Chapter 8
Read chapter 8. Summarize the chapter. What was the most surprising thing you learned? How does the knowledge from this chapter help you to motivate yourself towards desired goals?
Provide a list of terms at the end of your post that you used from the chapter.
Goal setting is a cognitive motivational strategy. Cognitive sources of motivation deal with a person’s way of thinking. This includes beliefs, expectations, goals, plans, judgments, values, and the self-concept. Plans play a large role in cognitive motivation. Everyone has an ideal representation of an event, environmental object, and behavior. We are also aware of our current state of the event, environmental object, and behavior. Incongruity occurs when the ideal event and the present state do not match up. The incongruity makes people act in a way to alleviate the incongruity and have the present state and ideal state coincide. Corrective motivation views plans are more fluid and adjustable. It activates a decision-making process where the individual ponders different options for removing the incongruity. The options typically include change the plan, change the behavior, or abort the plan. Emotions also play a role in corrective motivation. When we move towards the ideal state faster than we expected, we feel positive emotions. When we move towards the ideal state slower than we expected, we experience negative emotions. Discrepancy is another word for incongruity. There are two types of discrepancies: discrepancy reduction and discrepancy creation. In discrepancy reduction, the environment provides an ideal state. It serves as a check for notifying an individual if they are up to par or not. Discrepancy reduction is a corrective motivation form. Discrepancy creation is when a person looks forward and creates a future higher goal. This type of discrepancy does not require feedback in the sense that discrepancy reduction does. Discrepancy creation is a goal-setting motivation form.
A goal is what a person is working to achieve. Goal-performance discrepancy is the incongruity between the present level of accomplishment and the ideal level of accomplishment. People generally perform better when they have goals. As goals become more difficult, performance increases as well. Goal specificity deals with how clearly the goal tells the performer what they need to do. It is important because goals that are specific draws attention to what the person needs to do. Only difficult and specific goals enhance performance because it energizes and directs the behavior of the performer. Another key component to the success of goal-setting is feedback. The performer needs to know their progress in relation to the goal. A third condition of the success of goal-setting is whether or not the performer accepts the goal for themselves. To be accepted, a goal needs to have a reasonable amount of difficulty. The performer needs to help set the goal with a credible authority. There should also be extrinsic incentives. Goal-setting theory is more about increased performance than increased motivation. It is most effective with boring and mundane tasks. Goal-setting is associated with stress, opportunities for failure, and putting intrinsic motivation at risk. Long term goals increase intrinsic motivation.
When striving to achieve goals, one should not focus on the goal because it hinders performance. A person should focus on how the goal would be accomplished. Implementation intention describes a plan to carry out a goal directed behavior. Specific action plans increase the odds of an individual actually accomplishing their goals. Frequent and consistent pairs of situations and goal behaviors creates a strong link between the two.
I was surprised to learn that simply visualizing the goal did not increase the likelihood that the goal would be attained. Visualizing the process of achieving the goal is actually what leads to success. I have been considering exercising more lately. Reading this chapter will help me make a more successful exercise goal.
Terms: Goal setting, Cognitive motivational strategy, plan, incongruity, Corrective motivation, Discrepancy, Discrepancy reduction, Discrepancy creation, Goal, Goal-performance discrepancy, Feedback, Implementation intention
Chapter 8 discussed the topic of goal setting and goal striving. The first thing that the chapter talked about were plans. The essential motivational process that underlies a plan is that people have knowledge of both their present and ideal states and any perceived incongruity between the two makes people uncomfortable enough to formulate and act on a plan of action to remove the incongruity so your present state will be an ideal state. Incongruity kind of acts as a motivational process that provides energy. The chapter then talks about a TOTE model which is how plans are energized how behavior is directed. TOTE stands for test-operate-test-exit. Discrepancy is talked about and it is explained as something that creates a wanting to change the present state so that it will move closer and closer towards an ideal state. There are two types of discrepancy. One type is discrepancy reduction and the other is discrepancy creation. The chapter then goes into talking about goal setting. Some of things that it talks about is that setting goals helps a person achieve certain things than not setting goals. It talks about goal difficulty, feedback, goal acceptance, and criticisms of the goal-setting theory.
The thing that I found most surprising was when they talked about the study of short and long term goals and their impact on intrinsic motivation. On uninteresting tasks, short-term goals create opportunities for positive feedback, the experience of making progress, and means of sense of competence. On interesting tasks, only long term goals facilitate intrinsic motivation. It talks a how people like long term goals better and how it increases intrinsic motivation. I found this surprising because I would think people would prefer short term goals because they are mostly easier than pursuing long term goals.
This chapter will help motivate me better for certain things because I now know that goals are very important. If I set a goal I will improve my performance on whatever task. For example, if I want an A on a test I will set that goal out there and because of that I will study harder and be more likely to achieve that goal. Goals don't mean that I will do better in everything as the chapter talks about but it seems to greatly improve the chance of doing well at something.
Terms: Goal, Plan, Discrepancy, Discrepancy reduction, Discrepancy creation, Feedback, Goal Setting, Goal difficulty, Long-Term goal, Short-Term goal
Chapter 8 focuses around goal setting and goal striving and those differences motivate individuals to set and reach different types of goals throughout their lives.
First, a plan is created with awareness as to what needs to be done and how when reaching a goal. Incongruity helps motivate an individual to act on the plan by providing energy and the actual plan helps us organize ourselves into a state of reaching that plan by providing us direction. This mechanism for directing our planned behavior for different goals is the TOTE model which means to test one’s present state to an ideal state (present being a current state and ideal is the wish-to-be current state), then operate that mismatch of states by taking action and then re-testing the perceived state. If that state reaches the ideal state, then the person will exit this cognitive mechanism, almost acting like homeostasis.
Incongruity leads one to have a ‘corrective’ motivation because an individual, when setting goals, has taken time to figure out how to reduce this present incongruity by either changing the plan, changing the behavior, or withdrawing from a certain plan altogether. It is a dynamic process that helps an individual achieve a plan but to also be prepared to change and revise an ineffective plan to reach that ideal state.
Discrepancy (incongruity) presents two different distinctions: discrepancy reduction and discrepancy creation. Discrepancy reduction is based on receiving feedback about different plans and corrective motivation. It is reactive and helps to overcome deficiency needs. Discrepancy creation is more of a “feed-forward” goal in which the individual sees more positively because they look forward to setting a future plan. This discrepancy is proactive, growth pursuing, and moves forward towards success rather than backwards from feedback. Instead of reading how to get hired for a certain job (discrepancy reduction) one should plan to obtain good quality manners and staying alert with kindness and professionalism before applying (discrepancy creation). When one is in between the present level of reaching the goal and knowing the ideal level needed, it is called goal-performance discrepancy.
Goals should be set to a certain difficulty that the individual is most likely able to reach. Directions on how to reach such goals should be specific, not vague, so the individual can focus specifically at what needs to be done instead of “given a clue” of what needs to be done, such as knowing to “work hard” compared to “use correct vocab and grammar” when writing an assignment. When an individual sets a difficult goal, persistence increases because of continued effort.
Feedback allows information about how different goals should be met and can keep an individual’s interest at key by producing emotional satisfaction through goal attainment and emotional dissatisfaction through goal failure. When feedback is positive and allows the individual to know they are doing well, felt satisfaction occurs. Felt dissatisfaction occurs when feedback is negative and lets the individual know they need to improve certain aspects to reach their plan/goal.
Goal acceptance is another goal need because a goal can be difficult, but if it is too difficult then there is a change the individual will eliminate that goal all together. It is how the performer has a say in the goal needed and if others try to force a goal on them, they are more likely to reject it then if it their opinion and view of the goal was reviewed positively first.
Long-term goals facilitate intrinsic motivation if the task is interesting, such as choosing a major and knowing what job could arise from that career choice. Short-term goals allow more positive feedback to motivate the individual towards a long-term goal that might otherwise seem too difficult to attain through long-term goals. Short-term goals also create the experience of making progress and a means of competence which enhances intrinsic motivation. Another way to enhance intrinsic motivation with goals is to focus on planning and problem solving rather than outcomes. By having an implementation intention (having a plan to carry out one’s goal-directed behavior) will help ease the transition of reaching that goal. In doing so, one can eliminate volitional problems (distractions, setbacks, interruptions, etc) and start creating healthier goal habits.
The most surprising thing I learned from chapter 8 is that when you visualize the outcome of the goal, it does not actually help an individual reach that goal, rather they should visualize on how reaching the goal instead before thinking about outcomes. I now have learned my lesson on dreaming about good grades and should dream about studying instead.
Terms: plan, corrective motivation, discrepancy, felt satisfaction, felt dissatisfaction, goal-performance discrepancy, feedback, goal acceptance, long-term goal setting, short-term goal setting, implementation, goal striving, goal setting
Chapter 8 focused on setting goals and striving for them. It focused on the mental processes that causes us to think and than perform an action. This chapter starts with how cognitve sources are focused solely on a persons way of thinking and acting. Setting goals and achieving them is done by planning and focusing on the right things.
The first thing that chapter 8 focuses on is plans and how they motivate behavior. Every person is aware of their present state, how their behaviors and environment is right now. Everybody also has a dream so to speak about what they wish their behaviors or life is like. When there is a mismatch between someone present state, and someone ideal state, an incongruity has occured. This produces this person to take action, to do something about it. For example if someone's present state is they are a little overweight and their ideal state is to be fit than the incongruity causes them to start working out and watching what they eat. The TOTE Model shows how this phenomenon works. First you test something, than if their is an inconsitency than you operate, or do something to fix it, than you test it again and than operate again. Doing this over and over until it is to your satisfaction and you can exit this cycle. Being able to plan your goal will get you further than others without a goal.
Discrepency creation is when one looks to the future positively and sets a higher goal to achieve what they want. Shooting for a high GPA for example. When setting goals people should make them difficult to create challenge and gives the person energy. Difficult goals also increase persistency because people wanna keep trying until the succeed. Be specific on what exactly you are going to do, each goal should have a direction in what your shooting for (weight loss, GPA etc.)Another thing that will help people attain their goals is to recieve feedback. THis helps people keep track of their progress. For example a mile counter on the treadmill for runners.
Focusing on a goal and not the HOW TO achieve it, can be detrimental. Using mental stimulation you can focus on a planning how to get to your goal and how to solve the problem at hand. Overall the goal pursuit is to start, decide when and name a specific place. This holds someone to their promise to do something. Second, be persistant and prepare for your goal achievment. Lastly, to finish up your goal is to have an intention to finish it.
The thing I found most surprsing was to focus on how to achieve a goal. I never really thought that by focusing and experiencing the joy of the actual goal could hinder the chance of actually reaching the goal. But thinking back when I focused on how to achieve certain goals I was more than likely going to do them than if I just focused on the success of finishing a not yet done goal.
This chapter will help me to focus on how to achieve my goals and to set certain times and places to start achieving for a goal. For example, when I have a paper to do I usually just procrastinate and will get to it. I think after reading this chapter I will start setting specific times to do certain projects and homework. I'm sure it will benefit me in the longrun with having to rush!
Terms: Cognitive sources, Goal setting, Plans, Incongruity, Discrepency Creation, Feedback, Mental Stimulation, Long-term Goal, Short-term Goal, Goal setting
Chapter 8 is titled Goal Setting and Goal Striving. The first concept this chapter mentions is the cognitive perspective on motivation. Cognition can be difficult to define because it an umbrella construct that unites mental constructs such as beliefs, expectations, goals, plans, judgments, values, and the concept of self that function as causal determinants to action. Since cognition is difficult to define, it is often divided into an action sequence. The first part of this sequence is “Plans”. Plans motivate behaviors through mental representations that people have. Mental representations are demonstrated by the ideal state of behavior, environmental objects and events. “Goal setting” is the second part of this sequence. A goal is whatever an individual is striving to accomplish. Goals also generate motivation by focusing people’s attention on the discrepancy and their ideal level of accomplishment. This is identified as a “goal-performance discrepancy”. Within goal-performance discrepancy there are certain concepts to understand and follow if trying to create a legitimate goal. Goal difficulty is how hard a goal is to accomplish. As goals increase in difficulty so does performance. Goal specificity refers to how clearly a goal informs the performer precisely what he is to do. If the performer is unaware of what is expected of them, they are unable to perform as necessary. Difficult, specific goals enhance performance. When a goal is difficult, it energizes the performer. When a goal is direct, the performer can move towards a particular course of action. Feedback is also important with goal setting. It allows people to keep track of progress. Without feedback a person may feel they are working for nothing. Not only does a goal need to be difficult, specific, and receive feedback, but it also needs to be accepted. Four factors that determine whether an externally goal set will be accepted or rejects are 1.) perceived difficulty of the imposed goal 2.) participation in the goal-setting process 3.) credibility of the person assigning the goal 4.) extrinsic incentives. Goal striving is another important step in setting an effective goal. If an individual had no desire to accomplish a goal, they simply would not succeed. Goal striving starts with mental simulations and focusing on a certain action in order to succeed at accomplishing a particular goal. A few problems that can occur with goal-directed behavior are getting started, persisting, and resuming if an interruption occurs. An example of this would be exercising regularly then getting busy with homework and taking a few days off. Once you stop working out it becomes more difficult to start back up and continue working out.
The most surprising thing that I read about in Chapter 8 was in the Criticisms section. It is stated that the first caution associated with goal setting is that its purpose is to enhance performance, not necessarily motivation. This was surprising to me because most people would consider achieving a goal and being motivated to go hand in hand. However, it has more to do with enhancing an individual’s current performance. The second caution was that goal setting works best when tasks are relatively uninteresting and require only a straightforward procedure. This is because the task is generally so uninteresting that it, itself cannot move forward. This was also interesting to me because most goals are typically associated with something that is desirable and needing an enhancement. Both of these were interesting to me because they go against what people would typically assume with goal setting.
This chapter can help me in many ways to achieve future goals. I have learned about this technique of goal setting in Behavior Modification, but in this class it is looked at in a slightly different perspective. I will know to create a goal that is possible to achieve. Make small goals in order to eventually achieve the big goal. I will not get discouraged if I slip up or don’t perform exactly as intended. Instead, I will pull myself together and get back on track. Also, not focusing on the goal, but rather the performance at hand will help me perform my tasks more effectively.
Terms: goal setting, goal striving, cognitive perspective, motivation, construct, mental, beliefs, expectations, goals, plans, judgments, values, self, causal determinants, plans, mental representation, goal setting, accomplishment, goal-performance discrepancy, goal difficulty, goal specificity, feedback, extrinsic incentives, persisting, goal striving, criticisms, enhance performance,
Chapter 8
This chapter is about to cognitive perspective on motivation and how it focuses on mental processes as causal determinants to action. Cognition essentially means action sequence as it refers to the study of motivation. There for four elements in the cognition action sequence. The first two are plans and goals and they rely on discrepancy as their driving motivational force to action. Motivation is explained by highlighting how a person’s present state and ideal state differ when it comes to energy and direct action. There are two types of discrepancies that cause this: discrepancy reduction, which captures the essence of plans and corrective motivation, and discrepancy creation, which captures the essence of goals and the goal-setting process. The book explains that people are readily aware of the present state of their behavior, environment, and status of the events in their life. Along with these, we also envision ideal states for each that allow us to compare our present state to our ideal state. If the two states do not match, we automatically produce a motivation to correct the mismatch and give rise to plan-directed behavior capable for reducing the discrepancy. We either do this by making a plan to advance our present behavior up to the ideal behavior or by revising a plan to move our ideal behavior down towards our present behavior. There are also emotional implications that arise from corrective motivation such as frustration is a person’s progress takes long to reach desired state or a person who progresses faster experiencing positive emotions like enthusiasm. Goals are what we wish to accomplish and when they are difficult or specific, they actually improve performance. Goals that are difficult mobilize effort and increase persistence and goals that are specific direct attention and promote strategic planning. In order for goals to enhance performance, feedback and acceptance are necessary. Feedback allows people to evaluate their performance and determine if it is above or below the goal standard letting dissatisfaction or satisfaction generate the need to improve or set higher goals. Accepting the goal allows the person to accept another’s goal as their own. The improvement in performance does not happen automatically; people have to be persistent and be able to ignore interruptions and stay on track. To do this, people can specify a plan as to when, where, how, and how long they are to act. You are significantly more likely to see positive effects if you specify these implementation intentions in advanced. These intentions allow us to control our actions to anticipated situations, meaning when we encounter something, we know what to do after. The chapter ended by providing 8 steps to help put the overall principles into effective actions which are: specify objective, set goal difficulty, clarify goal specificity, decide when performance will be assessed, check goal acceptance, discuss goal attainment strategies, formulate implementation intentions, and provide performance feedback.
What surprised me while reading chapter 8 was that feedback was one of the two things needed in order to enhance goal performance. I was under the impression that the success that a person experienced when reaching their goals was based on their internal motivation. I thought of it as we were our own worst enemies, meaning that only us as an individual could get in the way of our success and that feedback from our environment was not necessarily important in improving you performance.
Reading this chapter has really motivated to rethink my goals and my plan for achieving them. I think of myself as a very futuristic person because I have known since early on in high school ‘what I wanted to be when I grew up,’ and I have been doing what I have needed to do, school wise to get there. I would like to think that I have enough will-power and persistence to get to where I was to go, but this chapter has given me some insight on addition measures I could take, such as relying more on feedback and my environment to help me improve my performance.
Terms- cognitive, motivation, mental processes, causal determinants, plans, goals, discrepancy, present state, ideal state, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, corrective motivation, goal-setting process, plan-directed behavior, emotional implications, feedback, acceptance
The text has now switched its focus from needs to the cognitive aspects of motivation. Cognitions are mental events. Therefore, cognitive sources of motivation are a person’s ways of thinking and believing that help to determine their behavior. This perspective views mental processes as causal determinants to action. In other words, the cognition causes the action. Chapter 8 covers the following cognitions behind motivation: plans, goals, implementation intentions, and mental simulations.
Plans are the means of organizing our behavior toward the pursuit of our ideal state. Everyone has an ideal state, or how they wish to see themselves, and a present state. When there is a mismatch between one’s present and ideal state, there is an incongruity. Incongruity has motivational prosperities that provide energy for behavior. One way that incongruity works is in the TOTE model. This is the test-operate-test-exit mode, or the cognitive mechanism by which plans energize and direct behavior. The idea is that we will continue to evaluate how our present state relates to our ideal state (test) until the correct changes are made to our behavior (operate). Once the incongruity is gone, the motivation to compare our present state with an ideal state disappears (exit). Since change can be difficult, this can be a very long process (ex: TOTOTOTOTOTOTE). While this model is helpful for understanding how plans motivate behavior, it is static in nature. Current researchers are proposing more flexible models such as corrective motivation. Corrective motivation activates a decision-making process in which the individual considers many different possible ways for reducing the present-ideal incongruity: change the plan, change behavior (increase effort), or withdraw from the plan altogether. The difference in this model is that corrective motivation energizes the individual to pursue the most adaptive course. In other words, the individual has a choice in how to go about addressing the incongruity.
The other point worth mentioning pertaining to plans is discrepancy, which is synonymous with incongruity. There are two types of discrepancies: 1) Discrepancy reduction and 2) discrepancy creation. Discrepancy reduction is based on the discrepancy-detecting feedback that underlies plans and corrective motivation. The environment provides feedback about how the person’s present state relates to the ideal state. This type of discrepancy is reactive and deficiency oriented. On the other hand, there is discrepancy creation, which is based on the “feed-forward” system in which the person looks forward and proactively sets a future, higher goal. This type of discrepancy is proactive and growth pursuing in nature.
The next motivational cognition is goal setting. In simplistic terms, goals are objectives people strive to accomplish. Like plans, goals generate motivation by focusing people’s attention the discrepancy between their present and ideal states. This is called goal-performance discrepancy. In general, goal-performance discrepancies enhance performance. There are two factors that determine performance gains: 1) goal difficulty and 2) goal specificity. Goal difficulty refers to how are a goal is to accomplish. The more difficult a goal is, the more it energizes the performer. In general, there is a linear relationship between goal difficulty and effort. Goal specificity, on the other hand, refers to how clearly a goal informs the performer precisely what s/he is to do. Ultimately, difficult goals energize the person while specific goals direct them toward a particular course of action. It is interesting to note how close this relationship comes to defining motivation itself.
Another component of goal setting that determines success vs. failure is feedback, or the knowledge of the results that allows people to keep track of any progress towards their goal. Feedback provides the emotional component of goal motivation within the experiences of satisfaction or dissatisfaction. Another point worth mentioning that determines performance is goal acceptance. This involves the person’s decision to either accept or reject the goal given to them by an outside source such as a coach or parent. To see enhanced performance, the person must accept the goal.
The last motivational cognition mentioned in the chapter that I will briefly summarize is goal striving. In most cases, there is a large gap between goal-directed thinking and goal-directed behavior. Goal striving looks at the mental simulations that focus on planning and problem solving to attain one’s goal rather than the goal outcome. One such method is implementation intentions, or a plan to carry out one’s goal-directed behavior by deciding in advance how to overcome volitional problems such as getting started or resuming the behavior once interrupted. Implementation intentions facilitate persistence and reengagement during goal pursuit by allowing people to anticipate difficulties.
The most surprising thing I learned about from this chapter related to goal striving and implementation intentions. In general, I am great at setting goals for myself. But what typically happens is that I tend to mess up and then I have a hard time “getting back on the horse”. This is often seen in exercise programs and diets. This part of the goal setting process is often overlooked, which could possibly be why there is such a large discrepancy between goal-directed thoughts and behaviors. It is so easy to come up with an ideal state but when you begin to strive for that state, reality quickly gives you her two cents and lets you know that you are likely to face some obstacles along the way.
I think this chapter will help me a lot in my own goal-setting behaviors because it has helped me highlight some of the areas where I went wrong in the past. One of the issues I run in to is goal specificity. I often make ambiguous goals or unrealistic goals that do not allow for positive feedback or reinforcement. This makes it much harder to continue on with that behavior. The other thing that I have already mentioned is the implementation intentions. I need to start setting concrete start dates for my goals and come up with concrete solutions to the some difficulties that might arise. For instance, if I am craving chocolate the first thing I should do is grab a piece of fruit. By having a concrete plan laid out, I will not have to rely on my depleted cognitive resources later on when I am not as likely to stick with my goal. I feel like this chapter has given me a much clearer idea of what goals I should be setting and how to be persistent in attaining those goals. I will definitely be implementing some of these strategies in my own life.
Terms: cognitions, plans, ideal state, incongruity, TOTE model, corrective motivation, discrepancy, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, goals, goal-performance discrepancy, goal difficulty, goal specificity, feedback, goal acceptance, goal striving, implementation intentions.
Chapter 8 discusses goal setting, goal striving, and the factors than can contribute or harm these processes. The chapter starts out by examining what plans are and how it leads to motivation. People have present and mental representations of the ideal states of their behavior, environmental objects, and events. Therefore, plans energize and direct behavior. The TOTE model illustrates this aspect using a sequence of events, first you compare present state with ideal state, then act on environment to realize ideal state, compare present state with ideal state again, and then determine whether or not the present state is congruent or incongruent with ideal state. It’s important to remember that plans are adjustable. If one is incongruent with ideal state, then the corrective motivation comes into play by using decision-making processes, such as change the plan, change behavior, or withdraw from the plan altogether. The book also discusses a discrepancy model of motivation. When the present state falls short of the ideal state then a discrepancy is exposed, creating the sense of wanting to change the present state in order to get closer to ideal state. There are two types of discrepancy listed, reduction and creation. Next the chapter defines goal setting and its factors. Goal setting enhances performance if people create goals or accept others goals, but it depends on the type of goal. Two factors that affect goal setting are difficulty and specificity. Only goals that are difficult and specific enhance performance. However, other external factors of performance are ability, training, coaching, and resources. Another variable is receiving feedback on performance, which allows people to keep track of progress towards their goal. Goal acceptance is another important aspect of goal setting, which involves the person’s decision either to accept or reject the goal, and only internalized goals improve performance. Despite this, there are still cautions and pitfalls of goal-setting that should be taken into account. Short-term goal setting provides a basis for long-term goals because they create opportunities for feedback. After goal setting, chapter 8 discusses goal striving, which first poses the problem that there is a gap between goal-directed thinking and goal-directed action. Presenting implemental intentions may fix this by setting up environment and behavioral incidents that lead to automatic, environmental control of behavior, thus reducing volition problems. Once the intention is formed the presence of the anticipated situational cue automatically initiates goal-directed action and also facilitates persistence and exclude distractions.
There were a few aspects of goal setting I found surprising and interesting. The main one is that focusing on the goal itself interfered with goal attainment. This surprised me that I had to re-read it. It’s funny how we’re always told to write down our goals and to focus on them, but that’s meaningless. Instead, we should be focusing on HOW to accomplish a goal, not just defining what goal we want. We need to develop a better mental effort to produce goal-directed action.
From my understanding of goal-setting and goal-striving, I am able to use this for my own goals. In my present state, I’m doing average in school. My desired goal is to do above-average in school. According to the book, I must specify this general short-term goal in order to direct me into action. So, my goal is to get a 4.0 this semester. To me, this is a difficult and challenging goal. Because I perceive it as difficult, I will persist through the challenge until the goal is reached. I am able to track my progress throughout the semester by adding up midterm grades, which supports the need for feedback in goal-setting. Now that I’m emotionally satisfied by the feedback, I need to focus on how to accomplish the goal. I can do this by the use of implemental intentions. I plan on setting aside time after work each night (9pm) to study at the library. I will first start on upcoming assignments and tests, and once those are complete continue on to assignments/projects due later on. Gradually, over the week, I’ll be either finished with the work or have a head start on them. I will be able to check my progress of my current state compared to my ideal state by using feedback from quizzes and tests.
TERMS: goal-setting, goal-striving, plans, TOTE model, present state, ideal state, discrepancy-reduction, discrepancy-creation, goal difficulty, goal specificity, feedback, goal acceptance, internalized, short-term goals, long-term goals, goal-directed thinking, goal-directed action, implemental intentions, volition, persistance
Chapter 8 focused on goal setting and goal striving. It first explained that cognition is an umbrella construct that unites mental constructs and self concept as mental events that function as causal determinates to action. This is called the cognition -> action sequence. The 4 elements that make up this sequence are plans, goals, implementation intentions and mental stimlations.
Plans are made when a person imagines an ideal behavior, ideal environmental object or ideal event. When these ideals do not match a present behavior, present environmental object or present event inconguity is instigated. When incongruity is present, it makes a person uncomfortable and motivates them to make a plan to acheive the ideal state. Incongruity provides energy, and a plan becomes the means to the pursuit of the ideal state. A model used to describe this behavior is the TOTE model, or the test-operate-test-exit model. In this model, a performer compares, or tests, their present state with their ideal state. Then the person will acto on their environment to achieve their ideal stae, or operate. They then retest, or compare again, their present state with their ideal state. If incongruity persists, the person goes back to the operate phase. If congruity is present, then the person exits the model. If it takes many tries to achieve congruity, then the model may look more like T-O-T-O-T-O-T-O and so on.
Plan -> action sequence involves four steps. The first is to detece present-deal inconsistencies, then generate a plan to eliminate congruity. The thirsd stip is to instigate plan related behavior and lastly, to monitor feedback. In order to make plans more achievable, they often need to be modifiable. This way, if too many obstacles interfere with the plan it can be revised. Often times, the decision to operate or revise involves emotion. Little emotion is experienced if progress occurs as planned, however negative emotion occurs for slower progress and positive emotions for faster progress.
Descrepency, which is synonymous for incongruity, can be categorized into two types. There is discrepency reduction, which occurs when feedback indicates descrepency. Corrective motivation occurs to reduce descrepency in feedback. Descrepency creation is the second type, which is proactive and a result of goal setting motivation.
People with goals outperform those without, but there are a couple factors that make this true. Goal performance increases directly with goal difficulty. This is because the magnitude of goal-performance descrepency is larger, exciting more energy. Goal specificity, or clarity of goal, also increases performance. In order tom ake a vague goal more specific, generally a numeric value needs to be attached to behavior. Increasing goal specificit reduces ambiguity in thought and performance. Difficult goals enrgize while specific goals direct which enhances performance.
Another crucial factor in goal setting effectiveness is feedback. Feedback dovuments the performer's progress in relation to the goal. This knowledge of progress informs the performer as to whether they are attaining or failing at their goal attempt. Attainment breeds emotional satisfaction, which contributes to discrepency-creating process. Failure breeds dissatisfaction nd contributes to descrepency reducing progress.
Another factor affecting goal performance is goal acceptance. This involves one person attempting to set a goal for another person. Whether this goal is accepted or rejected defines goal acceptance. An externally set goal will be accepted ro rejected due to 4 factors: percieved difficulty of the goal, participation in the goal setting process, credibility of the person assigning the goal and extrinsic incentives. Goal acceptence is inversely related to goal difficulty which is evaluate first. Input in goal is also crucial to goal acceptence. Credibility of goal assigner is defined through trustworthiness, supportiveness, knowledgeability and likeablilty.
There are a couple pitfalls with goal setting. First, short term goals are only effecting in uninteresting and straightforward procedures. Also, stress, oppurtunities for failure, and putting creativity and intrinsic motivation at risk are downfalls of goal setting.
Long term goal setting is most effective when several requisite short term goals are set. Goal proximity affects persistance and intrisic motivation because long term goals often provide insufficient oppurtunities for performance feedback Short term goals that can together add up to the long term goal are more effective. On interesting tasks, only long term goals facilitate intrinsic motivation.
So what causes a person to carry out a goal once it has been set? Implementation is a plan to carry out a goal. It is a plan for goal direction acting to follow goal direction thinking. Goals present several vocational problems; getting started despite destractions, persisting inspite of setbacks and difficulties, and resuming once interruption occurs. Implementation intentions are plans for how a goal will be acted upon. The more difficult the goal, the more important implementation. That way, goal directed behavior is linked to specific situational cues, so behavior is carried out automatically. Overtime, implementation intentions create habits. Goal pursuit is the last component. It involves persisting and finishi, preparing for difficulties, distractions and demands.
I was suprised by how important goal difficulty and specificity are in goal performance. This was especially interesting to me in relation to exercise. I generally have a 'do my best' attitude when it comes to working out. I generally don't set goals either, I just run, walk, bike and lift as comfortable. I think starting now I will set a well defined goals for my workouts.
Terms: feedback, goal attainment, goal specificity, goal difficulty, descrepency, descrepency reduction, descrepency creation, TOTE model, incongruity, cognition, implementation intentions, goal acceptance
Chapter 8 focuses on setting goals, maintaining them, and achieving them. The first part in goal setting is having a plan. Plans give a mental representation of ideal states of behavior, environmental objects, and events. When a person’s ideal state is not being met incongruity arises, generating unpleasant feelings. This forces a person to come up with a plan to relieve the incongruity by achieving their ideal situation. The test-operate-test-exit (TOTE) model explains the theory of incongruity. The model begins with a mismatch of a person’s ideal state and their current state. Because of the mismatch the person acts on the environment to achieve the desired state. The individual then evaluates their action. If the incongruity is gone the action ceases. If the incongruity persists, the action continues. Corrective motivation allows individuals to revise ineffective plans. Discrepancy, another word for incongruence, has two types; discrepancy reduction, and discrepancy creation. Reduction involves an environment that provides feedback on a person’s current performance level and how it matches up with the ideal level. Discrepancy creation involves a person setting a future, higher goal that does not require feedback from the environment. Goal setting is the main focus of the second half of this chapter. A goal is something an individual is trying to accomplish and is generated by motivation from incongruity between their present state and their ideal state. People who set goals achieve higher than those without goals. However there are some specifics to follow in order to succeed in goal setting. Goal difficulty is crucial. A goal must be difficult enough to energize the individual, yet still attainable. A goal must be specific in order for one to know exactly what needs to be done to make progress. Goals that are ambiguous can be interpreted in many different ways, and may not produce the desired outcomes. Feedback is yet another essential part in the goal setting process. Without feedback an individual lacks the ability to track progress. Recognizing progress or regression allows the individual to persist in the goal or to revise it if necessary. Often goals are set someone other than ourselves. With this comes goal acceptance, whether or not the goal is going to be carried out or not. Goal acceptance is high when the goal is easy to accomplish and low when the goal is difficult or forced upon. When given the opportunity to provide input into why a goal is important, goal acceptance increases. Goals can be classified as either long term or short term. Because long term goals offer little opportunities for feedback and positive reinforcement they can be detrimental to a person’s success. It is more beneficial for a person to have a series of short term goals that lead up to the long term goal. Putting goals into action can be described by implementation intentions. A main reason goals are not achieved is because of the lack of planning people put into them. Setting a situational cue to spark action towards a goal is beneficial. When the cue is present it initiates goal-directed behaviors and actions. With implementation action a person is able to persist through difficult patches and finish uncompleted goals.
I think the most surprising thing was that long term goals are generally unsuccessful. I currently have a lot of long term goals that are constantly in the back of my mind. However, sometimes I find myself doing behaviors that aren’t necessarily beneficial towards those goals. For example, I have a long term goal of making it into graduate school at UNI. In order to do so I need to have above average grades. Sometimes I find myself choosing to do other things when I should be studying, therefore resulting in an undesirable grade. If I turn the long term goal into something shorter like getting a 4.0 this semester I will be more successful.
I plan on using this information specifically with setting short term goals, like I stated earlier. I also plan on being more specific with my goals. After reading the chapter I realized many of the goals I have are ambiguous and aren’t measurable. Setting goals that I can track progress with will greater the odds of my success.
Terms: plan, incongruity, test-operate-test-exit model, corrective motivation, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, goal, goal difficulty, goal specificity, feedback, goal acceptance long term goal, short term goal, implementation intentions
In chapter eight, the text explains the process we go though to obtain goals. This includes the planning, the setting of the goals, and actually setting out to achieve the goal. The first section was an overview of planning. We have ideal behaviors and our actual behaviors and when those don’t match- we have incongruity. To fix this we make up new plan of action to be pleased with where we are. This takes form in the Tote model (Test, Operate, Test, Exit) The test phase is when the comparison is made, operation is when an action is made to the ideal self, and exit is when the person is satisfied. More modern researchers now believe in corrective motivation in planning one’s behavior. This concept involves one’s act of attempting to reach their ideal self and the changes that may need to take place in the tentative plan. Emotions also play a large role in corrective motivation. When positive emotions are involved, they can progress more rapidly towards their ideal self, but the opposite happens when negative emotions are in place. It has been found that the discrepancy is what causes the motivation between the ideal self and the actual self. There are two types of discrepancy (discrepancy reduction and discrepancy creation). Discrepancy reduction is a direct comparison from feedback received from the environment and how one’s performance level matches with the ideal level. This is more of a “plan-based corrective motivation” whereas the creation is goal-setting motivation. The second, discrepancy creation, focuses on the future and setting goals for that time frame and as a higher goal.
Another important topic in this chapter is goals. Goals make people motivated by making them focus on their discrepancies. Individuals with goals outperform people without goals and outperform themselves when they do not set goals. It has also been found that the difficulty of the goal matters. The more difficult the goal—the more effort one will put into achieving it. Specificity also is very important in goal setting. The more specific it is, the easier it will be to focus on it and not on other non-important or non-related things. Only difficult and specific goals will better someone’s performance. The performance has also showed to be affected by the ability, coaches, training, and resources as well as ones motivation.
Feedback is also very important when it comes to goals and performance. Feedback is what an individual receives back after a performance to see how they are doing in terms of their goal. Individuals need feedback in a timely manner to feel involved and care about their goal and how they are doing. They need feedback to be able to compare to their goal to see comparatively where they are in terms of their goal. The feedback can serve the individual with emotions that can drive their motivation even more. If they are not where they would like to be at, they will feel negative emotion, which will create a bigger effort into the goal.
For a goal to be obtained, the person needs to accept it. Individuals have evaluate the following before an external goal can be accepted: the believed difficulty, the participation they had in setting the goal, the credibility of the person setting the goal and the extrinsic incentives that come along with the goal.
Another important step in this process is obtaining the goal. It has been found that outcome simulation (focusing on the goal) is not as productive in achieving the goal as process simulation (focusing on implementing). When a person only focuses on the end all goal and not the process to get there is gives them a sense of false hope. The main tool one needs is implementation. Individuals need to have a plan when the set a goal; they need to know the specifics. Getting started, persisting, and resuming the goal are all important in obtaining goals.
The most surprising thing that I learned in this chapter was that the more difficult the tasks were the better the performance would be. I thought I remembered learning in a previous class of mine that if the task or goal were too difficult that it would diminish effort in the individual.
This chapter helps me in general because I don’t set myself a lot of goals. Growing up there were just the general goals: pass each grade level, eat all the vegetables at meals, go out and complete a new sport. Other than those, I was never told to make myself goals. This chapter shows me that setting goals will help me be more successful and have better performance overall.
Terms: Tote Model, Corrective motivation, discrepancy, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, goals, specific goals, difficult goals, feedback, goal setting, outcome simulation, process simulation, implementation
Chapter 8 focuses on goal setting and goal striving. The three main topics that the book goes into depth about are plans, goal setting, goal striving, and then putting them all together. The first topic that is mentioned in the text is plans.
A plan is something that an individual has in mind at a certain time that can be used to achieve a purpose or goal. It explains that in many situations in life, people have a set plan in their head. The book gives an example saying that people have a set plan for many things such as how to serve a tennis ball, what we are going to get our friend for their birthday and what they might have planned, such as an event. Something that goes along with a plan would be a cognitive mechanism in which a plan in energized. This is called the test-operate-test-exit or the TOTE. The book shows a picture of what this is which was definitely helpful since I am more of a visual learner. It shows that first we test something to compare it to something else. We then operate the act on the environment. Third, we test again to compare to that present state, and then we can decide to exit. If whatever it is matches our ideal of a plan, then we exit and move on. The example from the book that helped me consider this concept was with the painter. The painter paints something, compares it to their ideal mind set, it is works then the painter continues. When the actual painting match the painters plan or mind set then he can exit and stop painting. Another issue that relates to plan would be corrective motivation. In this, corrective motivation activates a behavior of decision making where an individual looks at other possible ways to reduce incongruity. In this a person can change the plan and/or behavior.
The next topic that was explained in this chapter would be goal setting. It first explains what a goal is. A goal is something that an individual is looking to accomplish. It can really be anything. Right now I have a goal of raising my GPA. Some other examples of goal setting could be to lose weight, run a race, get straight A’s, etc. It is stated that people who have goals, and set goals are more likely to achieve them and outperform people who had not set a goal. A goal increase motivation towards something. Yet, there can be difference between the difficulties of the goals. Some goal can be easier than others. It states that the more difficult the goal, the more motivation and energy you have. If your goal is hard, you will want to prove to yourself more that you can do it (or that’s how it is for me). For example, I am going to be running in two 5K’s in the next couple of months. This is a goal for me, but another goal I could have is to run a marathon after that. Obviously running a marathon will be a harder/larger goal than a 5K. Also, like I have learned in my behavior modification class, the goal needs to be specific! If it’s not, it is harder to achieve. The book also stated that goals have to be specific and difficult for us to really enhance our performance. Long term goal settings and some of the criticisms were also explained.
The third topic that the book explained would be goal striving. For example, if a person has not real motivation, and no desire to achieve the goal, then you will most likely not. You have to want it to reach it! A big reason why people do not achieve goes too is because they give up to early, or do not have a specific way they are going to attain that goal. You need to plan out step by step what you are going to do. The book also mentioned implementation intentions. This is the study of how your goals are acted out effectively. This is looked at when examining goals and motivation
I thought that the criticisms section was one of the most interesting parts of the chapter. When I think about achieving goals, I think of something positive. Yet when I hear the word criticism I think of something negative. I thought it was interesting that there are many criticisms to goal setting and striving. The goal setting theory states that it is more about enhancing some ones performance, not motivation. One of the most interested parts was when it stating that tasks that are interesting, and involve problem solving does not enhance your performance. I thought that something like that would. Obviously it would increase your motivation because it is a difficult task that you have just now achieved, but I thought maybe it would increase performance as well. If you are more motivated, I would think performance level would increase.
This chapter has definitely informed me on how to achieve my goals in a more timely manner. I have a couple goals right now that I would love to achieve, and the information from this chapter has helped me with that. It helped me understand my short term goals, such as getting an A on my test next week, to my long term goals, such as preparing for a race that’s over a year away. A lot of this information was an overview of what I have already learned in a previous class, but it was good to freshen up on the information since I had forgotten quite a bit. After reading this chapter, it has made me up to set up some new goals for the future. I will now not only focus on what the goal is, but how to get there step by step.
TERMS: goal setting, goal striving, plan, cognitive mechanism, test-operate-test-exit (TOTE), corrective motivation, incongruity, motivation, performance, goal difficulty, implementation intentions, goal setting theory, short term goals, long term goals
I found chapter 8 to be very interesting because it was easy to think about my own goals and apply the concepts. The chapter begins by describing the cognitive perspective on motivation. Since cognitions are mental events, motivation revolves around the way a person thinks or believes. This is where plans and goals come into play. An incongruity in plans (the way you see something and the way it actually is) causes a person to employ the test-operate-test-exit model (TOTE). This model refers to the tendency to look at a situation and compare it to the ideal. If the two are mismatched, a person will then operate, or perform an action to get the situation to the ideal form. This process can go on for long periods of time until an ideal is reached. The two types of discrepancy highlighted are discrepancy reduction; when feedback is provided in terms of the goal and discrepancy creation; when a person proactively sets a higher, future goal.
The main focus of the chapter was on goals, whatever the individual is striving to accomplish. I found it very interesting that in order for goals to be effective they must be 1) difficult 2) specific and 3) provide feedback. Another thing I found interesting was that a downside of goals is that they can inhibit intrinsic motivation. We learned in a previous chapter that extrinsic motivators, such as money, can also inhibit ones desire to engage in a certain activity. In terms of what we learned before, it would stand to reason that goals that are administered in a controlling way could have the same affect.
This chapter was very helpful in understand why some goals succeed while others fail. What I will take away from it is that focusing on the steps to attain a goal, not focusing on the goal itself, will be more productive in the long run. I have always been a person that believed that if you focused on something you wanted and made the steps to get there, you would eventually accomplish what you set out for. What I will do differently now is set out implementation intentions to better help me achieve each small step to accomplish my final goal. The chapter stated that those who do have implementation intentions are far more likely to act on them and achieve their goals.
Terms: cognitions, plans, TOTE, discrepancies (reduction & creation), goals, difficulty, specific, feedback, implementation intentions
The chapter discussed the discrepancy between a current state of affairs and an ideal state of affairs as being the source of corrective motivation. Corrective motivation (the desire to alleviate the current discrepancy) leads to a decision making process where alternative plans for achieving a more ideal state are considered. Two types of discrepancy are discussed: discrepancy reduction and discrepancy creation. According to Reeve, in discrepancy reduction, feedback from an environmental factor (e.g., supervisor, teacher, performance measure) regarding the current state triggers the corrective motivation; whereas in discrepancy creation, the individual creates the discrepancy by setting a new, higher goal for him- or herself.
Discrepancies involve goals: either those set by others or those we set for ourselves. Reeve said that individuals with goals perform better than those without goals, and individuals with specific, difficult (but acceptable) goals perform better than those with easy, vague goals.
Performance is not contingent solely upon goal-directed motivation, however: ability (e.g., competence, resources, prerequisite attributes) and timely feedback (i.e., information regarding one’s progress toward a goal) also play a part. Feedback can generate emotions which are also strong motivators: the satisfaction one feels when one is performing well promotes discrepancy-creation (as the individual sets higher goals for him- or herself), whereas the dissatisfaction one feels when performing poorly promotes discrepancy-reduction (as the individual strives to meet the goal).
In addition to feedback, the individual’s view of the acceptability of the goal also impacts performance. Acceptability is affected by four factors: 1) perceived difficulty (whether the goal is considered achievable or unreasonable); 2) participation in the goal-setting process (which satisfies the psychological need for autonomy); 3) credibility of the person setting the goal (which helps the individual to internalize the goal, once again promoting the sense of autonomy); and 4) extrinsic incentives (perceived benefits of attaining the goal).
Now that the reader is convinced that goal-setting is the key to improving motivation, Reeve explains that goal-setting is actually the key to improving performance, not motivation. It also works best when tasks performed are relatively uninteresting and straightforward. Reeve described three pitfalls associated with goal-setting: 1) stress (when goals are too difficult); 2) opportunities for failure (again, when goals are too difficult); and 3) putting creativity and intrinsic motivation at risk (when goals interfere with one’s autonomy, cognitive flexibility, and personal passion for the work).
The nature of the task and the ratio of positive reinforcement and performance feedback to goal proximity also affect persistence and intrinsic motivation. Short-term goals, having more timely feedback and more immediate positive reinforcement, may increase intrinsic motivation for performing uninteresting tasks; yet (as above) they may undermine intrinsic motivation when performing interesting, creative, or exceedingly difficult tasks. Long-term goals (having less timely opportunities for feedback and delayed positive reinforcement) can either increase or decrease intrinsic motivation for uninteresting tasks; but only long-term goals can increase intrinsic motivation for performing interesting tasks.
And now that the reader is convinced that goal-setting is the key to performance, Reeve explains that it is actually performance planning, not goal-setting, that improves performance. This brings us back to the beginning of the chapter, where Reeve said that “suffering incongruity,” (i.e., a discrepancy between the current state and the ideal state), “people formulate a plan to remove that incongruity” (207). Reeve said that the effectiveness of such a plan hinges on an ‘implementation intention’ (a plan for implementing the plan to achieve a goal, if I’m reading this correctly), which can increase motivation by tying the goal-directed behavior to situational cues without further conscious deliberation (I think that this would be considered operant conditioning). Example: “I want to get an A (goal), so I am going to work hard (plan): I will study from 3pm to 6pm every night (implementation intention, tied to a specific recurring time).” Thus, behavior is modified by the implementation intention so that the individual will begin the activity when triggered by situational cues, and resume the activity if interrupted following the TOTE model.
The most surprising thing I learned was that there was a blog due for this chapter tonight, since it wasn’t posted until 3:10pm (when I was posting my ‘Social Needs’ blog for 2/23, which was also unexpected). Since there are only 13 posts as of 11:30pm, I’m guessing it was/will be a surprise to others, as well.
I think that I can relate some of the material from the chapter to my own goal-pursuing behaviors. I have a long-term goal (working with other disabled vets at the VA) which can be broken down into intermediate goals (attending and completing the MA in Rehabilitation & Mental Health Counseling program at UI) which can be broken down into short-term goals (get some background in psychology, take the GRE, get accepted into the program). Being intrinsically motivated toward my long-term goal, I chafe at the restrictions of some of the short-term goals, but I keep looking for the light at the end of the tunnel (while I may still have to jump through hoops, I am hopeful that they will at least be interesting hoops). Discovering a way to be more motivated regarding the short-term goals (in addition to good study habits, which only afford the opportunity to learn) would be helpful.
Terms: corrective motivation, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, feedback, goals, goal-directed motivation, autonomy, extrinsic incentives, intrinsic motivation, positive reinforcement, implementation intention, operant conditioning, TOTE model
Chapter 8 teaches us about goal setting and goal striving. The main subtopics are plans, goal setting, goal striving, and making them all work together. The chapter begins by explaining plans. Plans motivate behaviors. People have mental representations of the ideal states of their behavior, environmental objects, and events. In simpler terms, people know what they want their outcome to look like and they know where they are in their current state of reaching their goal. If these things don’t match up it causes incongruity. A good way to help understand plans is the TOTE model. Test compares present state with ideal state. Operate means to act on environment to realize ideal state. Test means to compare present state with ideal state. And Exit means the present state in congruity with ideal state. Plans can be long term or short term, but if you follow the tote model it can help you reach your ultimate goal.
A goal is something an individual is striving to accomplish. Goal setting is important to have to reach a goal. Right now I have a goal set to graduate in May of 2013. Lots of goals are made each day by different people. There can be long-term goal setting or short-term goal setting. It is said that people who set goals outperform those without goals. Some goals are harder than others, but it is always good to have some goal in mind for yourself in your every day life.
The next topic is goal striving. People have to want to reach their goals and work towards them to make anything happen or accomplish something. People need to reach their goals by taking things step-by-step. Some people overwhelm themselves with a large goal and don’t know how to go about accomplishing it so they give up because it seems to be too much for them to handle. Goals need to be specific and have feedback. A good way to do this is by using implementation intentions, which is focusing/visualizing your goals.
The most surprising thing I learned in this chapter was that I control my outcome more than I know. Taking baby steps is key if I want to reach my goals. I need to tackle smaller portions of my goals at a time so I don’t become stressed and give up. I was also surprised that goal-setting can have pitfalls. In my mind goals are always good. A person can set a goal that is not capable for them to make and that can be largely discouraging. I like to live in the dream-world where everything is possible!
By reading this chapter it has helped me to slim down my own personal goals and focus on smaller parts so I am not so stressed. I need to take one class at a time and focus on assignments individually instead of thinking ahead so much. It may also be a good idea for me to right down my goals week by week or day by day so I can see the accomplishments I am making to reach my end goals. I also have also made new goals for myself because I know I can manage and reach them.
Terms: goal setting, goals striving, test-operate-test-exit (TOTE), implementation intentions, short term goals, long terms goals, plans
This chapter focused on goal setting and goal striving. Motivation uses mental processes that push our cognition into an action. If you break down that sequence we can look at plans, goals, implementation intentions, and mental simulations. Everyone makes plans based off an ideal behavior (for example, a perfect tennis serve). When incongruity occurs, this means there is a difference between a person's present state and their ideal state. This might make a person uncomfortable to move forward towards an action or ideal state. There are 2 types of discrepancy (or incongruity), the first is discrepancy reduction which underlies plans and corrects motivation. An environmental influence pushes them to do better. For example, to be eligible for a scholarship one is required to have a certain GPA, but they are below the requirements and can't apply. The second type of discrepancy is discrepancy creation. This is when a person is proactive and looks into the future setting more goals. Using the same example, the student might try to raise his/her GPA to become eligible for the scholarship.
A goal is something that an individual is striving to accomplish. Goals generate motivation by focusing on the discrepancy. This ideal level of accomplishment is referred to as goal-performance discrepancy. People who set goals perform better than when no goals are set. It is also known that more difficult goals increase the goal performance, it energizes the performer and stimulates their emotions. Lastly, when a goal is specific an increase in performance can be seen as well. Most of the time it serves as a guideline and checkpoints to help finish out the goal. For example, a professor tells students there is a paper due in a month. By week 1 he wants a rough draft, week 3 he wants revised drafts, and week 4 you turn in the paper. The specificity of the assignment helps you stay focused on the task.
Lastly, the book discussed goal striving. This the action you take to fulfill your goals, but it is easier said than done sometimes. Mental fantasies can get in the way and make a goal further out of reach than originally thought. Implementation intention is a plan to carry out a goal directed behavior and deciding in advance of a goal striving event. If one plans the goal striving process it will help them with the goal performance as well. Your goal needs to be specific and you have to want it for this to work. Putting everything together, a person needs to decide in advance when and where they will enact goal directed behaviors. Once the pursuit of a goal starts people often find it more difficult to carry through than expected. But again, implementation intentions can be set and help with the persistence needed to carry though. It helps a person anticipate the difficulties they may have. It deters a person from distractions.
What surprised me the most in this chapter was implementation intentions can be set and recognized and I can push myself to accomplish a goal knowing the difficulties I may have with it in the future. It seems really weird that I can blatantly tell myself to exercise and plan out a daily schedule for myself I will follow my goal a lot better. It just seemed so simple like I should have known this would have worked better than producing false hope in a weekly schedule instead of daily.
I am definitely using this to my advantage. I really have taken strides to be more active this semester but then I get busy with school and I kick exercise to the curb first because it isn't something I absolutely need to do. I want to do it, but getting myself to actually take part in the behavior exhausts me. Now knowing this I think I am going to write myself a note - and write my goal down. Just something daily in my planner that I can cross off my list along with my school work. If I make this only a daily goal I will continue to feel like I did accomplish a reasonable task and overtime it should become easier for me to do without cringing. I also plan to make it specific - this will help me follow through as well. If I write out exactly what my workout will be it will help me just go and do it instead of pondering what I should do. Overall I found this chapter to be helpful and understand a different way to think about achieving more things.
TERMS: cognition, plans, goals, implementation intentions, mental stimulation, incongruity, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, goal, goal setting, goal striving
Chapter eight discusses goal setting (creating a desired point to strive for) and goal striving (persistence to continue pursuit). A goal is something an individual tries to accomplish and is more successful if a plan is used. Plans are based on desired changes to one’s actual behavior, events, or environment to match their ideal behavior by reducing discrepancy (a mismatch between one’s ideal and actual behavior, environment, or events). This process can be described with the test-operate-test-exit (TOTE) model, in which someone tests their current status, operates or changes it, retests it to match their ideals, and exits the changing behavior (if their ideals are match with their actual situations). However, a more contemporary model adds that one’s operations may be possibly changed, creating many possible solutions. For instance, I want more money. At first, I try to save my money by spending less, but my ideal situation is not met. So, I change by operation to working a job to make more money, but that doesn’t meet my ideal situation either. Finally, I ask my parents for more money, and I find that my ideal situation is met with that course of action.
Discrepancy can be categorized as discrepancy reduction (evaluate with environmental standards to satisfy deficit need) or discrepancy creation (use a feed-forward system to reach for higher goals to satisfy growth needs). When setting goals to overcome either, one must clearly define the difficulty and specificity to perform better. The difficulty will energize behavior to increase effort and persistence, and the specificity will direct behavior to increase attention and strategy. However, one must also account for their own abilities and resources when considering goals. Aside from defining the levels of specificity and difficulty, one must also be provided feedback to reinsure progress toward their goal. For instance, I may get better at basketball by playing people slightly better than me and trying to score a set amount of points, but I will never have the ability or resources to make the NBA. Furthermore, goals depend as much on feedback as feedback does on goals, because feedback needs a standard of performance to let us know the extent of what levels are considered positive feedback and which negative.
People often receive help to create the goals to pursue. However, they must have goal acceptance, so the pursuit is even worth trying. Goal acceptance comes from the perceived difficulty of the task, the participation the person has in making it (helps create an autonomy-supportive environment), the credibility of the goal assigner, and the extrinsic incentives that come with the goal. However, goal-setting has its criticisms. It tends to increase performance but not necessarily motivation, it tends to only work for tedious tasks (however, long-term goal setting has been shown to be successful with interesting tasks), and it may undermine intrinsic motivation if put into an autonomy-controlling context. In spite of these disadvantages, goal-setting can be a successful way to get through unwanted tasks (exercising, homework, etc.), and may help with long-term goals.
Goal striving describes the persistence necessary to overcome difficulties while pursuing goals. A major practice that helps with goal striving is focusing on the strategy to complete the goal, and not the outcome of the goal. For instance, I should focus on walking a certain amount every day and eating so many calories to lose weight, and not focus on being ripped. Implementation intentions also help goal striving by increasing persistence from anticipating future problems.
I was surprised by the difference made by specificity and difficulty. After reading, it made sense that using an objective standard could increase one’s effort, plus it also gives the pursuer feedback and something to strive for. Difficultly continues to surprise me, because I wouldn’t think that one would constantly be pursuing difficult tasks on account of getting discouraged or burned out. However, it makes sense to challenge one’s self to improve. This chapter is applicable to toward real life, because we all have goals. For instance, I now know I should set specific workout plans and gradually increase their intensity when I want to work out again. I can also use this for applying to graduate school (goals for grades, observation hours, extra social activities, and visits). Furthermore, I got some tips for keeping my head in the game when the pursuit is getting tough (goal striving), such as anticipating future obstacles and focusing on the strategy not the outcome.
Terms: goal setting, goal striving, goal, plans, discrepancy, TOTE model, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, deficiency need, growth need, difficulty, specificity, feedback, effort, persistence, goal-acceptance, incentives, intrinsic motivation, autonomy-controlling environment, implementation intentions
Chapter eight is about how we make plans and set goals. We learn how people construct these plans and goals and how they go about carrying them out. This is done from the cognitive perspective on motivation where we focus on how mental thoughts become actions and plans. Goals were first studied in the 1960’s with the test-operate-test-exit model (TOTE). This tells us that if there is a mismatch between what our current state is and what we perceive as an ideal state, we are moved to operate towards correcting this incongruity. An incongruity simple means a difference between two perceptions. Another term that is more aptly used to replace incongruity is discrepancy. A cognitive discrepancy between our plans and goals with the current reality motivates us to act to reduce the discrepancy. Discrepancy reduction is our attempt to make our reality better fit or move towards our plans and goals. We can also set goals that cannot no be seen or achieved at the present time. This is discrepancy creation. Discrepancy creation allows us to set future goals that are not currently relying on feedback from the environment.
Corrective motivation is generate by detecting the discrepancies and incongruities in our present state and our ideal state. Since our plan of action tends to be in constant flux it can be seen as dynamic in nature. Therefore, we are constantly evaluating our present versus ideal state detecting differences throughout the process. So we are constantly tweaking our plans and actions when we perceive incongruities allowing for corrective motivation throughout the entire goal setting and achieving process.
There are several differences between short-term and long-term goals besides the time frames. Long-term goals are usually involve the attainment of several short-term goals along the way. Long-term goals require greater persistence and rely more on intrinsic motivation and are thought of as more cognitively complex in structure. Short-term goals are usually more specific and targeted upon behavior. For uninteresting tasks, short-term goals can create positive feedback and enhance competence, which increases intrinsic motivation. For interesting tasks only long-term goals enhance intrinsic motivation as short-term goals are perceived as boring and getting in the way as they already have a high sense of competence over the task.
In general those who set goals perform better than those who do not set goals. Setting goals that are both difficult and specific tend to enhance outcomes. Feedback is what we learn about how current efforts are doing. This allows us to track our progress towards our goal. Feedback also improves performance and outcomes by further motivating our efforts. The final piece to enhance performance is goal acceptance. This allows us to either accept or reject our goal. If we end up accepting our goal it motivates us to have more of a commitment to it. Goal strivings are what people are trying to do throughout their lives.
The most surprising thing I learned by reading this chapter was the realization that I do not and have never set long term goals in my life. I tend to focus on what is task at hand and what I need to accomplish in the short-term and leave the rest up to happen. I am comfortable with the life and my outlook on life without long-term goals. I instead live by a personal value system had make decisions based on this and let life happen as it will. I do not know if this makes me odd but I do not plan on changing how I approach life.
The knowledge from the chapter will motivate me to construct more meaningful, relevant, and achievable goals. I have learned from this chapter to make goals that are both difficult and specific and look for feedback to reinforce goal achievement. I will to incorporate implementation intentions in order to increase the likelihood that I will stick with action and see it through.
Terms: the test-operate-test-exit model (TOTE), incongruity, discrepancy, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, corrective motivation, long-term goals, short-term goals, feedback, goal acceptance, goal strivings, implementation intentions
Chapter 8 focus' on cognition. Cognition is the mental events happening in our head. Cognition motivation comes from our thinking and believing. Plan, is one of the first stages in motivation. Plans motivate behavior. There are two different "states" that are part of the plan motivation. There is an ideal state (where you would like to be)and a present state (where you currently are). These states play a big part in motivation. If you are someone who becomes motivated using your ideal state than you have something to work for. Corrective motivation comes after plan. Corrective motivation detects present-ideal inconsistencies and then generates a plan to get rid of the inconsistencies. It then starts a decision making process in which you can decide what plan of action to take to reduce the present-ideal inconsistencies. There are two types of discrepancies. The first one is discrepancy reduction; which is detecting feedback that underlies plans and motivation. The second type is discrepancy creation; which is when a person looks forward to to setting higher goals. Goal setting comes into play whenever an individual wants to accomplish something. Feedback can be helpful when you are trying to accomplish a goal. That way you can watch your progress. Some say that feedback is just information but I think it's important to have feedback when you are trying to achieve your goals. Goal striving becomes handy when you are focusing on an action plan. You want to focus on the goal you are trying to achieve and find out how you are going to attain that goal. Once you have set a goal it's not going to achieve itself. You have to find the motivation to accomplish your goal.
The most surprising part of this chapter to me was that most people have trouble getting started because people have trouble translating their plan into action. To me, that's surprising because when I have a goal I am motivated right away to get it started. I thought most people had trouble finishing their goal because they had too high of standards or something along those lines.
I learned a lot from this chapter. I found out that to start and achieve a goal it's best to make a plan of action. I usually just go with the flow and see what happens. Also, I learned that their was a eight step program to effective goal- setting. I might have to test that out the next time I make a goal for myself. I think it's important for everyone to have some sort of goal in life. That way you can feel accomplished about yourself and what you have done in life. This chapter has been very helpful and I think it will become very useful in life.
Terms: Cognition motivation, Plan, Ideal state/Present state, Corrective Motivation, Discrepancy reduction, Discrepancy creation, Goal setting, Feedback, Goal striving
The chapter on goal setting was very interesting. It first talked about plans. People know what their present state is (where they are at now) and what their ideal state is (where they want to be) and the discrepancy between the two springs a person to action to make a plan on how to get to their ideal state. For example if someone weighs 150lbs (present state) and wants to be 135 lbs (ideal state) they have to make a plan on how to get to their ideal state. There cant just be the want, there has to be a plan from one state to the next.
This is where corrective motivation comes into play. This turns the plan into a decision making process where the individual looks at all the different possibilities to get from the present state to the ideal state. One could exercise to get there, one could starve, one could eat more healthy, one could take diet pills, etc. but there has to be a corrective motivation decision to get them there. The person also has to get rid of the discrepancies that are stopping them from getting to the ideal state. Eating healthy is expensive, exercising takes time and energy, starving makes you feel really hungry etc.
A goal is whatever an individual wants to accomplish. Like plans, goals generate motivation. There are a few things that make goals attainable. One of them is goal difficulty, as the goals difficulty increases, the performance increases. This was the most surprising thing to me in this chapter. I would have thought that easier goals would be easier to reach, but that is not the case. The other thing is goal specificity. How clearly set a goal is, the easier it is to reach it. I know this from experience. When I wanted to lose weight, just having that goal, I never seemed to reach it, but once I said I want to lose this many lbs and this many inches by this date, it was much more attainable. Feedback is also crucial in goal setting. This feedback has to be timely and relate specifically to the goal. If someone’s goal is to get a 4.0, they have to see their grades for every test and paper, hear from their professors that they are doing well, etc. If not, the goal and performance can seem unimportant and uninvolving. The person wont know what their GPA is until the end of the semester, and therefore not focused on it during the semester as much.
Goal acceptance is also crucial. The person setting the goal must accept the goal. If a parent is pushing their child to go to a specific school, so that person applies to that school, he or she has not really accomplished the goal if he or she never really accepted that goal. I have seen this a lot working with teens, their parents want them to do something, such as complete a program we are doing, and once they complete, the parent feels like they have accomplished something, but the teen didn’t really want to do it in the first place, so for them, regardless what they tell their parent, it isn’t an accomplishment.
There are a few other parts to goal setting such as criticisms and long term goal setting. There is stress in setting goals, there is the opportunity for failure and there is the persistence and attention it takes to complete a goal. These can all become difficult after a certain amount of time. Setting a goal out too far may also be distracting, such as someone wanting to become a doctor or to go on their dream vacation that is going to take them 8 years to save up for. There must be smaller goals on the way to this long term goal.
This chapter really makes me look at my goals in life and making sure I am creating an effective goal setting program. I think I am really good and setting and achieving short term goals, but there are things I say are my goals for in five years, that I cant say what I am doing right now to work towards, so after reading this, I am going to do some reevaluating.
Terms used: Goal, present state, ideal state, plan, discrepancy, feedback, goal acceptance, criticisms, long term goal setting,
Chapter 8 focuses on the goal setting and goal striving cognitive perspective on motivation. Cognitive events are mental events that take place within the individuals mind. The sources of these cognitive motivations are based in the person’s way of thinking and believing. Some of those mental constructs come from a combination of plans, goal settings, and goal strivings.
Plans arise from a person’s need to remove an incongruity. People have mental representation of the ideal states (how one wishes life was going) of their behavior, environmental objects, and events. People are also aware of present states (current status of how life is going) of behavior, environment, and events. When these two (ideal and present) states have conflicting properties an incongruity arises that carries with it motivational properties. It is this incongruity that provide energy to organize our behavior from our present state toward our ideal state providing direction. A model to explain this process of cognitive mechanisms is the test-operate-test-exit (TOTE). Test: referring to the comparing of the two states, operate: the motivational act on the environment through a planned sequence, as long as the incongruity the action of operate continues. When the present matches the ideal the person can exit. Plans have a corrective motivation; that is an individual considers many different possible ways for reducing an incongruity. Plans are not fixed, static, and mechanical, they are subject to adjustment and revision allowing the individual to pursue the most adaptive course. One must also carry out the plan and have the ability to change and revise an ineffective plan that encounters problems giving corrective motivation a dynamic process.
Discrepancy (synonym for incongruity) is the motivational property that arises rather than the ideal state. When a person envisions all the possible situations that are different from the present situation he/she becomes aware of the mismatch that is discrepancy, that produces motivational behavior. Now that we know what discrepancy is and its function there are two types to take into consideration. The first is discrepancy reduction is reactive, in that it revolves around the feedback from some stimuli. Were the environment brings a standard of excellence to the individuals attention “Are you currently performing at this level.” The second type is referred to as discrepancy creation a goal-setting motivation. Which is a higher level of excellent that is already set in the performers mind to look forward to that doesn’t need feedback from extrinsic forces. An example of this would be if a sales person decide to sell 15 cars one day instead of the usual 10.
Goals are along the lines the same as plans, they generate motivation by focusing people’s attention on a discrepancy. They are also what an individual is striving to accomplish. When there is a discrepancy between the present and ideal accomplishment it is called a goal-performance. In order for a goal to enhance performance and translate into any performance gains a goals setting must vary in its difficulty and how specific it is. Goal difficulty (how hard a goal is to accomplish) has a linear effect with performance; that is the harder the goal, the more it energizes the performer to exert the right amount of effort needed to acquire the goal. Goal specificity (how clearly a goal informs a performer) is typically restating the goal in numerical terms, this reduces ambiguity in thought and variability in the performance. Difficult goals energize the performer, and specific goals direct them toward a particular course of action. The feedback from a performance allows a person to keep forward with their goals, and without can be emotionally unimportant and uninvolving. A goal can be either a long-term or short-term goal or both, however the arrangement the performance emerges the same. Short-term goals create positive feedback and long-term goals facilitate intrinsic motivation.
The last one is goal striving, and the implementation intentions of the plan. That is an advance goal-directed behavior to carry out and strive for the goal-directed action. The most surprising thing I think I learned was the two types of discrepancy and that I have always taken part in the both reduction and creation. This chapter has motivated me in my goals to strive for more short-term goals and look for the feedback so I can continue forward with my goals.
Terms: plans, ideal and present states, behavior, environmental objects, events, incongruity, TOTE, test, operate, exit, corrective motivation, discrepancy, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, goal setting, goal-performance discrepancy, goal difficulty, goal specificity, performance, effort, energizes, direct, feedback, long-term, short-term, goal striving, implementation intentions
Chapter 8 is largely based on the concept of cognition/action. It discusses all of the cognitions that take place when we need to make an action. Four main points that are viewed are plans, goals, implementation incentives, and mental simulations.
Plans and Goals are cognitions we create to help us gain achievement and needs as discussed in previous chapters. Goals and plans help direct our focus and attention and keep us motivated towards our achievements and needs. The underlying factor for motivation is discrepancy. There are two types of discrepancy. Discrepancy reduction motivates us to create plans of action to get what we desire. Discrepancy creation is geared towards goals and the process of setting goals. Discrepancies occur when people view their current state and dream of an ideal state. For example, being a poor college student would come up as a discrepancy and the ideal state would be to earn money, but there must be a plan and a set goal to get that money to achieve the ideal state. This process of state evaluation is constantly happening and always motivating us to achieve bigger and better things.
When it comes to setting a goal many things must be taken into account. Is the goal specific, measurable, attainable, realistic, and time-based? These qualifications are the basis for SMART goals. The idea of implemented intentions finds itself in SMART goals because it focuses on the process between setting the goal and actually attaining the goal. Specificity helps an individual to stay on track and know exactly what the goal is and avoid broad terms. Measurable goals allows people to do exactly that, measure where they are at currently, monitor progress, and achieve a desired number. Attainable is based on the very important concept of level of difficulty. Impossible goals with be tossed aside quickly and easy goals will become boring. I good level of difficulty needs to be found in order to keep motivation intrinsic. Realistic ties in with attainable in the sense that impossible shouldn't be something you call your goal. For example just because you have a huge desire to fly planes doesn't mean you can be a pilot if you have bad vision. You may cognitively think it is a good goal, but physically it is impossible. Time-based goals help you measure your progress. Knowing how long you have will allow you to make better plans, schedules, and mini goals to help your progress. All of these components are important measures to take when it comes to good goal setting.
Setting yourself up with a good social network and environment is also key to attaining goals. You will need feedback and information from other people. This need forces you to surround yourself with people who will motivate you are praise you for sticking with your goal and making progress in the short term to maintain long term motivation. Having others hold you accountable will also keep you on track as you will feel like you are letting others down when you quit and you don't want to do that. Your environment is also key. If you surround yourself with bad habits and distractions from your goal, eventually you will give in because it is there is easy access. Surround yourself with a good environment and good people and your goals will be met easier.
Mental simulation is another big part of cognitions because of the part they play in motivating our actions. Salespeople often use the "imagine it" trick on people. No matter how much you think you can resist the idea of having something better will get inside your thoughts. This is where the discrepancy motivation comes into play and the ideal state is no longer where you are, but in the state where you have the product they are trying to sell. Eventually you will be motivated to attain those products to achieve the state you wish to be in. Mental Simulations can also be effective and productive. They can help visualize the outcome and motivate people to keep going and achieve the goal. A fine line must be walked carefully. You want to imagine, but not falter stray from the path that will get you there.
The most surprising thing I learned was how much I actually play into the mental simulation. I might be what you consider an online shopaholic. I hate walking around stores and looking for stuff, but give me a computer and a plastic card of any sort and I will buy a large quantity of items. Most of them are sold to me because I have imagined how much better my life will be if I do have them. I imagine that my life will change drastically and that it is well worth my time and money to invest in my new future when in reality I will be just fine without it.
When I considered my own goal setting I came to the realization that I am good at setting long term goals, but never setting short term goals to keep my intrinsic motivation for the long term at optimal levels. I am also very bad at writing them down which I believe is a huge pitfall because I don't see them I tend to fall into the mindset of, "Out of sight out of mind."
Terms Used: plans, goals, implementation incentives, and mental simulations, discrepancy, praise, intrinsic motivation
Goals and plans are both cognitive events. Our actions begin as cognitions and then move to be actions. In chapter 8 we learn that you have your present state but we have an ideal state also. However, these two do not always match up. When they do not match up, we experience incongruity. When we experience incongruity, we create a plan to get rid of that incongruity. A plan helps provide direction for us to alter our present state to match our ideal. The TOTE model helps us energize and direct plans and behavior. TOTE stands for Test-Operate-Test Exit. First we test to see if our present state matches the ideal. If it doesn’t, then we operate on it to try to change that incongruity. We then test again. If it still doesn’t match up, we operate again. But if it does match up, we exit the sequence. What is it, however, that creates the motivation to change? The space between the present state and the ideal state is the discrepancy and this is the part that creates the motivation.
There are two types of discrepancy. The first type is discrepancy reduction. This is based on feedback that detects discrepancy. Discrepancy reduction goes with plan-based corrective motivation. Also, discrepancy reduction is reactive rather than proactive. The other type is discrepancy creation. This is where a person is looking to the future and sets a higher goal in the future. The ideal state is only in the person’s head and they are working towards achieving it. Discrepancy Creation is goal-setting motivation and is proactive rather than reactive.
To have goal-setting motivation, you first need to have a goal. A goal is whatever someone is trying to accomplish. If you set a goal, you are far more likely to reach or exceed it than someone that just intends to do the best they can. For a goal to be effective, however, it must be difficult and specific. Difficulty just discusses how hard a goal is to achieve. Specificity just means how clear a goal is. Difficult goals energize you in trying to achieve them while specific goals direct you down a certain course.
One important factor in goal setting is feedback. According to our text, you will only experience increased performance in goals if you have regular feedback that shows the progress related to our final goal. If we don’t have feedback, we don’t see what we are doing as important or involving. From gaining feedback that shows we are at the right level or above, we feel more satisfied and will keep striving towards that goal or make our current goal more difficult.
Another important factor in goals is goal acceptance. Goal acceptance means that we agree with and are willing to work towards the goal we received. The four factors that our textbook discussed regarding whether or not a goal will be accepted or rejected are (1) perceived difficulty of the imposed goal, (2) participation in the goal-setting process, (3) credibility of the person assigning the goal, and (4) extrinsic incentives.
Most people set many goals but the most memorable ones are the long-term goals. The biggest thing that must be understood about long-term goals is that you must break them down into several short-term goals that follow along the path that leads to the ultimate long-term goal. One interesting thing about long-term goals is that if it is a long-term and interesting goal it will help in creating or enhancing intrinsic motivation.
The most surprising thing I learned was how goal achievement can help with your intrinsic motivation. When we learned about intrinsic motivation it sounded so elusive and difficult to actually increase or improve your intrinsic motivation. I was surprised that long-term goals can aid in that. After reading the section, it does make sense, I just hadn’t thought of it before.
The knowledge I gained from this chapter reinforces what I have learned in other vicinities. One of the big things I learned about goals was SMART goals (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Results-Focused, and Time-Bound. I had always hated SMART goals because they required more effort in creating than just saying a goal. I also hated SMART goals because I was required to make them. However, after reading the chapter, I see the psychology and motivation behind why that works and why goals are done that way. The most important thing about SMART goals based off of what we learned in this chapter is that any goal must be specific to work effectively. This chapter helps me understand more ways in which I can motivate myself to reach my goals and how to create my goals. I don’t want to go into it too much, however, because most of what I would say on the subject would be better suited in the next blog comment.
Terms Used: Goals, Ideal State, Incongruity, Plan, TOTE, Test, Operate, Exit, Discrepancy, Discrepancy Reduction, Feedback, Motivation, Discrepancy Creation, Goal-Setting, Goal, Difficult, Specific, Energize, Direct, Goal Acceptance, Long-Term Goals, Intrinsic Motivation
Chapter eight deals with four factors in cognitive perspectives on motivation, these are plans, goals, implementation intentions and mental simulations. Plans include congruence between present ideas and ideal ideas. If incongruence exists this is what motivates people. Like the example with the bad hair day you are motivated by how bad your hair looks to fix it and match the idea in your head about how you want your hair to look. This mechanism is called the TOTE model, test-operate-test-exit. This can go on for a long time between test and operate until the individual is satisfied or gives up. Planning also includes the plan to action sequence. In this model one must detect present-ideal incongruities, generate a plan, instigate the plan, and monitor feedback. This activates a decision making process where the individual must come up with ways to correct the incongruence. Finally we have discrepancy, this is another work for incongruence. There are two types of discrepancy, one is reduction and the other is creation. Reduction is based on discrepancy-detecting feedback that underlies plans and corrective measures. Creation is based on “feed-forward” system where the person looks forward and set future, higher goals for an idea state that does not yet exist. These provide the motivational basis for action.
Next we have goal setting; this also focuses attention on discrepancy. Goal setting usually enhances performance but what is also important is the type of goals one sets. There is goal difficulty which includes how hard the goal is to accomplish and then there is goal specificity which is how clearly the goal informs the person what to do. Only goals that are difficult and specific increase motivation. Harder goals energize behavior and specific goals direct attention and planning. Motivation however is not the only factor we also have to consider ability, training, coaching, and resources. We also have to consider the role of feedback. This allows people to keep track of their progress throughout the goal progress, without this performance can be unimportant and uninvolving. Feedback provides emotional punch that feeds the goal setting process with emotional experiences of satisfaction or dissatisfaction. Then we have goal acceptance, if a person does not accept the goal then they will not do it. Input is a big factor in this process. Goal acceptance also deals with the credibility of the person setting the goals and the perceived rewards. When a person decides to deal with long term goals is has been shown that having several little goals along the way are highly effective if the task if difficult. Finally we have goal striving which is where we visualize our goals. Visualizing the outcome is far less effective than visualizing yourself working on the goal.
Next we have implementation intentions. This is the idea of having a goal with a plan. If you don’t have a plan with the goal then you won’t achieve it. This type of planning also helps a person overcome hardship they will face on the road to success. An example of this would be deciding on the time you would work out every day and when that time comes you are activated to do your workout and achieve that goal. This also creates a close mindedness that helps to narrow your actions and attentions to the specific goal, it also helps people finish unfinished goals. Finally the chapter sums up how to combine all these ideas into an effective goal setting process.
Terms: cognitive perspectives,plans, goals, implementation intentions and mental simulations, congruence, incongruence, discrepancy (creation, reduction), Goal (setting, difficulty, specificity, striving,acceptance), feedback
Chapter 8 talks about goal setting and the process to obtain goals.
A goal is whatever you want to accomplish. When you are setting goals you need to make sure that you are setting goals that you can accomplish and are too difficult or too far in the future to be able to achieve. Goal difficulty refers to how hard the goal is to accomplish. As goals increase in difficulty, performance of the individual increases, likewise the easier the goal is to attain the less effort the individual has to put in to achieve their goal. You also don’t want to set a goal for 10 years in the future because it can be hard to measure if you are succeeding or failing. It would be best to set shorter term goals to achieve and that will assist in achieving the long-term goal.
When goal setting be difficult and be specific about your goals. When a goal is more difficult it will energize behavior and like I mentioned up to it increases effort and a person works harder, but it also increases persistence, which will make a person work longer. When you are specific about your goals it directs behavior. When your attention increase, you are more likely to work with more focus, and when you’re planning is increased, you work smarter as a person. Also, difficult and specific goals offer feedback. Feedback is knowledge or results, and a person needs both a difficult and specific goal and timely feedback to maximize their performance.
The most surprising thing in this chapter that I learned is that setting long-term goals is not the best idea, instead set short-term goals to achieve the long-term goal. I am one that sets long-term goals and I think that now by learning this it will help me in the future by just setting smaller goals first. Kind of like the example in class about having a job by May 25th, instead of setting that one goal, work backwards and set smaller goals, that will help achieve the one larger goal.
Terms Used: Goal, Goal Difficulty, Difficult, Specific, Feedback
Chapter 8
Basically Chapter 8 discusses goal setting and achieving. Goals are the essential to self achievement and motive people to strive to become more than they are. The chapter talks about discrepancies in setting goals and how these discrepancies help to motive people to achieve their goals by realizing what they don't have and what they want to have. The chapter also tells about how difficulty and specificity lead to better goal achievement. Basically the harder you work and the more difficult the goal, the more likely you are to strive to achieve it because it is more important and requires more effort and attention. An important part of goals is the feedback you receive either from others or yourself when achieving your goal. If you feel more accomplishment from achieving your goal, you are more like to set more goals because you are happy from succession. Another thing the chapter talks about is long-term and short-term goals. Long term goals are good and provide motivation for a bigger picture, while short term goals help you achieve your long time goals by giving you positive feedback along the way of achieving your long term goal. Overall this chapter gave really great information on goal setting and striving and how goals motive people to achieve higher success in their lives.
The most surprising thing I think I learned from the chapter is how important it is for your goals to be specific and difficult in order to achieve them. I used to think that just setting goals were important, which they are, but the book is right. I am more likely to complete my goal if it is specific and I know exactly what I am trying to achieve. Also I think it is very important for them to be more difficult, but I am more likely to give up on things that seem pointless or too easy to accomplish.
This chapter was actually really important to me in my personal life. I feel like I really needed that kick in the ass to start being motivated to do the things that I need to do to achieve the goals that I have set in the past. Lately I feel like I have put some of my goals on the back burner for other priorities in my life, and I am happy that this class and specifically this chapter had lead me to find that motivation I need.
Terms: goal setting, goal achieving, self achievement, discrepancies, strive, motive, difficulty, specificity, feedback, long term goals, short term goals.
Chapter 8 discusses goal setting and goal striving. We all utilize cognitions, or cognitive sources of motivation, which lead to us taking action. First, the chapter states that the plan was the initial motivational spring to action studied. This study showed that people have mental representations (plans) of an ideal state of behavior, events, and so on (incentive to strive for). Those same people have an understanding of what their present state looks like as well (standard, whether personal, cultural, or stimulus). If there is any discrepancy between the two mental representations, incongruity occurs. That very same incongruity causes people to become energized and strive for the ideal they are falling short of. This process of energized cognitive action is referred to as the TOTE model, or test-operate-test-exit model. An example of this model in action would be choosing an outfit for the day; try on one outfit, get a friend’s reaction (feedback- which can document progress toward a goal or act as a reward/punisher), try on a different outfit, get feedback, and so on. This example also demonstrates discrepancy reduction. Discrepancy creation is based on the feed-forward system- person looks forward and sets higher goals for the future.
A goal is anything a person wants to accomplish. Like plans, goals generate a person’s motivation by making him/her focus on the level of inconsistency or incongruence between their present level of accomplishment and the ideal. This discrepancy is called a goal-performance discrepancy. Goal setting is affected by the difficulty and specificity of the goal. Difficult goals call for a lot of effort and being specific about a goal is beneficial, and enhance performance. For example, you would rather hear from a friend how he or she hopes you get the part in the play you are wanting rather than just good luck. Four factors determining whether or not a goal will be accepted are perceived difficulty of the goal, participation in goal-setting processes, credibility of the person who assigns the goal, and the extrinsic incentives involved.
Goal-setting theory is about enhancing performance rather than motivating. Also, it works better if the goal is associated with an uninteresting task. In order to obtain long-term goals (goals not in the near future), one must conquer several short-term goals first. Mental stimulations can focus on the planning and problem-solving aspects of goals rather than the outcome itself. Focusing on the goal (e.g. studying to get a good grade on an exam) fares better motivationally speaking than focusing on what is known as implementation intentions. The study of implementation intentions involves the way goals, once they are set, become active. People often face problems with a goal such as getting started, persisting, and resuming.
An effective goal-setting plan includes four steps: specify the object to be accomplished, define the goal’s difficulty level, clarify the goal’s specificity, and specify the time span when performance will be assessed. Also, during this goal-setting process’ execution, steps regarding goal-striving must be assessed: check on goal acceptance, discuss goal attainment, create implementation intentions, and provide performance feedback. There are four predictors of goal choice: ability, self-efficacy, past performance, and incentives involved. The dangers involved in goal-setting are: more stress, the possibility of failure, non-goal areas are ignored, short-range thinking is utilized, cheating is more likely to occur, and intrinsic motivation is undermined when a goal is involved.
We learn from chapter 8 that goals do increase performance, but why? One reason is that it helps clarify performance expectations. A second reason is that goals counteract boredom and apathy and get us going. Another reason goals increase performance is because they make feedback important. Lastly, goal attainment can ultimately generate pride, satisfaction, or competence. Accomplishing a task alone cannot give us the same sense of pride or satisfaction as when accompanied by a goal.
The most surprising thing I’ve learned was regarding the problems with long-term goals (LTGs). Often in my life, I have made the mistake of setting too many long-term goals and because of the lack of feedback and goal reinforcement, commitment really does decrease immensely. Knowing this information will now help me to realize that I need to make more short-term goals, which are easier to commit to and follow through with, and ultimately can lead to the long-term goals I want to attain.
TERMS: plans, goals, short-term/long-term goals, implementation intentions, mental stimulations, cognitions, TOTE model, feedback, discrepancy, goal-performance discrepancy, goal difficulty/specificity/ setting/acceptance, goal-setting/striving
Chapter eight discussed goal-setting and goal striving. Present state is the current status of life, while ideal state is how a person wishes life was. People always want something to be different about their lives, so this is where goals come in. A goal is whatever an individual is trying to accomplish. Person sets a goal, there is a process. The process is goal acceptance, goal choice, and short-term vs. long-term goal setting. The chapter explained why goals work to increase performance. Some reasons are; they clarify expectations, counteract boredom, make feedback important, and make people feel pride when accomplished. Also, a major point is that to achieve a goal, it must be the right amount of difficulty and specific. If it is too easy or hard, the person will give up quickly. If it is not specific, the person doesn’t have enough direction on how to strive.
The most surprising topic I learned was about the four factors that affect goal choice. People focus on whether they can do it, ability, and how they did last time, their past performances. Also, they recognize the incentives they gain from the goal. However, people look over they self-efficacy part too often. Either a person is super confident and knows they can accomplish something, or they just don’t even look into trying to accomplish it because of their low self-confidence. I feel many people would accomplish way more if they just believed in themselves. On the other hand, if someone knows they are deaf, and accepts that, then they know they really can’t accomplish a goal to become a counselor that listens to people.
I feel that I am definitely a person who just assumes I can’t accomplish anything big. I have gotten better over the years and hope to improve even more. For example, after high school, I didn’t go to college for two years. I decided I can do it and I started at a community college and now I’m here. As I think about how my plans to lose weight fail, I now realize that just saying I’m going to lose X number of pounds, isn’t going to get me anywhere. I need to make smaller, specific, and hard enough goals. I might say that every day I need I need to get in thirty minutes of exercise. As I go through my day I find ways to fit it in. I could take the stairs more, take a long rout around campus to get to class, or just replace a half hour of TV with a walk. But I would need to make sure I would keep with it. So, I could keep a journal of what I did that day to remind me of how well I’m doing. I really do feel more motivated to achieve my goals after this chapter.
Terms used: present state, ideal state, goal, self-efficacy,
Chapter eight describes goal setting and goal striving. To get to the goal, one has to plan. There are two states to their plan: present and ideal. If there is any incongruity between the present and ideal states, this motivates the person to make a plan to eliminate the incongruity. The test-operate-test-exit (TOTE) model is a cognitive mechanism that makes plans energize and direct behavior. Test means to compare the present state against the ideal state. The incongruity cause the person into action and the person operates on the environment with a plan of action. The person tests the present state with the ideal state again, and if the present state does not match up with the ideal state, the person goes back to the operate . This can go on many times, T-O-T-O-T-O-T-O-T-O-T-O. . ., until the present state matches the ideal state, where the person can exit the plan. The plan allows people to detect present-ideal inconsistencies, generate a plan to get rid of incongruities, instigate plan-regulated behavior, and monitor feedback. Corrective motivation is a decision-making process that the person decides on different possibilities to reduce the present-deal incongruity. Examples could be: change the plan, change the behavior, postpone or eliminate the plan. There are two different types of discrepancies: discrepancy reduction and discrepancy creation. Discrepancy reduction is based on the discrepancy-detecting feedback that underlies plans and corrective motivation. Discrepancy creation is where the person looks forward and proactively sets a future, higher goal.
A goal is something a person is striving to accomplish. In goals, incongruity in the present level of accomplishment and ideal level of accomplishment motivates the person to act. In goal-performance discrepancies, people with goals perform better than people without goals. Under goal-performance discrepancies there are goal difficulty and goal specificity. Goal difficulty is how hard a goal is to accomplish and goal specificity is how clearly a goal informs the performer precisely what to do. Feedback is very important in making goal setting effective. Feedback allows people to keep track of their progress towards their goals. Without feedback, person can feel their performance is emotionally unimportant and uninvolved. Goal acceptance is when goal setting takes place when in an interpersonal relationship in which one person attempts to provide another person with a goal. Four factors that determine if an externally set goal will be accepted or rejects are: perceived difficulty of the imposed goal, participation in the goal-setting process, credibility of the person assigning the goal, and extrinsic incentives. A person can have long-term, short-term, or both goals. Long-term and short-term goals are intrinsically motivated. Short-term goals create opportunities for feedback and long-term goals increase intrinsic motivation. Goal striving is the means to attain a goal. Implementation intention is a plan to carry out a person's goal-directed behavior. This is deciding before the goal striving, when, where, and how long. Implementation intentions facilitates goal-directed behavior by getting started and finishing up.
The most surprising thing in this chapter was the TOTE model. When I was reading about the TOTE model, a person tests the present state with the ideal state and see if there are any incongruities. If so, then the person operates on the environment with a plan of action. The person tests the present state with the ideal state again, and if the present state does not match up with the ideal state, the person goes back to the operate . The person tests and operates until the present state matches the ideal state, where the person can exit the plan. I find myself doing this all the time with hair, picking out clothes for the day, or shopping.
The knowledge from this chapter helped me to motivate myself towards my desired goals by making a plan of action. I usually just write down things I want to accomplish, but never actually making plans on how and when I am going to achieve them. I usually just say "I will finish them when I get to them." I need to set dates to start and finish what I want to accomplish and ways to finish them. I also learned that I should set up more short term goals. I usually have the end goal in mind and take that in whole, not broken down. I think I will be more successful in accomplishing my goals, even if they are small, if I do these things.
TERMS: plan, present state, ideal state, TOTE model, corrective motivation, discrepancy, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, goal, goal-performance discrepancies, goal difficulty, goal specificity, feedback, goal acceptance, long-term goals, short-term goals, intrinsic motivation, goal striving, implementation intentions, goal-directed behavior
Chapter 8
This chapter was about goal setting and the motivation aspect involved in it. The chapter covered material describing how to start and continue a goal till it is accomplished as well what is involved in a goal and what it takes to make a goal successful. The chapter started out with the cognitive perspective on motivation. This is simply describing how we think about things and turn them into action. This process of thinking includes plans, goals, implementation intentions and mental stimulations. Plans play a big role in the goal setting process. The book described plans in a different way than I expected. It talked about how we have our present self or state which is what we currently are or are doing and we have an ideal self or state which is what we want to be or be doing. The difference between these two and wanting to get to the ideal state is called discrepancy. Planning comes into effect when we want to change our present state to become our ideal state.
Actual goal setting comes into play when we discover something we want to accomplish. For example when we want to lose weight or get a 4.0 GPA. This leads to goal-performance discrepancy which is the difference from where we are now to our accomplished goal. The book also talks about how important goals are and how people with goals tend to succeed and accomplish more than people without goals. Another aspect that helps make a goal attainable is goal difficulty. This refers to how hard a goal is to accomplish. Studies show that as goal difficulty increases so does the person’s performance. So when setting a goal a person is much more likely to try and put effort forth on a hard goal then for an easy goal. Along those lines is goal specificity. This is making a goal specific and stating exactly what it is that the person should be doing. This is very important because it gives the goal setter direction. After having set the ideal hard specific goal it is important to have feedback. Feedback is important because it lets a person know where they are in terms of accomplishing their goal. It is also an important motivator as well. If someone is achieving their goal faster than they thought they would this will bring on positive feelings and maybe have them set harder goals next time. This also works in reverse if a person is behind on achieving a goal they might experience frustration and want to try harder.
Goal Striving is also very important in achieving goals. This is the keeping at it or putting goals into motion. Goal setting in theory without goal striving is in essence just a thought process, almost like an absent thought or daydream. Mental stimulations: focusing on action is still a part of mental process but it is the first step in goal striving. Focusing on the action is basically saying focus or picture how you will accomplish a goal instead of the end product. For example when your goal is to get an A on your next test, don’t visualize holding your test after it’s been graded with a big A on it, but instead visualize yourself studying for the test. Another huge (if not the most important part) of goal setting/striving is implementation intentions. This is the making up a plan to get started with specific dates or times in mind. It also includes persistence through tasks or goals even when they become difficult or tiresome or when distractions and life in general may get in the way. It is also making a plan to get back on track with the goal once the distractions do occur and life gets in the way. Implementation intentions can also be categorized into two categories, goal pursuit: getting started and persisting and finishing. The getting started is the setting a day and time to start and the persisting and finishing is the seeing the goal through till it’s accomplished as well as avoiding distractions and working through them when they happen.
The most surprising thing I learned in this chapter was that the harder a goal is the harder you persist and work at accomplishing it. The thing I’m going to take away and implement into my own goal planning is the focusing on acting and the process of accomplishing the goals. I will also focus on the implementation intentions and the making plans with specific dates and time tables. I will also focus on making plans that help me to stay focused and avoid distractions as well as a plan to get back on the wagon when those distractions may get the best of me.
Terms: cognitive perspective on motivation, plans, discrepancy, goal setting, goal-performance discrepancy, goal difficulty, goal specificity, feedback, goal striving, mental stimulations: focusing on action, implementation intentions, goal pursuit: getting started, goal pursuit: persisting and finishing
Chapter 8 talked about how to create goals and how to achieve them. It gave some insight as to how to make achievable, yet challenging and realistic goals. The chapter explains that a discrepancy, or difference, between the present state and the ideal state is what motivates us to change our behavior. There are two types of discrepancies: discrepancy reduction and discrepancy creation. Discrepancy reduction is when you become aware of how well or how poorly your present state (current performance) matches up with your ideal state (ideal performance). In other words, the environment causes awareness. In discrepancy creation, the person sets their own, higher goal. This goal does not require feedback from others. Feedback is very important in evaluating performance. Feedback makes the performance emotionally important and involving. Feedback tells the person if their performance is at average, above average, or below average. From this feedback, the person can adjust their behavior and become motivated to achieve their goal.
The most surprising thing I learned from this chapter was that I have been terrible at setting goals thus far in my life. This chapter really opened my eyes to exactly how bad of a job I have been doing. The pitfalls in goal setting also surprised me. I did not expect cheating, short-range thinking, or ignoring non-goal areas to be problems with goal setting. However, it does make sense that the pressure to achieve a goal would increase, and with that, performance would decrease. I think that the focus turns from achieving the goal to pleasing others and not letting them down and making yourself look like a failure. It does make sense now that non-goal areas would be ignored, but the extent would depend on how big your goal is. If your goal does not require all of your time and energy, this should not be as big of a problem. However, if your actions to achieve your goal take a lot of time and energy, it would be a big problem.
The knowledge from this chapter will help me motivate myself toward desired goals by giving me the steps needed to be successful in goal setting. I now know that implementation intentions are extremely important in achieving goals. I could have the greatest goal in the world, but without implementation intentions, I would not achieve it. Implementation intentions are plans to help you achieve your goal. They are the little steps that are taken to achieve the bigger goal. A big reason many people do not achieve their goals is because they do not develop action plans. Having implementation intentions will help keep me motivated and keep me moving forward toward my goals. It will also give me insight as to how to energize and direct my behavior toward achieving my goals. Making my goal difficult will energize my behavior and allow me to increase my effort and work harder. In addition, it would increase my persistence and I would work longer. Making my goal specific would direct my behavior and increase my attention and focus, as well as my planning. It would also help me to work more efficiently, or smarter. These things combined would lead to enhanced performance, which would increase my likelihood of achieving my goals.
Terms: discrepancy, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, goal setting, present state, ideal state, feedback, implementation intentions, goal difficulty, goal specificity
Chapter 8 is about goal setting and goal striving. The chapter looks into the various mental processes or the cognitive perspectives that not only enable us to think about doing something, but also leads to our acting toward the achievement of that thought. Goals are achieved through planning and focusing-->the chapter looks at an individual’s ways of thinking and acting and how it contributes to their achieving of their goals.
Broken down, the chapter talks about the cognitive perspectives. Cognitions are aspects of the motivations that make up the construct of goals. Mental constructs are the values/beliefs, judgments, goals, expectations, and aspects of one’s self-concept that help to predict one’s actions.
Setting goals starts with a plan of what and how one is striving to accomplish something. Goals start with a motivation to change a discrepancy in one’s current environment in order to reach their ideal environment; this is known as goal-performance discrepancy. In goal setting, it is also important to have a difficult goal. That is not an impossible goal, but rather one that encourages persistence and gives an individual the energy to push themselves harder.
When setting a goal that is difficult, it increases the effort and persistence that one may take in working to achieve that goal. They may work harder to rise to the challenges the goal presents. Performance of the goal is enhanced as more effort and persistence is put forth. Enhanced performance then leads to more direct behaviors with higher levels of focus and planning in performance. When a goal is specific, it has powerful consequences that come with greater effort, persistence, enhanced performances, focus, and planning. Another interesting point discussed in this chapter was that criticism helps more in goal planning and setting than motivation.
What I learned: Goals need to have clarity, counteract boredom, resist apathy, give knowledge of results in the form of feedback, and generate pride, satisfaction, and competence. It’s also important to have short term check points for long term goals as well.
Most surprising to me was the idea of goal acceptance. Goal persistence makes complete and total sense to me. Of course you need to persist and work harder and longer to accomplish goals and get positive feedback. Being able to accept our goals was a shocker to me. The example used in class really put this into perspective for me. Dr. Maclin talked about how someone may decide not to work for the summer and another person may decided that they are going to try to get good internships and set high, unrealistic, or difficult goals for a summer job. The one with really high goals may be more upset and crushed if she does not achieve her goals. Further, she will have a difficult time accepting failure or possibly even accepting success if she is not happy with the goal she has achieved. However, the person who decides not to work and enjoy their summer has set a goal as well. Perhaps it is the last summer of their life where they can get away without working. It is the last summer before their senior year and they want to relax. They will be happy if they accept their goal. Even though it is not a high achievement goal, the goal to relax is still important. This tied in with goal choice as well.
I found the concept of goal choice to be interesting as well. I never thought of how important the sub-points were. I didn’t realize how much of an affect a goal choice has on the achievement and how thoroughly this all needs to be calculated and planned out when choosing a goal to work toward. Ability, past performance, incentives, and self-efficacy all need to be considered to come up with the ideal goal, an actual goal, and a minimal goal that planned over an amount of time that will allow for appropriate reflection and feedback. It’s shocking how much of a role in the final outcome the simple idea of planning can play in the big picture.
The knowledge from this chapter helps motivate me to set more goals and to put more of an emphasis on picking a goal that is capable of reflection and feedback. Like I said when talking about what surprised me most, goal acceptance is vital. I have so many long-term life goals that I get caught up in them. They aren’t easily measured and I rarely reflect upon them. I have been motivated to create some more short term goals for myself and to pick goals that I know I will be happy to accept the consequences of the means to achieve them. I often get discouraged because I pick really difficult goals and then will get so distracted about trying to achieve them and thinking about how much work I have already put into them, that I forget to check in on my happiness and reflect on my success.
I am motivated to have more appropriate and less harsh critics of myself and enhance my goals so that I may reach my full potential and be more than pleased with my achievements. I am motivated to plan my goals more carefully and think more before I act as a result of the knowledge I have gained in this chapter’s reading. I plan to work toward creating a balance between my present state or environment and my ideal state/self. This chapter will also help me to work backwards from a goal and plan all of my steps along the way.
I will plan better goals, which make me happy, and have opportunities for reflection and feedback along the way.
Terms: goal setting, goals, cognitive perspectives, mental, plan, achievement, feedback, incentive, goal striving, predict, self-concept, mental constructs, values, beliefs, judgments, expectations, actions, goal acceptance. Goal persistence, goal choice, ability, past performance, self-efficacy, ideal goal, actual goal, minimal goal, reflection, long-term goals, short-term goals, enhance, criticism, present state, persistence, enhanced performance, difficulty, direct behavior, effort, focus, specific goal, energized behavior, clarity, counteract boredom, decrease apathy, generate pride, satisfaction, competence.
Chapter eight discusses cognition and how it is related to motivation. Cognition’s are mental events that evolve around a person’s ways of thinking and believing. These mental constructs can include things such as beliefs, expectations, goals, plans, judgments, values and self concept. Four motivational agents in the cognition-action sequence were examined in chapter eight. These include plans, goals, implementation intentions, and mental simulations. Plan was the first motivational agent discussed. This agent stems from people’s knowledge of their present and ideal states. Any incongruity between the two makes people uncomfortable which drive them to formulate and act on a plan of action to remove the incongruity. The incongruity acts as the motivational tool and provides the energy; the plan becomes the means of organizing our behavior toward the pursuit of the ideal state. The cognitive mechanism by which plans energize and direct behavior is the test-operate-test-exit model. This model demonstrates the steps in which people act to decrease incongruity. This can be long or short term, and the model is still applicable. Plans however are not so fixed, static, or mechanical. People make plans, and often at a later time, will revise an ineffective plan. This is known as corrective motivation. Discrepancy was described in that it creates the sense of wanting to change the present state so that it will move closer and closer toward the ideal state. There are two types of discrepancy. The first is discrepancy reduction, which is based on the discrepancy-detecting feedback that underlies plans and corrective motivation. The second type of discrepancy is discrepancy creation. This is based on a “feed-forward” system in which the person looks forward and proactively sets a future, higher goal. These both provide a motivational basis for action. Chapter eight also discusses goal settings. A goal is defined in the chapter as whatever an individual is striving to accomplish. Goal setting generally enhances performance, however the type of goal is important in determining how long or how much the goal is translated into performance gains. Goals that are difficult and specific are the goals that will enhance performance. Feedback is also a very important variable in which to increase performance. Feedback will document the performer’s progress in relation to the goal. Goal acceptance is another critical variable. If an externally set goal is not accepted then the goal may be rejected. Four factors determine whether an externally set goal will be accepted or rejected. These include perceived difficulty of the imposed goal, participation in the goal-setting process, credibility of the person assigning the goal, and extrinsic incentives. Goal setting has many advantages, but it also has its cautions. The three main pitfalls include stress, opportunities for failure, and putting creativity and intrinsic motivation at risk. Long term goals can also be difficult, so breaking it up into multiple short term goals can enable the person to stay with the goal for the entire time it takes. Specific plans of action must be set in order to attain goals. Implementation intention is the study of how goals, once set, are effectively acted on. It facilitates goal-directed behavior by getting started and finishing up. Getting started is a volitional problem where the individual won’t take the opportunity to accomplish the goals when the time is giving, and finishing up is a volitional problem where the individual is distracted while trying to achieve the goal and never gets back to achieving the goal.
One of the most surprising things that I found in this chapter was how the more difficult a task is the more likely an individual is going to stick with it. I was thinking that it would be the other way around. I figured a simpler task would be easier to stick with, so more people would be likely to accomplish that easier goal. In actuality, as goals increase in difficulty, performance increases in a linear fashion. There was a lot of valuable information in this chapter. It definitely has motivated me to sit down and write out some goals of my own and the steps I can take to achieve them. It is nice to know that I will go farther in life if I do take the time and simply write out my goals. It will give me direction and enable me to go farther than I would have without any goals set.
Terms: cognition, mental constructs, motivational agents, plans, goals, implementation intentions, mental simulations, incongruity, corrective motivation, discrepancy, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, goal setting, feedback, goal acceptance, volitional problem
Chapter 8 is the first chapter of three that seeks to focus us on Cognition. This chapter focused primarily on motivational factors. I had taken Behavioral Modification and we had touched on motivational factors in regard to the perseverance of a desired behavior. This chapter took it much further than I had previously learned. They began with the test, operate, test, exit model which I though summed up so much of our motivational behavior. This model suggests that we are constantly comparing our present state to our ideal state. Our present state is wherever we currently are and this can apply to payroll, level of fitness, or how well you speak French. Our ideal state is the optimum/premium/best of the best we imagine either of the above categories to be (i.e. making $1 million salary, being Marathon fit, or being able to sweep a woman off her feet with your sexy French). When you compare the present with the ideal and find a deficit that is referred to as incongruence or the discrepancy. When we notice this discrepancy we seek to repair it by going back to the ‘operate’ phase and then test again until we either give up or eliminate the discrepancy (exiting).
The most surprising revelation to me in this chapter was the presentation of two different types of discrepancies. I always knew that I was comparing myself in some capacity to my ideal self but I never thought about it the way the book did. The most common form of this for me is discrepancy reduction, which occurs when I have received feedback concerning my performance in some area and have been found wanting. This generates a response from me in which I will try to reduce the distance between my present state and the ideal state. In my opinion this is not necessarily the best because it builds stress in individuals, especially if the feedback is not handled carefully or occurs too often. If I am told that I fall short everyday it will eventually lead me to give up.
The biggest practical aspect I took away from this chapter was the critical aspects that help me to perform better. It was cool to find out how powerful goals can be in affecting our performance. I have always struggled with persevering in long term goals, primarily things that I don’t really care about much at all. The prime example that comes to mind is when buddies and I agree to try to meet in the morning to do a workout program…I last 3 weeks, skip 1 morning, never come back again. However, I could fight this by generating goals that are difficult and specific. The most helpful part for me will be the positive effects that come with difficult goals, namely causing me to work harder and to work longer. This flies in the face of what I normally do when experiencing failure, which is to cop out and make easier goals which it turns out negatively effects my performance. Now I can actively apply this to my own goal setting strategies.
Terms: motivation, goal, perseverance, behavioral modification, cognition, TOTE model, present state, ideal state, discrepancies, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, feedback, goal setting, energizes behavior, directs behavior
Chapter 8 talked about goal setting and goal striving and the cognition that is behind this. It first discussed present state verses ideal state. The present state is where we currently are, and out ideal state is where we wish we were. For example an individual’s present state could be having a lot of homework to do tonight, but the ideal state would be already having completed your homework for tonight. This creates two types of discrepancies, discrepancy reduction and discrepancy creation.
Discrepancy reduction is when feedback is given and it shows how well or how poorly an individual is doing on a certain task. This shows the individual if they are lacking in a certain area and don’t meet the criteria for something, for example if a 3.5 GPA was required for an academic position and an individual had a 3.2, they would not be able to do this position until their GPA is raised. Discrepancy creation is looking forward to what needs to be achieved in order to reach a goal. Using the same example, if an individual is hoping to get an academic position and they need a 3.5 GPA and they have a 3.2 then they will work hard so that they can reach their ideal GPA.
Goal setting is a very important thing for individuals to do. Most of the time individuals with goals will perform better than their peers who have not set goals for themselves. Another aspect about goals is that the difficulty of a goal increases performance. If an individual wants to lose 15 pounds in 2 months their much more likely to achieve that then if they had said they wanted to lose 7 pounds in 2 months. Specific goals are also important. If an individual says I want to lose weight, they are likely to not make any changes or only make slight changes. If they have a number in mind and a time set, they are much more likely to achieve their goal.
The final thing that a goal needs is to be accepted. If someone gives an individual a goal, they have the choice of accepting or rejecting that goal. For instance a professor may challenge a student to read a book on their free time and that individual has the choice of accepting or rejecting this goal.
The most surprising thing that I learned was that individuals perform better when the task is more difficult. This seems like it should be the other way, but when I think to experiences in my life it makes sense. For example if I set a goal to work out a few times a week then I will just go and do a minimum amount, but if I sign up for a triathlon, then I will work out much harder than I otherwise would have. This goal and the difficult makes me want to work even harder at achieving it.
After reading this chapter I will definitely be more aware of what my goals are and know how to be more effective in setting them. This will help me achieve more, and help me to feel more accomplished when they are achieved. This will change my motivation behind certain activities.
Terms: Goal setting, goal striving, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, specific, accepted.
This chapter focuses on the Cognitive Perspective of Motivation and the four factors of the cognition—action sequence model which include plans, goals, implementation intentions and mental stimulations. All of which play a role in goal setting and striving. Everyone sets certain goals, whether they are easy, difficult, or long vs. short term. However, in many goals discrepancies are present. These discrepancies are more prevalent with unrealistic goals, such as losing 20 pounds in a week. What truly needs to be focused on is the present state and the ideal state of where you want to be. Along with this, there are many other factors to consider when setting goals, such as the difficulty, goal specificity, goal acceptance and goal pursuit.
Everything in this chapter was interesting because I can implement my new knowledge into my own goal setting. Basically a goal starts with a discrepancy or “incongruity” that an individual notices in their life. This is something that comes off as aversive and people usually want to change something about it. This leads to planning a goal. When we are planning a goal we want to keep in mind that it needs to be realistic in order for it to be successful. If we set high goals with an unrealistic timeline and we don’t succeed, we are just setting ourselves up for failure. As with anything else, there are steps in order to plan a goal. With corrective motivation first you need to detect the inconsistencies between your present and ideal state. Second, create a plan to eliminate inconsistency. Third, implement plan into daily activities. Lastly, monitor your goals feedback for discrepancy reduction. I thought it was interesting to learn that performance increases with the difficulty of the goal. It makes sense, because people would inevitable have to try harder to strive for a difficult goal. However, I would think that a more difficult goal would be subject to frustration and make it easier to quit. Goal specificity relies on the individual to make a clear, concise goal. In this aspect, people are more likely to strive for goals when they have a specific deadline, or specific request. Feedback is necessary to monitor goals success.
After reading this chapter, I know that setting goals works best when the task is relatively uninteresting. I am currently in a research lab that requires me to do content coding. With this in mind, I set a goal for myself to code a minimum of 40 subjects per week, although I am only assigned 20. This way I am setting a higher, more difficult goal that is specific. In the end, I will complete my content coding ahead of schedule and my reward will be praise from my professor.
Terms: cognitive perspective of motivation, cognition—action sequence, plans, goals, implementation intentions, mental stimulations, goal setting, discrepancies, goal specificity, goal acceptance and goal pursuit, corrective motivation, discrepancy reduction, feedback
Chapter 8 talks about the cognitive perspective on motivation and how it focuses on mental processes as casual determinants to action. In the cognition action sequence there are four elements. The first element is Plans. Plans are the means of organizing our behavior toward the pursuit of our ideal state. Discrepancy is also talked about in the Plans section of chapter 8. There are two types of discrepancies. The first type is Discrepancy Reduction, which is based on the discrepancy-detecting feedback that underlies plans and corrective motivation. The environment provides feedback about how the person’s present state relates to the ideal state. This particular type of discrepancy is reactive and deficiency oriented. The other type of Discrepancy is Discrepancy Creation, which is based on the “feed-forward” system in which the person looks forward and proactively sets a future, higher goal. Discrepancy Creation is proactive and growth pursuing in nature. The second element in the cognitionaction sequence is Goal Setting. Goal Setting enhances performance if people create goals or accept other goals, but it depends on the type of goal. There are two factors that affect goal setting, and they are Difficulty and Specificity. Only goals that are difficult and specific enhance performance, but other external factors of performance are ability, training, coaching, and resources. The four factors that determine whether an externally set goal will be accepted are the following: perceived difficulty of the imposed goal; participation in the goal-setting process; credibility of the person assigning the goal; extrinsic incentives.
The most surprising thing I learned from reading this chapter was that when you visualize the outcome of the goal, it does not actually help an individual reach that goal, rather they should visualize on how reaching the goal instead before thinking about outcomes. I now have learned my lesson on dreaming about good grades and should dream about studying instead.
This chapter will help me focus on how to set achievable goals and how to achieve those goals by a certain time in my life. An example would be waiting until the last minute to do an assignment or project, but with the help of this chapter I will be able to divide up the assignment/project and make each part of it an individual goal. Then I can set a specific time or day for me to achieve each individual goal, and not have to pull an all-nighter the night before the assignment/project is due.
TERMS: Cognitive Perspective on Motivation; Plans; Goals; Goal Setting; Discrepancies; Discrepancy Reduction; Discrepancy Creation; CognitionAction Sequence.
Chapter 8 involved goal setting and goal striving. The cognitive study of motivation concerns itself with the cognition to action sequence. There are four elements to the cognition action sequence: plans, goals, implementation intentions, and mental simulations. I learned that plans and goals rely on discrepancy as their driving motivational force to action. In basic terms it deals with a persons present state and where he/she wants to be in the future or ideal state. There are two types of discrepancies: discrepancy reduction which captures the essence of plans and corrective motivation, and discrepancy creation which captures the essence of goals and the goal-setting process.
When a present-state-versus-ideal-state mismatch exists, incongruity/discrepancy produces a general corrective motivation that gives rise to plan-directed behavior capable of reducing the discrepancy. A popular example is when a college student must clean his room, this is called corrective motivation. If people who make slower than expected progress toward their plans they experience negative emotions and vice versa for people making rapid progress.
The first four steps in a goal-setting program involve the sequential steps within the goal-setting process. The main question is, “What do you want to accomplish?”. The answer to this often life changing question is the specification of a performance-based ideal state one longs to achieve. The second step is to ensure that the goal is a relatively difficult one. The third step is to translate vague goals into more specific ones. Fourth, a time when performance will be assessed needs to be stated.
The most surprising thing I learned was how incredibly technical setting goals can be. The small things that distract us from our end goal can be so devastating. I always say I want to exercise more, but don't really have a clear focus on how to do it. I realized I need to discuss possible plans, strategies, and courses of action that might enable me to advance from goal setting to goal attainment.
Terms: goal-setting, goal striving, cognitive study, action sequence, plans, goals, implementation intentions, corrective motivation, goal-setting process, performance-based, assessment.
Chapter 8 covers the cognitive perspective of motivation and the four factors that support a person’s motivation: plans, goals, implementations intentions, and mental simulations. To feed a person’s cognitive motivations a person will look at their present state of being and then consider an ideal state of being. To settle the differences between a present state and an ideal state are what is known as incongruity. For a person to then to get back into sync (out of incongruity) they will work to over come the differences between their current and ideal states because otherwise they will continue to feel uncomfortable in the current state that they are in. To move one from the current state onto the ideal state, a person will uses what is known as the test-operate-test-exit model (TOTE), and until a person has found the ideal state they will repeat their way through the TOTE model until they have felt they have reached their ideal state.
While one is going through the TOTE model they are experiencing discrepancy, which is the difference between the present state and the ideal state. There are two types of discrepancy that people experience. The first is discrepancy reduction, which is based on feedback (which tells you how good or bad that you’re doing on your performance) from an outside source and corrective motivation. The next type of discrepancy creation is based on a goal setting ideal where a person proactively works towards and ideal state. Once a person realizes the discrepancies they can then set plans into place, which will help a person work towards an ideal state from a current state.
A goal is something a person is striving to accomplish. Similar to plans, goals are put into place to settle the incongruities between a person’s current state and their ideal state. When it comes to goals, there needs to be a certain level of difficulty, and depending on the difficulty of the goal determines the effort being put forth by a person. A goal must also be specific (in what is to be done, how it will be accomplished, and in what time span the goal need to be accomplished) so the performer knows how they are precisely execute their intended goal and reduces any ambiguity. Thus, it is better for a person to have a goal that is somewhat difficult and is specific, it energizes a person to focus their attention, do better, and persist until the goal is accomplished, which then in turn generates motivation. People also require feedback on their performance in order to determine if their goal is adequate or if they need to be changed. Feedback also feeds into a person’s emotional state and it can hinder or enhance a person’s motivation. People also go through goal acceptance to determine if they accept or reject a goal that they have, in the hopes that they improve their performance. Goal acceptance is usually internalized and determines a person’s commitment to a goal.
Goal length also has a major factor that affects a person’s interest in continuing or stopping themselves from setting or accomplishing a goal. Short-term goals are usually seen as uninteresting and fairly easy tasks that can get feedback easily, and one can see themselves making some progress. Whereas long-term goals aren’t as easy to track and receive feedback for, therefore, for a person to accomplish their long-term goals it is best for them to break the long-term goal up into short-term goals so they can hopefully continue to strive for the goal. Goal striving is when one visualizes the success of a goal and persists until the goal is accomplished. A person needs to have strong persistence if they are going to accomplish their long-term goals.
Personally, I found this chapter to be interesting in understanding why goals are accomplished. Many aspects go into achieving a person’s goals and plans, especially when it comes to long- term goals. As someone who continually looks towards the future, I am someone with many long-term goals, and I am someone who makes use of short-term goals so I feel like I am achieving something along my way to my long-term goal. I want to go into student affairs, therefore, while I’m in my undergrad I am looking for opportunities to get involved in the university. I have done so m joining groups, become an RA, and I have looking into graduate school. Once I have completed these short-term goals I can hopefully have success in the field of student affairs.
Terms used: test-operate-test-exit model (TOTE), incongruity, discrepancy, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, long-term goals, short-term goals, feedback, goal strivings, difficulty, persistence, ideal state, present state
Chapter 8 focuses on the process involved in Goal setting and goal striving. This is what motivates people to set and successfully complete goals throughout their lifetime.
People rely on their cognitive sources of motivation which revolve around a person’s way thinking. Cognitive mental events include goals and expectancies; this motivates one to “spring into action and do things with the pursuit of achieving a goal.
When people formulate a goal, they think of things they want to achieve, they then create a plan. According to the contemporary cognitive study of motivation people have mental image of what their goal looks like for example what their ideal car looks like but people are also aware of their present state. But they are also aware what the current car they have looks like. Incongruity is when a person realizes the difference between their current state and their ideal state and is motivated to form a plan to remove the incongruity. The test-operate-test-exit (TOTE) model is a cognitive mechanism by which plans create and energize direct behavior. With this model you first test, this means to compare present state to ideal state, then you operate by acting on environment to realize ideal state, test again by comparing present state with ideal state and exit is present state in congruity with ideal state.
Corrective motivation is used when planning and goal setting. Corrective motivation is the process in which an individual considers many different options to reduce present-ideal incongruity, for example change plan, change behavior or get rid of the plan in entirety. Corrective motivation involves 4 processes. (1) present-ideal inconsistencies (2) forming a plan to eliminate incongruity (3) instigating plan and behavior (4) feedback. Through this an individual figures out if their plan to achieve their goal will work, of if they need a new plan or behavior. Corrective emotion produces emotion when a person reaches their goal quickly, they experience positive emotions, when they are slowly progressing, and negative emotions are experienced.
Discrepancy is a synonym for incongruity; it can be represented by a magnitude for example
Present state ----------------- ideal state. There are two types of discrepancy. The first one is discrepancy reduction which is discrepancy-detecting feedback that deals with plans and corrective motivation. The second type of discrepancy is discrepancy creation, this is based on a “feed-forward approach: setting high future goals for themselves.
Goal setting is an important step in achieving a goal. Goals are what people set out to do or change. A goal setting generally enhances performance; goal difficulty and how specific it is affect how successful a goal is. Goals that are difficult increase persistence, a person works hard to achieve the goal and keeps working until they reach their ideal state. Goal specifity gives a person an idea of what they need to do specifically to reach a goal. For example, it’s easier to plan on being a plastic surgeon, then to just plan on going into the medical field. Feedback and goal acceptance are necessary for performance enhancement. Feedback lets a person know where they are at, and where they need to be to reach their ideal state. Without feedback performance can be emotionally unimportant or uninvolving. With feedback the goals feel more important to the person trying to achieve them. The person receiving feedback can then decide if they are satisfied or unsatisfied with their performance.
Goal acceptance is when a person accepts and takes on another’s goal after carefully contemplating whether to accept the goal or not. The person’s decision to accept or deny the goal is dependent on the facilitator. For example if the person feels that the goal is attainable they will try, if the person asking them to take on the goal makes it seem impossible then the person will most likely deny the challenge.
Goal striving is the last step involved in the goal process. In order to translate goals into efforts people focus on the action and the goal they wish to attain. Once a goal has been set, this does not mean that the goal will be successfully carried out. Implementation intentions need to be set in place. People need to be able to overcome obstacles, distractions, setbacks and how to resume once an interruption occurs. Implementation intentions facilitate goal-directed behaviors and actions by getting the job done despite or distractions or interruptions. For example I had all day to do my homework but I never got around to it or I was doing my homework but Facebook was distracting and I never got back to my homework. When a person decides when and where they will enact goal oriented behavior this is getting started.
Then one must put together 8 steps to effectively achieve a goal and create progressive action and behavior. The first four are sequential steps within the goal setting process and the second set of 4 steps are 4 steps of sequential steps within the goal-striving process.
I learned that feedback from other is very important and without we don’t think that achieving a goal is that important. I thought that we were more motivated to satisfy our own needs then to get feedback and opinions from others.
Reading this chapte taught me techniques to successfully achieve my goals and to recieve feedback. I just think that understanding the process of goal setting and striving will help me to effectively achieve any goal that I want to, since they set up realistic expectations and steps.
Key terms: goals, cognitive mental events, TOTE Model, corrective motivation, incongruity, present-ideal. Inconsistencies, discrepancy, discrepancy reduction, discrepancy creation, persistence, feed-forward, goal difficulty, goal specificity, feed-back, goal acceptance. ,getting started, persisting and finishing
Chapter 8 is concerned mainly with Goal Setting and Goal Striving. First off, there are four different features of the mental to action process. To better explain this to the reader, an individual needs to realize mentally that something is wrong with the present state of something in their life. Once they have made this 'realization', they begin the TOTE behavior and formulate plans and goals. TOTE stands for test-operate-test-exit. Essentially, this means that someone sees' a discrepancy with their present state of things and how they would like them to be (ideal state). So, they test the current state then they operate or 'spring into action' to correct the state. After that they test again and if satisfied with the newly achieved state then they quit, or exit.
Now back to the original four motivational elements. These elements are plans, goals, implementation intentions, and mental simulation's. Just from looking at the TOTE explanation, clearly it can be seen that goals and plans are essential in goal setting and goal striving as well as goal completion. The amount of effort that is exerted in hopes of completing a goal is directly correlated with how hard that goal is and whether or not a specific goal has been established. These refer to goal difficulty and goal specificity. Specific goals may include making an outline of certain tasks or behaviors which will ultimately lead to the end goal. Goal difficulty is related to how hard the goal will be to achieve by the pursuer.
The larger gap there is between the ideal state and the present state is referred to as incongruity. The larger the incongruity the larger the effort made will be. Goal difficulty correlates strongly with effort. Easy goals require little effort whilst hard goals require a lot of effort. These viewpoints can be blurred when taking a persons ability, cognition, competence, and coaching into account. One individual may exert little effort while someone else may exert a lot to achieve the same goal.
Incongruity can also be referred to as discrepancy. It's worth mentioning as well that there are two different types of discrepancy. First of the two types is discrepancy reduction. Discrepancy reduction concerns plan making and making adjustments to previous plans a long the way to help a long the process. This is called corrective motivation. The second type, discrepancy creation, involves goals and the establishment of the goal-setting behavior.
Implementation intention can really be explained as the goal itself. It is actually the carrying out of a plan, actually doing it.
The most surprising thing I learned about was the TOTE model. Even though it is simple and common knowledge, I find that it interesting to actually think about it in that way. I mean that we actually examine something we don't like then we engage in a behavior to get something to how we want it to be. Then after that, we reevaluate it and if we are satisfied we stop or 'exit'. I just found it interesting when looked at in that much depth.
Well, the knowledge from this chapter really doesn't affect my motivation levels for achieving any specific goals. Short-term and long-term goals have long been in my arsenal for many different aspects of my life. This chapter really just gave me a better idea of what is actually going on behind the scenes. I didn't know that the harder the goal the greater the effort, however, I feel that an extremely hard goal can be discouraging as well. I will keep it in mind next time I set goals to be very specific and not make it to easy for me complete.
Terms: TOTE, Plans, Goals, Discrepancy (reduction and creation), Incongruity, Spring-into-action, Implementation intention, Mental simulation, Goal difficulty, Goal specificity, Correctional motivation, and Short/Long-term goals