Please read the chapter assigned for this week.
(Reading Schedule: http://www.uni.edu/~maclino/hybrid/hs_book_s11.pdf)
After reading the chapter, please respond to the following questions:
Of the various aspects of History & Systems presented in the chapter, which did you find the most interesting? Why? Which did you find least interesting? Why? What are three things you read about in the chapter that you think will be the most useful for you in understanding History & Systems? Why? What are some topics in earlier chapters that relate or fit in with this chapter? How so?
Please make sure you use the terms, terminology and concepts you have learned so far in the class. It should be apparent from reading your post that you are a college student well underway in a course in psychology.
Make a list of key terms and concepts you used in your post.
Let me know if you have any questions.
--Dr. M
The topic that I found most interesting in Chapter 12 was about Clifford Beers. He launched the Mental Hygiene Movement. This movement was focused on the ideas that mental illness could be cured and with proper care it could be prevented. Beers had attempted suicide and suffered with depression. He was in and out of three different mental institutions and after he was released for good, he wrote a book describing his experiences. He made special note of constant verbal and occasional physical abuse suffered by the hands of the staff and believed improved conditions and professional training was needed among the attendants. I found this to be interesting because Beer’s felt like he had fully recovered from his mental illness and during this time, recovery was unheard of. The medical community generally believed there was little or no hope for the mentally ill. In 1909 he founded the National Committee for Mental Hygiene to further the cause of prevention.
I found this whole chapter to be interesting so it’s difficult to pick out a topic that wasn’t interesting. The section on Criticisms about Freud was a lot of material that I have learned in the past and therefore it wasn’t quite as interesting. I still enjoy reading about Freud though.
Three things that will be most useful for me when it comes to understanding History & Systems is where treatment started for the mentally ill and how far it has progressed. This is important because many people in Psychology will work with the mentally ill and need to understand the history of it in order to not make the same mistakes again. Another topic that is important is Sigmund Freud. He is one of the most controversial psychologists and very well-known. Understanding his ideas gives a good picture of how some people think and it forces you to try and see things in a new perspective. A third topic that I think is important to understand is how Clinical Psychology started. Lightner Witmer created the first clinic for the treatment of psychological disorders in the United States. This led to the creation of APA which professionalized the practice of psychology.
One topic that relates to previous topics is about Dorothea Dix. She was an early crusader that cared for the mentally ill. She assisted people in mental institutions and during the 1840’s she toured jails, hospitals and any other location that might house the mentally ill poor. During her travels she discovered a ghastly amount of abuse and neglect occurring. She found this to be unacceptable and presented her case to the Massachusetts legislature and led a series of reforms. This topic is pretty extraordinary considering how much she accomplished whilst women were viewed as only being good for reproducing, raising a family, cooking, cleaning, and so on. In earlier chapters there are specific topics on how women were discouraged from furthering their education of pursuing a higher level job. Another topic that I connected to previous readings was Freud’s evolution of the psychoanalytic theory. Freud believed there were a constant conflict between three forces; the id, the superego, and reality. I connected this to Kallikak study from the previous chapter. It was believed that families of “bad” genes would pass the same genes on to their offspring, same for families with “good” genes. Freud believed that a properly functioning ego served as a mediator, channeling id-based needs in directions that are realistic and consistent with moral values. These are similar because if one family were considered feeble-minded they would most likely be “off” to Freud.
Terms: Clifford Beers, Mental Hygiene Movement, National Committee for Mental Hygiene, Freud, Lightner Witmer, APA, Dorothea Dix, evolution of the psychoanalytic theory, id, superego, reality, Kallikak study
The most interesting piece of information I found in this chapter was the concept of bloodletting. I found this cure to mental illness to be quite interesting. Bloodletting was a common remedy to remove disease or excess blood. It was intriguing to me how it caused the person to become tranquil and made them feel as if they were relieved of their symptoms. I found the least interesting pieces of information to be Freud’s obsession with the importance of sex. I just think some of Freud’s ideas were too much based of sex and that he was so preoccupied with how sex affects people. Freud ideas of what caused hysteria was very sexually based. Freud’s seduction hypothesis said that hysteria was the result o childhood sexual abuse by a parent or other adult. Freud just had sexual ideas involved in all his theories and ideas.
The three important aspects I found in this chapter were the aspects of free association, dream analysis and the tripartite structure of personality. Free association is important because many psychologist use this method today. Free association is when patients are placed in a relaxed position and encouraged to say whatever came to their minds, without censoring anything. Dream analysis is also important to understand because it is used still today as well. Dream analysis is the belief that dreams are the “royal road” to the unconscious. The surface or manifest content of dreams needed to be analyzed for their deeper or latent content. Even though I thought some of Freud’s ideas were quite different, I did think his concept of the tripartite structure of personality is important to understanding personality. The structure was made up of the id, ego, and superego. The ego was the center and was partially conscious and unconscious. The ego helped to maintain a balance between the id and superego. The id constantly demanded that the needs of instinctive drives of sex and aggression be satisfied. The superego was the person’s learned moral values. These three things make up or personalities.
Terms: Bloodletting, Seduction Hypothesis, Free association, Dream Analysis, Ego, Id, and Superego
In this chapter, I find Neurypnology or hypnotism to be very interesting. This means a "nervous sleep" in which a patient would stare and concentrate on an object and fall asleep and recollect memories of the unconscious mind. Of course there were controversies and some believed hypnosis was a concept called suggestion, or one who was under hypnosis would believe exactly what a person was told. Some say hypnotism can be used to investigate symptoms of hysteria which is disorder with neurological malfunctions without physical damage to the nervous system. But Freud believed hysteria was the result of childhood sexual abuse by a parent or adult which made him come up with a hypothesis known as the seduction hypothesis in which most children have experienced some kind of sexual trauma at a young age and therefore can remember or bring it up through free associations or dream analysis. Hypnotism was just one way to find out what was behind the conscious mind. Another interesting way in discovering what was in their mind was through free association where the patient would say exactly how they felt at the top of their head. Those who had trouble doing this displayed resistance which Freud believed was the answer to figuring out a person's problem. Along with free association one could describe their dreams as a sense of some kind of meaning which was called dream analysis. I find all of this very interesting and sometimes I do believe dreams are what is on our mind unconsciously. I remember most of my dreams every morning and can recall specific details and most of what I dream about are either things that worry me or things that I must do in the future.
I haven't really found anything that's not that interesting in this chapter but I would have to say Freud's personality types are the least maybe? I have already learned about the Id, Ego, and superego so I'm familiar with them. The Id is described like a child-like manner. These are instinctive drives and demands that need to be satisfied. The Ego is partly conscious and unconscious and gives us somewhat of a sense of right and wrong in situations. The superego is the stage in which we know what is right and we establish morals and values and when we do something right, we give ourselves all the credit. Tying in with theses personality types are anxieties. Objective anxiety is a normal reaction in which a perceived threat means danger. An example of this would be if a bear were to come into a classroom, some students would fight, run, or hide. Neurotic anxiety is when a person is scared their childlike behavior or Id will get out of control. Thinking bad about something to get what they want could be an example of this. Moral anxiety are feelings of shame that interfere with our superego. One example would be someone working out to get in shape or "get skinny" by also eating healthy and they are presented with junk food. They know they shouldn't eat the junk food because that could jeopardize their healthy exercising habits.
Three important findings of this chapter that would be helpful for this class is learning about Freud and his psychoanalytic theory processes of personalities, anxieties, and defense mechanisms that go along with it all, also the classification of mental illnesses of Emil Kraepelin was important in identifying certain illnesses, and the last important finding is clinical psychology for treatments in America and finding cures to go along with the illnesses today.
Terms: Neurypnology, hypnotism, suggestion, hysteria, free association, dream analysis, resistance, seduction hypothesis, ID, EGO, SUPEREGO, neurotic anxiety, moral anxiety, objective anxiety
What I found to be the most interesting in chapter 12 was the section over the early treatment of the mentally ill. I remember learning about some of these things in my intro to psych classes and I just thought to myself how awful it would have been to be alive during these earlier time periods when mental illness was not only unacceptable, but also misunderstood. I particularly enjoyed the work of Dorthea Dix and Clifford Beers because they both had had their own issues whether it was being a woman or being a former asylum patient, but they both kept on in their journey for better treatment of the mentally ill.
The part I liked least was the section over hypnosis. I don’t know what it is but I have always found hypnosis to be a bit odd and I don’t really trust it. I see it as a means of entertainment rather than a form of healing or therapy. I understand that some people do benefit from hypnosis and mesmerism types of therapy, but I find it to be too odd to commit my support to it.
The things I think that will be most useful would have to start out with the prior treatment of those who were mentally ill. Even in today’s world mental illnesses are obviously not fully understood or accepted, but in earlier years treatment and conditions were so poor and no one seemed to want to take the time to learn or even try to treat those people humanely; it was as if their illness made them a threat to society and that they were monsters. Another thing important to understanding the history of psychology would obviously have to be Freud. Freud had his hand in so many different ideas and theories about why people develop or have issues with mental health. I didn’t realize until reading this chapter that he spent so much time developing and learning about the different theories he was creating; I was also interested in the fact that he abandoned or changed several of his theories when new evidence was present. I also think the work of Carl Jung is important to our understanding. He was somewhat of a branch off of what Freud was doing but in a more believable or accepting way. I think word association is a good technique to try to get into a person’s mind that is not so easy to have open up in sessions.
Finally there are a lot of topics, mainly in relation to Freud that have appeared in this chapter as well as in others. There were several names that came up in the Freudian section that have been mentioned in previous chapters such as Hall inviting him to come speak at Clark University; others who came to hear Freud speak were James, Cattell, and Goddard. I find this to be important because it instills in us that these men were in contact in one way or another with what others around them were doing in the world. I am sure that ideas of some of the biggest names in psychology were bits and pieces of other psychologist’s theories and thoughts. This book does a good job of integrating all of the psychologists and how they benefited or relate to one another.
Terms: mentally ill, Dorthea Dix, Clifford Beers, hypnosis, mesmerism, Freud, Carl Jung, Hall, James, Cattell, Goddard
I found the early treatment of the mentally ill fairly interesting. Showed how ignorant I guess people were at the time. We thought they were evil, possessed, witches, demons, dangers to society, etc. As a result, we typically beat, tortured, executed, and essentially dehumanized mentally ill individuals as much as possible during the early times.
Although Freud was extremely influential in popularizing and coming up with innovative and thoughtful (if not scientifically evident) theories, I have learned the heck out of him in all my psych classes so I don't find him that interesting anymore. His view of the unconscious mind and his obsession with sex was interesting until learning how big of a dud his actual theories were.
I find many of Freud's ideas important for understand psychology today. His theories and research on parent-child relationships, the id, ego, and super ego, and on unconscious thoughts allowed future researchers to test and provide additional information regarding these facts. Freud basically opened up a world of ideas for people to examine.
Terms: Freud, id, ego, superego, unconscious.
The first thing I thought that was interesting wa Mesmerism and Hypnosis. Mesmer thought that if you aligned internal magnetic forces then they would result in good health. He would give them magnants with high doses of iron then hold magnents over their bodies to determine that humans are powered a lot by suggestion. He called this process Animal Magnetism. The medical community started to see that Mesmer was a quack and he started to fade out slowly. Mesmer slowly came back to the forefront when he changed the name of his practice to hypnotism. He thought the general fixation of ones vision, would then lead to his study about suggestion. Hypnosis had a lot of controversys.
The second part that I found interesting was the part about Clinical psychology. Lightner Witmer like most people believed that psychology should help people. It started by him seeing children and identifying their troubles. His first patients were children who were struggling in school. Based on their physical health and family background the children would then be placed into groups as a) experiencing some correctable medical condition, b) possibly experiencing some medical problem but more clearly requiring some special program, or c) having severely retarded, untreatable, and requiring custodial care.
The two parts I did not want to read into further were Psychoanalysis because I have heard tons about freud and just wanted to look at the “lesser” stuff in the chapter. And the second part I did not read further into was the early treatment of the mental ill at insane asylums. Besides understanding that asylums were major places to observe and test on the mentally ill, I did not read inot their change and reform.
Terms: Mesmerism, Hypnosis, Witmer, Clinical psychology, Feud, insane asylums.
some more on the mentally ill. because of the closing years of the enlightenment, more efforts to improve treatment of mentally ill occurred. The best known informer was Phillipe Pinel of france.is most dramtic action was to remove chaines from patiences. He called his overall program "moral treatment". in America Benjamin Rush, the "father" of modern psychiatry became the strong advocate of a contemporary belief that illnesses derived from problems in the blood and circulatory. Bloodletting seemed to relieve tension, then opening veins reached a "tranquil" state. other systems to calm the blood was gyrator, and tranquilizer.
Dix started in Massachusetts in 1841 on an eighteen month tour of jails, hospitals and almshauses. she found abuse and neglect, and that peopel were treated no better than animals. Her efforts helped to create forty seven mental hospitals and schools.
Beers started his run with the mental hygiene movement. once a patient came out on top and wrote books which proved to peopel that it could be cured. he was credited with creating the DSM-IV which helps to diagnose mental illnesses.
more on clinical psychology. Witmer found that severly retarted children should be segregated from society in institutions and prevented from having children. he believe his clinic demonstrated his belief that deficiencies could be corrected with training and control of the enviornment. Witmer introduced the term orthogenics to refer to his strategy of investigating retardation, and the methods of restoring to normal condition.
FOr Chapter 12, I thought the most interesting aspect was Lightner Witmer, mainly because I am a school counseling major and so it was interesting to see kind of where school psychology steamed from. Witmer was originally a experimental research psychologist and became interested in clinical psychology by chance when a teacher brought a student into his lab who was having trouble spelling. From there, he began seeing other cases of children with disorders. He believed that experiences can shape us, believed in eugenics and was not so keen on paper and pencil tests for IQ.
Moral treatment (mental hygiene movement is also something that you can not attend a psychology class and not learn about. Dorthea Dix, William Tuke, and Phillipe Pinel, Benjamin Rush (blood letting) all had good intentions even if eventually most of the institutions just developed other problems after their efforts.
Itard was interesting because I TA for Child and Adol Psych and the Wild Boy of Aveyron is a one of the things we hit hard during lecture.
Mesmerism was interesting but it is still so skeptical. Even today, hypnotism is used more as a means on entertainment than it is used for therapy. Franz Anton Mesmer, in my opinion, had some crazy ideas (believing that he contained magnetic forces). However, the fact that it was used in surgery during the 1900s before pain medications blows my mind and makes me think that maybe their is some truth to it (there also happens to be a Scrubs episode where a patient insists on being hypnotized for her surgery but she wakes up during).
Frued was the worst part of this chapter. I am so sick of reading an hearing about him. I get it though, he "pioneered" a lot. Some of his ideas weren't far off but his obsession with sex caused a lot of problems and loss of followers and friends. Id, Ego, Super Ego- I've heard a million times. THe Oedipal Complex is also well known for the play and Regina Spektor did a spin off song of the play. Psychoanalysis is interesting as the study of unconscious processes but wasn't really empirical. Defense Mechanisms however are in my opinion, Frueds best contribution to psychology (repression).
Terms: Lightner WItmer, School Psychology, Clinical Psychology, Mental Hygiene Movement, Dorthea Dix, Pinel, Tuke, Benjamin Rush, Blood letting, Itard, Wild Boy of Aveyron, Memsmerism, Franz Anton Mesmer, Hypnotism, Frued, Id, Ego, Super ego, defense mechanisms, Oedipal Complex, Psychoanalysis, repression
Mentally Ill-
Phillipe Pinel: remove chains from patients who had been restrained. "Moral Treatment"- improvements in patient nutrition, hygiene, and general living conditions, rewards/punishment system.
William Tuke: York Retreat (benevolent treatment of the insane), patients who behaved well were given more opportunities for recreating and work, and those who were bad were punished (restraints, isolation).
Benjamin Rush: blood letting- "hypertension in the brains blood vessels". Gyrator- revolving board that patient would be spun rapidly.
Jean Itard: Wild Boy of Aveyron, 2 years worked with the boy "Victor", able to complete simple chores but never able to care for himself completely.
Dorthea Dix- 18 month tour- found closet sized rooms, poorly fed and clothed, beat and abandoned patients. Presented her case and won funds to improve the asylums. Continued tour through rest of nation and helped 47 hopitals and schools.
The thing I found most interesting from this chapter was the beginning of clinical psychology. Clinical psychology treats and diagnoses mental disorders. Lightner Witmer was credited with creating psychology’s first clinic. He believed that psychology should not just consist of research, but that it should also be used to improve people’s lives. Wittmer began seeing children with various cognitive or psychological ailments. He founded the journal The Psychological Clinic and wrote a leading essay in its first issue titled “Clinical Psychology”. Because his main focus at first was children, clinical psychology developed a narrower focus called school psychology. This was used to diagnose and treat children with school-related problems. He termed his strategy of investigating people who were different or “deviates” as orthogenics.
The least interesting thing I found in this chapter was the psychoanalytic work of Freud, but I also feel it is the most important thing for understanding the history of psychology. Freud is a widely recognized figure in the history of psychology because of the new ideas he brought to the table. During med school Freud met an important person who shaped the beginning of his experience with psychoanalysis. The Anna O. case was a significant part of psychoanalysis’ history. Anna O. referred to a woman by the name of Bertha Pappenheim who experienced various different mental and physical problems. Breur found that his method of catharsis worked well with her. He found that if he asked her to trace a symptom back in her memory to where it first began, he could have her release it emotionally and she would be relieved. By witnessing this case, Freud began to develop his own ideas on psychoanalysis. For example, he believed he witnessed transference between Anna and Breuer. Transference is the transfer of feeling from one person in your life onto your therapist. He also developed the practice of free association. Patents were asked to relax and encouraged to say whatever came into their minds. When patients found it difficult to talk about something, Freud called it resistance. He believed resistances were significant and that they were the root of the patient’s problems. Freud also developed dream analysis. He believed that dreams were the key to the patient’s subconscious. Freud also believed sex played an important role in mental health. He thought that unresolved sexual problems were the root of hysteria. His seduction hypothesis stated that hysteria was the result of sexual abuse as a child from an adult. After much work with these new theories, he began to create what he referred to as metapsychology. This was his general theory of human behavior and mental processes. During this time he wrote Beyond the Pleasure Principle. This explained the difference between eros and thanatos. Eros were the life instinct that showed itself through sexual motivation. Thanatos was the death instinct that showed itself through aggression and self-destruction. Some of his most famous work existed in his book The Ego and the Id. The ego was the center of personality and consisted of unconscious and conscious components. The id made demands and was like instinct. The superego was learned values that worked to control the id. The ego was the mediator. Because of all the demands placed on the ego, objective anxiety existed. Objective anxiety was fear within a person because of past events. Neurotic anxiety exist when we fear we cannot control our impulses and stem from past instances when we were punished for being unable to control ourselves. Moral anxiety leads to shame that is experienced when we knowingly go against our superego. These anxieties are signs that our anxieties are under attack. This means we must create defense mechanisms to protect ourselves. The most common is repression (projecting unwanted impulses into our unconscious). We may also use projection to put our own faults onto others. Reaction formation is when we replace our unwanted impulses with ones that are more acceptable to our ego. In sublimation we channel unwanted impulses into productive activities.
The three things I found to be most important in understanding the history of psychology were psychoanalysis, clinical psychology, and the reformation of asylums. The reformation of asylums resulted in the need for psychoanalysis and clinical psychology.
Terms: Anna O. case, catharsis, transference, free association, resistance, dream analysis, seduction hypothesis, metapsychology, eros, thanatos, ego, id, superego, objective anxiety, neurotic anxiety, moral anxiety, defense mechanisms, repression, projection, reaction formation, sublimation, clinical psychology, Wittmer, school psychology
I like how the process of how psychoanalysis came about through Freud. Freud saw how his collegue Joseph Breuer's patient Anna O. transfered her feelings towards her father towards her therapist. He then developed theories about bouts of hysteria present themselves after being released from repressed memories of sexual abuse, this was the seduction hypothesis. He tried to get to these memories through the process of Free Association where the patient would laid on the coach and just spoke of what came to mind. Often though the patients with withhold what they were really looking to say and this was called resistance. Freud tried to combat this resistance through Dream Analysis, where he would disect the meaning of the items in dreams. He eventually abandoned his seduction hypothesis and developed the thoeries of sexual events in infancy and childhood, bringing about his famous "Oedipal Complex."
Along with the story of Anna O. Breuer used a method of Cartharsis to try to help cure her of hysteria. This method tries to trace symptoms back to their first appearance and then if the root is found the symptoms would be relieved.
The uniteresting included the Id as the instictive drives of the individual including sex and aggression and the Super Ego on the other end that was made of moral values and constraint of the Id and the ego which serves a balance between the two. All of them appear at different levels of conciousness.
Franz Anton Mesmer found that he could use the power of suggestion to supposedly cure symptoms of hysteria by waving magnets over people to put them in a trance like state. He was kicked out of Vienna and he moved to France putting on shows. This led to hypnosis.
It is important to study the roots of Psychoanalysis to see the thought processes and though alot of what Freud had released has been looked on with a critical eye it brought about clinical psychology and the notions of repression and the levels of conciousness.
Terms: Franz Anton Mesmer, Sigmund Freud, Joseph Breuer, Anna O., Hypnosis, Id, Ego, Superego, Oedipus Complex, Transference, Resistance, Free Association, Hysteria, Dream Analysis, Repression, Catharsis, Seduction Hypothesis
I found the early treatment of the mentally ill to be very interesting. I actually wish they had gone into more detail on the subject. One of the first people to reform the way mentally ill were treated was Phillipe Pinel. He brought change to the asylums around Paris, France. He used rewards and punishments to treat the patients and worked to bring them better living conditions with better nutrition and hygiene. These were all tied in with the Enlightenment that was going on at the time. Tuke was also a reformist from England who established the use of retreats, that treated the mentally ill more benevolently and felt less like prisons. Benjamin Rush started the use of bloodletting as a cure. At the time, it was thought that many illnesses were related to the blood, and taking some of the bad blood out or mixing it up and rebalancing it could cure somebody of mental or physical illnesses. Dorothea Dix worked very hard to reform asylums across the United States. She visited several of them and wrote an expose about them to get laws passed to improve upon the asylums.
Another topic of interest for me was mesmerism and hypnosis. One thing that is most interesting is that we derived the word mesmerized from Franz Anton Mesmer’s last night and the work that he did. He used magnets to cure people because he believed in the idea that magnetic powers had a strong effect on humans and their health. His patients would eventually enter into what he called a “crisis state” and when they would come out of it they would be cured. He called this theory animal magnetism. Even after his death, mesmerism continued to spread and eventually was turned into hypnotism by Braid.
I found Freud to be of little interest, mainly because he seemed to be very full of himself, and his theories seem to be ridiculous with no proof to back them up. Even from a young age he thought he was going to be something great, as he said in a letter to his wife. He burned all of his notes, just so no one could have any idea as to where his theories came from and people who would author his biographies in the future would have a tougher time. He hated anybody who opposed him in any sort of way. If someone did oppose psychoanalysis, it would be blamed on some kind of complex they had. He did help to start the idea that events of childhood can have a big impact on the personality and motives of an adult. He also helped to popularize the unconscious.
I think it is important to know some of the ideas that make up Freud’s theory, just because so much emphasis is put on him in psychology. He put a strong emphasis on sex and thought that that was the main motive for the things we do, from infancy to adulthood. He split up the personality into three different things, the id, ego, and superego. The id was the things that a person instinctively wants to do and is only worried about being satisfied. The superego is the part of the personality that is morally based, and therefore is trying to stop the instincts that a person wants to do. The ego is the middle ground that tries to balance these issues and conflicts always going on in a person. Conflict can cause three kinds of anxiety. Objective anxiety is a real danger from the outside world that we try to stop. Neurotic anxiety happens when one is concerned that their id impulses will go out of control. Moral anxiety happens when someone’s morals cause them to feel guilt if they violate their moral code.
Freud is related to Hall because Hall invited him to give a speech and receive an honorary degree from Clark University. This invitation helped to spread psychoanalysis to America. Freud also earned his degree at a time when the mechanist zeitgeist, when it was believed that all things could be identified through scientific means. Also Charcot, who studied hysteria, taught Alfred Binet, from the intelligence testing area, about hypnosis.
Terms bloodletting, retreats, mesmerism, hypnosis, crisis state, animal magnetism, the unconscious, id, ego, superego, objective anxiety, neurotic anxiety, moral anxiety
One thing that I found to be interesting from the early days of dealing with mental illnesses was bloodletting. Bloodletting is when the diseased or extra blood is removed from the body; this was used to “cure” a wide range of illnesses. Benjamin Rush believed that mental illnesses came from hypertension of blood vessels in the brain so he believed that by opening the vessels and letting out the bad blood until they became more tranquil would cure them of their illness. Today we can see just how ludicrous this idea is, but at the time, before they knew better, this would have been a logical thought. Another interesting topic is the work of Dorothea Dix. Dix was an early pioneer and crusader improvements in the care of the mentally ill. Her research of state jails, hospitals, etc showed her that there was a high amount of abuse and neglect and that the people here were being treated worse than animals! I always knew that people were not treated as they should have been, but reading how they were chained to walls in unheated rooms no bigger than closets that were filled with their own waste, poorly fed and clothed, badly beaten, and abandoned makes it even more upsetting. I can only hope that if I had seen what Dorothea Dix had seen I would have become a crusader for these people as well! I think that the least interesting part of this chapter was the information about Freud because, even though it is important, it has been repeated so much. Every psychology class, along with every development class, I have taken over the years has talked about him so it was information that I’ve already heard. Some things that are important aspects would be Freud’s idea of free association. Free association is when patients are put in a comfortable setting and encouraged to say whatever they want to say – I believe that this has influenced how counseling is done now. Also, I think that looking at the early treatment of the mentally ill shows us that while we may not understand those with mental illnesses as well as we could/should, we could be a lot worse. The id, ego, and superego also influence our understanding. The id is the part of us that controls our desires, the ego is the center of our personality, and the superego is our moral compass. Understanding these and where Freud was coming from when he came up with these ideas helps us to understand some of that history.
Terms: bloodletting, Benjamin Rush, Dorothea Dix, Freud, free association, id, ego, superego
I thought the French physician phillipe pinel was a very influential and important person in this chapter. He was the first to bring about reform in mental asylums in the 1700s. he referred to his reforms as “traitement moral” or moral treatment, some of the improvements included patient nutritient, better hygiene and living conditions and even used reinforcement and punishment as ways of changing and modifying behavior.
I thought the idea of hypnotism wasn’t actually all that interesting—probably because it wasn’t explained very well, and I’ve never been a big believer in it anyway. Braid discovered this phenomenon by realizing that people could be put into a trance after fixedly staring at an object that was above their line of vision. Evidently, he reported that many of his subjects remembered and could report memories from hypnotic trance to the next one without having an conscious recollection of it when they emerged from the trance.
I thought bloodletting to be an interesting concept from the chapter. Benjamin Rush, in America was a big promotor of this treatment for the mentally ill. They used it as a “cure” for a wide range of illnesses—Rush believed mental illness stemmed from “hypertension in the brain’s blood vessles” so they would open the veins and remove blood until the person became more tranquil. This ended up working well to calm the patients who were violent, but only because after removing so much blood the patient was too weak to behave in such ways. He also created two more devices—one was the gyrator which was a large revolving board that a patient was sun rapidly on to “redistribute blood toward the head”, and the “tranquilizer” which was a chair with hand, arms, and leg straps which eliminated the patients movemement and reduced the pulse rate.
Dorthea dix was also an influential name in the history of psychology and reforming mental asylums. She traveled the country over 18 months and vistited tons of mental hospitals and realized how cruel the patients were being treated. She wrote down her observations and assisted in the improvement of the the living conditions of those mental patients.
Franz Anton Mesmer’s theories were very interesting as well. He believed that magnetic powers affected humans directly and that good health was the consequence of properly aligned internal magnetic forces.—bad health resulted in the disharmony of forces opposing eachother. He then decided that by giving his patients large amounts of iron and then passing magnets over their bodies, they would fall into a trance and then once they emerged their health would be improved. He called this theory “animal magnetism” and it was one of the first attempts at hypnotism as well.
In addition, even though I’ve learned about freud so many times, I always find his psychoanalysis to be interesting and important to psychology. There was Free association, where he had a patient sit on a couch and relax, then talk about whatever came to their mind. He was also the father of dream analysis, with the theory that our unconscious desires lied within our dreams, and often said that our dreams were the “royal road” to our unconscious.
terms: freud, dream analysis, free association, Mesmer, dorthea dix, hypnotism
The things that I found to be the most interesting in this chapter were the types of treatment for mental illness. Pinel was the first to have a moral treatment of patients by letting them out of their restraints which allowed them to become better nourished, improve hygiene, and general living conditions and using a rewards and punishment system to bring order to their lives. Tuke allowed patients who behaved better more freedom in the institution and they were given more opportunities to do recreation and work, he also had a reward and punishment system like Pinel. Rush took a scientific approach to mental illness. He became the father of modern psychiatry and became the promoter of bloodletting. He also created the gyrator and the tranquilizer to calm patients. Itard specialized in the deaf and curing the "incurable idiot." I found these to be interesting because it shows you how much modern medicine has progressed. I'm also partial to learning about mental illnesses because my mom is a nurse who specializes in those who are mentally ill so I have grown up around talk of mentally ill patients. The apple doesn't fall far from the tree does it? In this chapter I didn't find anything to be all that uninteresting. I enjoyed the chapter a lot actually. Functionalism seems to be another topic that is related to this chapter from previous chapters. And Freud, we can't forget Freud, he manages to always make an appearance since he is the father of psychology after all.
Terms: Freud, Functionalism, Pinel, Moral Treatment, Tuke, Bloodletting, Rush, Itard
The area on Mesmerism (Early version of hypnotism, associated with Mesmer; held that hysteria and other disorders could be cured through the use of magnets) and Hypnosis is interesting to even imagine. We know that hypnotism involves mental control between two parties, but when I heard it was used to try and cure mental illnesses I was immediately focused in.
Mesmerism began to spread throughout Europe more as a form of entertainment before medical treatment. Very few doctors paid close attention to these demonstrations except one, Professor John Elliot. He was astounded by how the patients under hypnosis showed no signs of pain (being poked with sharp needles for example). But hospitals denied any use of Mesmerism on there patients. Later on down the line in the 1840's, physicians started using mesmerism on their patients during amputations. James Esdaile performed mesmerism in several hundred surgeries (before chemical anesthetics were invented) and reported a mortality rate of less than 5 percent (normally 40 percent). From this point on Mesmerism became more popular.
To imagine hypnosis being used during surgeries to reduce or completely eliminate pain is wild when you look at what hypnosis is used for in today's world.
I also found the Psychoanalytic theory to be interesting. Freud was in the process of developing his own theory known as metapsychology - Theory of human behavior and mental processes. He believed that destructive tendencies were just as powerful as sexual ones in motivating behavior. After experiencing his daughter, grandson, and niece die and then discovering he had cancer of the mouth because he smoked 20 cigarettes each day, for him this confirmed that death instincts go hand in hand with life instincts.
I enjoyed most of this chapter because I felt the history of mental illness and how it was treated and improved was interesting. Phillipe Pinel was from France and removed chains for people who had been restrained, in some cases for years. He also was an advocate for moral treatment, or improvements in patient nutrition, hygiene, and general living conditions. To do this he used early behavior modification. Which was also used by William Tuke, this method became a model for America.
Benjamin Rush is considered the father of modern psychiatry. He believed illnesses were derived from problems with the blood, which meant that he was an avid promoter of bloodletting. He also believed mental problems stemmed from hypertension in the brain’s blood vessels. He invented two devices for calming the blood. The first was the Gyrator, which was comprised of a revolving board on which the patient is spun rapidly in order to redistribute blood to the head. The second was the Tranquilizer which was a chair with straps and a box like device that fits over the head, eliminating movement and lowering blood pressure.
Although a number of private asylums were founded in the new reform spirit, they were reserved for the rich. Dorthea dix toured Massachusetts and wrote a huge tell-all article in which she described the horrible conditions she saw. This was brought to the attention of the Massachusetts state legislature and was addressed; she did this for every state except North Caroline, Florida and Texas.
Mildly uninteresting was learning about jean Itard who raised the “Wild boy of Aveyron” but only because I learned this in my Child and Adolescent Psychopathology already so I knew that Itard took this boy and had him pronounced an incurable idiot by Pinel and decided he would be able to teach him. However he failed.
Also uninteresting was learning about Clifford Beers who started the Mental Hygiene Movement. This operated o the idea that illnesses were incurable and preventable.
Really super uninteresting was learning bout mesmerism and hypnosis. Franz Anton Mesmer was a crazy who felt that magnetic forces affected human directly and that good health was a consequence of properly aligned forces. He developed the concept of animal magnetism which was giving psychology patients heavy doses of iron and passing magnet over their bodies to cure them. This was interesting because it introduced the power of suggestion, and lead to Mesmer thinking he was a magnet himself. When he was forbidden to practice medicine in Vienna anymore he moved on and created the Group Therapy which is when people would gather around and hold hands and swoon. This was called mesmerism.
James Esdaile used mesmerism for surgeries which resulted in lower mortality which is actually kind of interesting.
James Braid came up with neuryphology which is nervous sleep and hypnotism. It involves the general fixation of attention and the power of suggestion. He found that people would remember things from one hypnosis to another but not while they were awake.
What was important to learning about the history of psychology was learning about Jean-Martin Charcot who was an expert in hysteria: this was an illness that included a wide range of symptoms characterizing neurological malfunction. Hysteria is how Freud got started and I think that the section about him was most important in learning about the history of psychology.
Second then, is the section on Freud. He was started with Joseph Breuer in the Anna O. case. Anna O. aka Berth Pappenheim had a wide array of symptoms of hysteria. Breuer used catharsis: which was tracing the symptom back to its beginning in order to experience emotional release. This was important to Freud for three reasons. He felt that it showed the traumatic events were suppressed and made unconscious. He also felt that symptoms have a direct relationship to their even and that insight into the original event alleviates the symptom. He also felt that there was an undercurrent of sexuality, and that Anna was unusually attached to her father and at the end of treatment she was attached to Breuer. He called this switch of attention Transference and considered it an important step.
Freud developed many ideas, which were important to the history of psychology because of their strong impact and influence. They were
Free association: this is when the patient relaxes and says anything that comes to mind. It was usually met with resistance which is their unwillingness or inability to mention things.
Dream Analysis which was an additional way to explore the unconscious.
Seduction Hypothesis was the idea that hysteria is a result of childhood sexual abuse. And because it is not understood it was buried in the subconscious. Freud later decided that sexuality was developed in infancy.
Metapsychology: general theory of human behavior and mental processes. He believed that destructive tendencies were just as strong as sexual ones. The believed that human behavior was jointly motivated by Eros or life instincts and thantos, or death instincts.
Of course there is the id, ego and super ego.
The ego is the conscious and unconscious center of personality. It tries to balance between the id, superego and reality, or the environmental factors.
The id is the home of instinctive drives, and demands to be satisfied constantly.
The superego is the home of learned normal values.
Freud felt that there were three kinds of anxieties that could happen to a person anxiety is an attack on the superego. The first is objective anxiety which is the realistic anxiety, and is a normal reaction to perceived threats from the real world, based on memories.
Neurotic anxiety is fear that the id based impulses will take control
Moral anxiety is feelings of guilt and shame that arise from breaking the superego’s moral code.
Since anxiety is the attack on the superego there were internal responses called defense mechanisms. The first is repression which is the unconscious ego, forcing unwanted impulses from awareness. The next is projection which is when personal faults are attributed to others. The last is sublimination which channels instinctive urges into activities that have social value.
Freud started the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society, which Alfred Adler was a part of. In this society people either worshiped or disliked Freud. Adler originally was a fan but he and Freud had a huge falling out, after which he came up with the Inferiority Complex which said that infants are inferior and life attempts to compensate. He also came up with Individual Psychology.
Carl Jung was another who got close to Freud in a father-son way. They also had a falling out when Jung came up with analytical psychology which was composed of the ‘personal’ unconscious and the collective unconscious which was the collective use of experience from ancestors.
Terms used: analytical psychology, collective unconscious, individual psychology, inferiority complex, sublimination, repression, projection, defense mechanisms, neurotic anxiety, moral anxiety, objective anxiety, id, superego, ego, thantos, Eros, metapsychology, seduction hypothesis, dream analysis, moral treatment, gyrator, tranquilizer, Mental Hygiene Movement Group Therapy, Mesmerism, neuryphologoly, hysteria, hypnosis, Anna O. Case, Transference, free association, resistance
What was the most interesting part of this chapter…hmm? Well let us see now; there was Freud’s psychoanalysis which was of some interest and then there was Mesmer and all he had to offer animal magnetism. There is so much to cover; where do I even begin! Well, good ol’ Franz Anton Mesmer was the founder of animal magnetism which was a type of therapy he offered individuals. He would give them some medicine containing heavy doses of iron and then he would pass magnets over their bodies and then people would fall into a ‘crisis state’ or a trance and when they woke up they would feel better. By doing all of this Mesmer quite accidently discovered hypnosis or at least the power of suggestion. Eventually Mesmer was run out of town because of his unique treatments, eventually called Mesmerism, because he was quite the womanizer in a very seductive setting. After Mesmer died along came the science of neurypnology, which means ‘nervous sleep’ which eventually became known as hypnotism. Hypnotism was used primarily used to cure various types of hysteria, which is a disorder that had many symptoms with no apparent nervous system damage ranging from partial seizures to nervous tics and even memory lapses. There was never a whole lot of evidence supporting this treatment but individuals still believed in its ‘magical’ powers and continue using it.
The next important and interesting individual to take a look at is Sigmund Freud. While going through his education Freud became a close contact of Joseph Breuer who had his famous Anna O. case. This case involved a woman who had severe and unexplainable symptoms of hysteria including seizures, sensory blocks, weird eating behaviors, and losing the ability to speak German while holding onto English. Breuer’s semi-successful cure for her was what he called catharsis, which entailed tracing a symptom to the occasion to when it first occurred. This would cause the patient a sense of emotional release just from this experience, which in turn provided some temporary relief. Once Freud was off on his own he hit the ground running. He eventually came up with the field of psychoanalysis, which was a field of therapy that sought to dig deep into an individuals’ subconscious to find problems. Freud had developed various theories to explain whatever he thought he discovered in the subconscious. Some ways that he sought to explore the subconscious was through free association, the uncensored thoughts of the patients spoken aloud, dream analysis, looking at dreams to explore what was not fully conscious, and word association, giving patients a prepared list of words and asking them to respond to each word with the first word that came to mind. Whenever Freud ran into a problem he would label it as resistance which meant that the individual was unable or unwilling to mention something that just occurred to them. Freud’s theory put a very heavy emphasis on sex. This can first be seen in his work with Breuer and the Anna O. case in which he suggested transference or the transferring of intense, strong feelings from one individual to another, sometimes sexual; in this case it was from Anna’s father to Breuer. Freud formulated a seduction hypothesis, in which he argued that hysteria was the result of childhood sexual abuse by a parent or other adult. This idea was not received well by the scientific community at large. He later changed his idea to the sexual situations were imagined rather than the result of actual physical/sexual abuse. Freud came back big with his revised edition calling it Metapsychology, which was his general theory of human behavior and mental processes. It is here that he formulated the eros, life instinct, and thanatos, death instinct. These two motivated us by life enhancing and life destroying instincts and these instincts are constantly acting on our lives. Another part of Freud’s work was the invention of the id, superego and the ego. The id was fueled by instinctive drives of sex and aggression with an insatiable appetite to be fed. The superego is a person’s learned moral values and works to inhibit the free expression that the id craves. The ego then is left as the middle man balancing these two instincts. With these established Freud named imbalances in these as specific disorders. His baseline for all of this was objective anxiety which is a normal reaction to a perceived threat from our environment. Imbalances of the superego and id resulted in neurotic anxiety, when a person fears that id-based impulses will get out of control and moral anxiety, when a person feels guilt and shame from a sense that one is about to violate the strict moral code of the superego. As a result of these imbalances certain actions were developed. These included defense mechanisms such as repression, unwanted impulses that are forced out of our minds, and projection, seeing one’s own faults in others rather than in ourselves. Another defense mechanism was reaction formation which is when unacceptable impulses are repressed and replaced with the opposite ones. Some other interesting findings or theories created by Freud and Carl Jung included inferiority complex, which is when infants view life as an attempt to compensate for their inferiority, and collective unconscious, which is the collective experiences of our ancestors…this sounds particularly stupid to me. All of this was very interesting to take a look at just how some very unique ideas can be widely accepted.
In this chapter, I was a little disappointed that they didn’t spend a whole lot of time discussing the history and treatment of mentally ill. It did discuss it in a little detail but it would have been better to take a deeper look at this so that we could better grasp just how badly the treatment of the mentally ill was. If we better grasp just how bad it once was it will better enable us to realize how much of a sensitive issue it really is and how much care is needed for those with mental illnesses. I thought everything else in this chapter was interesting; it just didn’t cover the treatment of the mentally ill in as much depth as I had hoped.
The first thing that helped me to understand history and systems of psychology better was the fact that Mesmerism first discovered his idea of the power of suggestion. It really is amazing at how much of what is taken for granted today was discovered accidently by scientific means. This was just one example which ultimately led to hypnosis, a semi-useful tool for psychologists now days. The second thing that is helpful is looking at Freud and his tactics for developing his theory of psychoanalysis. Yes, looking back now, he had some pretty funky ideas and he is usually the butt of a lot of jokes. It was interesting to see that when he proposed his initial hyper-sexual theories of the subconscious that he changed it when the scientific community as a whole rejected his thoughts and ideas. At first I thought that he was just being a pussy and wasn’t staying true to his beliefs and theories. When I gave it some more thought I realized that what he did is just the intelligent thing to do when the majority of the scientific community has rejected the work that an individual has done. If he can’t back it up then I would say that it would be the wise thing to do. I think that many could learn from this example. Not to just simply back down when others challenge your ideas, but to use conventional and scientific wisdom and knowledge to back your ideas up. The third and final item was to look at what clinical psychology did for psychology as a whole. In previous chapters other individuals had sought to make psychology a completely recognizable, reputable field of science. Clinical psychology brought along the finishing touches to this and is now the final step and brings everything up to date, as of 2011 that is.
This chapter offered a lot of material that related back to earlier chapters. For one thing psychoanalysis was similar to introspection in quite a few ways. It was dealing with two unobservable events that led to a whole lot of disagreements within the scientific community. How can we prove that we have a subconscious and what it affects? Similarly, introspection was highly criticized for being impossible to prove. I simply believe that there are some aspects of human nature/mind that will be impossible to ever break down into little known pieces. This study of the unconscious built off of many other earlier areas of psychology because it sought to be a strictly measurable/observable science. These earlier areas of science included the behaviorists, functionalists, and experimental psychology. Earlier chapters also mentioned some of the treatments that were applied to the mentally ill, but this chapter emphasized it much more than it had been. These are just some of the areas in which this all applied to earlier chapters.
Terms-bloodletting, Dorthea Dix, Dementia praecox, animal magnetism, neurypnology, hypnotism, hysteria, Anna O. case, catharsis, transference, free association, resistance, dream analysis, seduction hypothesis, displacement, condensation, metapsychology, eros, thanatos, superego, id, objective anxiety, neurotic anxiety, moral anxiety, defence mechanisms, repression, projection, reaction formation, inferiority complex, individual psychology, word association, analytical psychology, collective unconscious, clinical psychology, school psychology, orthogenics
One of the things that i found to be the most interesting in this chapter was the fact that not too long ago the mentally ill were either just left out to survive in the streets or they were basically imprisoned in institutions where they were in rooms bound in chains. What i found interesting about this is that they had up to this point not found some better way to deal with the mentally ill. Another thing that i found to be interesting was that Mesmer had accidentally discovered hypnosis through his experiments on subjects using magnetism, and that he believed himself to have magnetic powers himself.
For this chapter i was unable to find anything that i didn't find to be interesting.
This chapter relates to many of the past chapters because it spans across the same timeframe as many of the other chapters did. One of the biggest similarities is that almost all of the psychologists, while wrong on some things, were great leaders in their fields. Other than that there wasn't very many similarities that I was able to find between this chapter and the other chapters.
I found it to be that most of the chapter was very interesting starting with the early treatment of the mentally ill. Especially when Phillipe Pinel introduced the concept of moral treatment; the tendency to rely exclusively on physical restraint of patients was reduced, and direct efforts were made to improve the behavior of patients. I also found the mesmerism and hypnosis to be very interesting when Franz Anton Mesmer developed a procedure for treating hysteria; based on his belief that the disorder was the result of disturbed magnetic forces within the body. He was able to cure and treat patients by mesmerizing them, an idea where he thought he had magical powers. Tying in it with it, I liked James Braid’s procedure neurypnology; term reflecting Braid’s belief that hypnotism was related to the state of sleep. Based on what Sigmund Freud said about psychoanalysis, the study and treatment of hysteria started to interest him. Hysteria is a disorder characterized by a wide range of symptoms that appeared to indicate neurological malfunction, but without apparent physical damage to the nervous system. Freud would eventually refer to this attachment for the therapist as transference; occurs when the patient develops a strong emotional attachment to the therapist.
The thing that I found the most interesting in chapter 12 was the section was how the mentaly ill were treated early in history. I found this section most interesting because of how we are conditioned today on how to deal with the mentally ill. Early they were thought just to have demons or evil inside them and were just thrown on the streets to basically live like an animal and just survive. Many of them were burned, drowned, or just killed. This is important to note because we have come a LONG way since these times. There were no facilities to help the mentally ill, basically just a place to gather them all up and be able to moniter what they did and keep them in the shadows of the main stream society. This is similar to what we do in a sense today, but not to the extreme with the menally ill. I found it interesting that as like today, the class matters. Mental help and hospitals are very expensive and the poor still today aren't as affluent in understanding that there is help out there versus the hollywood stars that you see being able to hire a shrink or psychologist/psychiatrist to help them on the spot. One thing I did not find interesting about this chapter was the secion on Sigmund Freud and his biography. It was hard to find something in this chapter that was not interesting. I feel like learning what each psychologist did versus where they were born is more interesting than giving a biography. There are many things in the chapter important to the history of psychology but I will pick three. The first is stated above, the treatment before mental illness was really looked into and seen as something that was more than the devils and demons in someone. The second thing that is most important to the history of psychology is how Dorothea Dix and Clifford Beers reformed the places where the mentally ill went. They were able to create more places for the mentally ill to go and to allow for the growing populations in the US to be able to handle the higher numbers of individuals in the facilities. The third thing that was important to the history of psychology is Sigmund Freud and his controbutions to psychoanalysis. He was able to get the patients into comfortable positions and allow for what we picture now as therapy or free association. They were to express their thoughts openly. Many of the patients had resistance, and wouldn't mention everything on their minds. Freud also used dream analysis to explore the patients unconscious.
Some topics that fit in with earlier chapters are psychoanalysis. Another is how Freud discovered that there was more to people than just being mentally ill, as Pavlov found there was framing of people through conditioning. Many of the mentally ill had different conditions they were put in or surrounded by that could have caused their mental illness.
Terms: Sigmund Freud, free association, psychoanalysis, unconscious, Dorothea Dix, Clifford Beers, reform, mentally ill
The history of the mentally ill is a very interesting one to me, mostly because the reasons people believed ‘mental illness’ existed have changed so drastically over time. Some of the earliest beliefs on people who exhibited odd behavior was that they must be possessed by the Devil or some sort of demon, while today there are many factors that we believe cause mental illness, from environment to biological factors.
One idea that remained prominent until fairly recently was that mentally ill people were ‘less than’ and many people believed they didn’t belong in ‘normal’ society. Asylums were said to be created in order to help mentally ill patients get better and to provide them with a better life, but they were run much like prisons, seeking mostly to keep them locked inside and away from society. Conditions in asylums were terrible until a man named Phillip Pinel from France came along and instated a program of ‘moral treatment’ for the patients. He was appalled to see people chained to walls, among other things, and called for the removal of chains and more humane treatment of patients.
Treatment of the mentally ill has gone through as many changes as the views on the causes of mental illness. In the days when it was believed that ‘odd’ behavior was caused by evil spirits, people were literally beat so that their body would no longer be a suitable or desirable home for a demon. When theorists like Benjamin Rush believed that the root cause of mental illness lay in the circulatory system, bloodletting was a common practice believed to release tension and put patients in a tranquil state.
Today, there are numerous medications on the market that help patients to live a happier and more ‘normal’ life, despite their mental illness. While medications are about the only option for certain disorders, there are still many other forms of treatment used today to help mentally ill patients, such as therapy, ECT, etc. Today we even have a manual known as the DSM-IV, which provides diagnostic guidelines for mental health professionals and this ability to diagnose guides them in the best course of action to help their patients.
I found a lot of things very interesting in this chapter. I could not find uninteresting topics so I will just talk about my favorite interesting things.
I really liked reading about the enlightened period. One of the main people I the chapter was French man Phillipe Pinel. This was back when the mentally ill were housed in asylums. Most of them were kept in chains and greatly neglected. He removed all the chains from the people in asylums, which was a very big deal at the time. He did remove the chains however the book states that the chains were replaced with other forms of restraints, which is very sad. It is hard to believe that people were treated that way. What a scary feeling, they had to of been very confused which probably made treatment worse. This was first done at the Bicetre asylum for men and then at the Salpetrere asylum for women. Pinel was named director of the Bicetre asylum for men.
Another man I found interesting in the chapter was Tuke, an Englishman. He actually reserved a piece of land named the “Yorke Retreat” and he housed them there. At the Yorke Retreat he allowed them to work and have more freedoms. The ones that did misbehave were often isolated or restrained none the less. This was a step in the right direction but still inhumane in today’s society. This became a model for treatment for the mentally ill in the 19th century.
Another man named Benjamin Rush developed a treatment plan for the mentally ill called blood letting. They would drain a portion of a person’s blood from them. This would temporarially calm them. This made them too weak to behave badly, and they thought this gave relief temporarially from syptoms. Well they were wrong… it was just highly unhealthy and also.. inhumane. I can’t believe all the horrible things they did to the mentally ill! It makes me very sad, but at the same time they did not know at the time that it was not working. They were just trying to figure out what to do with them. One interesting technique was the gyrator which was a board that they would spin patients on to try to get more blood to their heads. Also the tranquilizor which was a chair that restrained patients so that they could attempt to reduce their pulse rates. How confusing and scary for patients, they probably didn’t understand what was being done to them or why.
I found the Wild Boy of Aveyron to be very very very very interesting! This was a boy that was 12 years old that was discovered abandoned by his parents and left to fend for himself. The boy could not speak any language. Jean Itrad decided to attempt to socialize the boy and eventually he was able to complete chores. The thing I found interesting was he was ever able to use language productively. He did develop the skill of understanding some phrases. This could be thought to contradict Descartes theory of innate ideas. Most believe that language is one of them, but here is a boy that was brought up with no language, and was never able to use language effectively because he was not socialized to do so. This suggests that language may not be innate. However there may have been some metal disability limiting him from this. Also I wonder, could his disability be due to lower stimulation during childhood?
I liked the part in the chapter about Freud, although I have heard most of it before. I especially liked the part talking about psychoanalysis. Free association was the centerpiece for this technique. This was when patients were instructed to free their mind and say whatever came to their heads. He thought resistance to this would help them understand the root of their problems. He also used dream analysis to explore their unconscious. He thought that dreams were the root to what was going on in their heads and would often analyze them. He was very concerned with sexual dilemmas. He developed the theory of the seduction hypothesis. He thought that sexual abuse in childhood could lead to later issues. He claimed that sometimes sexual abuse could be suppressed and eventually lead to hysteria. Freud had very influential theories, but the book notes that sometimes he is glorified too much.
I really liked this chapter and there were many things during this time period that interest me. I think I would like to change my mind from the first blog we did. I would like to have lived during this time period.
TERMS: Gyrator, tranquilizor, Benjamin Rush, Blood Letting, Tuke, York Retreat, Enlightened period, Phillipe Pinel, Salpetrere, Bicretre, asylum, Jean Itrad, The Wild Boy of Aveyron, Freud, Free Association, resistance, seduction hypothesis,
This chapter also makes you think of the advancement in mental illness treatment and what the world would be like if it never happened or got as advanced as it is today. The world could be more violent or graduation rates could be lower because of minor mental illnesses that aren't serious today because of the medicine there is to treat could be more serious and affect learning.
There could be countless issues and difference in the world today without the advancement of mental illness study… which is still constantly advancing to this day year after year.