinsic or extrinsic when intrinsic motivation was not made completely obvious in the movie. It was particularly challenging to know which motivation was stronger when the situation was sexually motivated. For example, when Jib and Diggy were leaving the house to go eat with Jaleel, Malcom made a choice to stay back with Lily after she practically got naked in front of Malcom. It could have been intrinsic motivation because Malcom really did want to stay with her, hoping for the opportunity for sex. It was also extrinsic motivation/external regulation because Lily was taking her clothes off, creating an incentive for Malcom to stay behind with her. Lily, on the other hand was motivated to tempt Malcom because she was intrinsically motivated by the potential reward of molly.
I particularly enjoyed the scenes from the movie when I could think about Malcom’s decision-making process, like when he was deciding which way to go down the street on his bike. If he went straight, he’d have to ride through a music video, which would not end well; if he went down 104th Street (the cross-street), he’d have to ride past the dope dealers, who would attempt to steal his bike. Although the narrator didn’t say exactly why Malcom chose to take 104th Street, I can assume it’s because Malcom weighed the consequences of each possible scenario, and 104th Street seemed like a safer option.
Terms: intrinsic motivation, extrinsic motivation, incentive, reward, punisher, consequences, external regulation, introjected regulation